The SEC’s lawsuit against Ripple Labs over XRP ended on August 7, 2025, when both sides filed a joint stipulation dismissing their cross-appeals in the Second Circuit.1SEC. Litigation Release No. 26369 The dismissal left the district court’s August 2024 final judgment intact: a $125 million civil penalty, a permanent injunction against future securities registration violations, and the 2023 ruling that distinguished between XRP sales that broke the law and those that did not.
How the Case Ended
The ending was messy. In March 2025, Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse announced that the SEC planned to drop its appeal, and by May 8, 2025, the two sides had reached a formal settlement.2SEC. Litigation Release No. 26306 Under the deal, the SEC would keep $50 million of the $125 million penalty Ripple had placed in escrow and return the remaining $75 million, and the parties asked the court to lift the permanent injunction.3CNBC. SEC Will Keep $50 Million of Ripple Fine and Refund the Rest
Judge Analisa Torres, who had handled the case since 2020, refused. She rejected the request twice, finding that the parties had not shown the “exceptional circumstances” needed to undo a final court judgment and calling the proposal “legally flawed and contrary to the public interest.”4DL News. Ripple $50M Settlement Blocked, Judge Says Haven’t Come Close A final judgment, she wrote, belongs “to the legal community as a whole” and cannot be erased because the parties have changed their minds.5Banking Dive. Ripple, SEC Judge Again Denies Settlement Request to Lower Penalty When the parties tried a different procedural route, asking for an “indicative ruling” under Rule 62.1, Torres called that request “procedurally improper” too.6The Block. US Federal Judge Rejects SEC and Ripple’s Request for Indicative Ruling A renewed joint request followed on June 12, 2025.7Business.cch.com. SEC v. Ripple Joint Request
Rather than keep fighting Torres over the penalty, the SEC and Ripple dropped their appeals outright on August 7, 2025.8Yahoo Finance. SEC, Ripple End Appeals, Closing Case The original judgment stayed in place.
What Ripple Paid
The court’s August 2024 final judgment imposed a civil penalty of exactly $125,035,150, which Ripple placed in escrow and said it would pay in cash from its balance sheet.1SEC. Litigation Release No. 263699Banking Dive. Ripple XRP $125 Million Penalty SEC Securities Ruling The May 2025 settlement called for the SEC to keep $50 million and return $75 million, but because Judge Torres never approved the modification, the formal penalty amount was never reduced.2SEC. Litigation Release No. 2630610Reuters. SEC Ends Lawsuit Against Ripple, Company to Pay $125 Million Fine Yahoo Finance reported that the $125 million would be transferred to the U.S. Treasury.8Yahoo Finance. SEC, Ripple End Appeals, Closing Case Whether the escrowed funds were ultimately split as the settlement proposed is not entirely clear from the public record.
Torres had already handed Ripple significant wins on the money question in her August 2024 judgment. She rejected the SEC’s requests for $876 million in disgorgement and $198 million in prejudgment interest, finding no proof of investor financial harm, and set the civil penalty based on 1,278 individual violations rather than the far larger figures the SEC sought. She declined to waive the “bad actor disqualification,” barring Ripple from using the Regulation D exemption for five years.11Justia. SEC v. Ripple Labs, Final Judgment
The 2023 Ruling That Still Stands
The reason this case mattered beyond the dollar amount was Judge Torres’s July 13, 2023, summary judgment ruling. She issued a split decision: some XRP sales were illegal unregistered securities offerings, others were not, and XRP as a digital token is not “in and of itself” a security. What matters, she wrote, is the circumstances of each transaction.12U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y. SEC v. Ripple Labs, Order on Summary Judgment
Ripple’s direct sales to institutional investors, executed through written contracts with lockup provisions and resale restrictions, qualified as unregistered securities offerings under the Supreme Court’s Howey test. Those buyers knew they were buying from Ripple and could reasonably expect to profit from Ripple’s efforts to increase XRP’s value.
Ripple’s “programmatic sales,” where XRP moved through trading algorithms on exchanges, came out differently. Those were anonymous transactions where buyers had no way of knowing whether they were purchasing from Ripple or someone else. Torres ruled the blind transactions did not meet the Howey test because the purchasers could not have been motivated by an expectation of profits tied specifically to Ripple’s efforts.12U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y. SEC v. Ripple Labs, Order on Summary Judgment Employee compensation and grants paid in XRP also escaped the securities label, because recipients did not pay Ripple anything for the tokens and the first prong of Howey was therefore not met.
Because the parties dropped their appeals, the Second Circuit never reviewed any of this. The Torres ruling remains a district court opinion with persuasive but not binding authority. Other judges in the same Manhattan courthouse took a different view in parallel crypto cases. Judge Jed Rakoff, in the Terraform Labs case, rejected the idea that sales could be treated differently based on whether the buyer bought from the issuer directly or on an exchange, and Judge Katherine Failla followed that approach in the SEC’s case against Coinbase.13Katten. Crypto in the Courts: Five Cases Reshaping Digital Asset Regulation The Second Circuit was expected to resolve the split through the Ripple and Coinbase appeals; instead, both sets of appeals were dismissed in 2025.14U.S. Chamber of Commerce. SEC v. Coinbase, Inc.
Why the SEC Walked Away
The reversal reflected a sweeping change at the agency. Gary Gensler, who had led an aggressive crypto enforcement program with 125 actions and $6.05 billion in penalties between 2021 and 2024, stepped down as SEC chair on January 20, 2025.15Georgetown Law. Beyond Enforcement: The SEC’s Shifting Playbook on Crypto Regulation The next day, Acting Chair Mark Uyeda launched a Crypto Task Force under Commissioner Hester Peirce. Within weeks, the SEC dismissed its case against Coinbase, issued guidance declaring meme coins are not securities, and reorganized its crypto enforcement team. Paul Atkins, a former commissioner with professional ties to the crypto industry, was confirmed as permanent chair on April 9, 2025.
Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw dissented when the Ripple settlement was announced. She called it a “tremendous disservice to the investing public,” argued the deal “erases the investor protections we already won,” and warned that if Ripple sold unregistered XRP to institutional investors in defiance of Torres’s earlier ruling, “this Commission will do absolutely nothing about it.”16SEC. Commissioner Crenshaw Statement on Ripple Settlement She said the agency was “gut[ting] its own enforcement program from the inside out.”17National Law Journal. SEC Commissioner: Ripple Settlement Shows Regulator at War With Itself
The SEC had also dropped its claims against Garlinghouse and co-founder Chris Larsen individually back in October 2023, after the court denied the SEC’s motion for summary judgment on the aiding-and-abetting charges and refused to certify an interlocutory appeal.5Banking Dive. Ripple, SEC Judge Again Denies Settlement Request to Lower Penalty18SEC. SEC Files Action Against Ripple Labs19SEC. SEC Complaint, SEC v. Ripple Labs
What It Means Going Forward
The permanent injunction barring Ripple from future Section 5 violations technically remains in force. In her August 2024 judgment, Torres noted Ripple was still selling XRP to institutional buyers through its “on-demand liquidity” product and warned that the company’s “willingness to push the boundaries” suggested a likelihood of future violations.11Justia. SEC v. Ripple Labs, Final Judgment As Crenshaw’s dissent noted, the current SEC leadership has signaled it will not pursue enforcement against those sales.16SEC. Commissioner Crenshaw Statement on Ripple Settlement
The regulatory posture around XRP itself has also shifted. In March 2026, the SEC and CFTC jointly classified XRP as a commodity, which further reduces the likelihood of future treatment as a security.20Yahoo Finance. RLUSD Just Crossed $1.6B The Torres framework distinguishing institutional from programmatic sales continues to be cited in related disputes, including a suit by CFTC-registered Bitnomial Exchange arguing that its XRP futures are not “security futures” because XRP itself is not inherently an investment contract.21Bitnomial. Bitnomial SEC Complaint Whether the manner-of-sale distinction holds up as crypto law develops through legislation or future appellate decisions is still unresolved.