Both terms refer to the same program, but if you’re deciding between “workman’s comp” or “workers’ comp,” the modern, correct form is workers’ compensation (plural possessive, apostrophe after the s). “Workman’s comp” and “workmen’s compensation” are older versions of the same concept. You’ll still hear them in conversation and even find them preserved in a few federal statutes, but state agencies, insurers, and claim forms use the modern phrasing.
Why the Term Changed
Early labor laws in the United States used “workmen’s compensation” because the workforce they protected was overwhelmingly male and industrial. As women entered more sectors of the economy through the mid-to-late 20th century, legislatures and agencies began swapping “workmen’s” for the gender-neutral “workers’.” Most states have since updated their statutes, agency names, and official forms to match.
The update wasn’t universal. Federal tax law still uses the old language. The Internal Revenue Code excludes from taxation “amounts received under workmen’s compensation acts as compensation for personal injuries or sickness,” preserving the original 1954 phrasing word for word.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 104 – Compensation for Injuries or Sickness A handful of state constitutions also retain the older term, because amending a constitution takes more political effort than renaming an agency. The legal protections and requirements are identical regardless of which version appears in a given statute.
The Apostrophe Actually Matters
In professional and legal writing, “workers’ compensation” uses the plural possessive because the system belongs to the entire workforce, not a single person. Writing “worker’s compensation” with the apostrophe before the s implies a benefit for one individual, which misrepresents how the program works. Insurance carriers, HR departments, and state agencies overwhelmingly use the plural form in policy documents, contracts, and claim forms.
So the hierarchy, from most correct to least, looks like this:
- Workers’ compensation — the modern standard. Use this in any formal writing, paperwork, or professional context.
- Workers’ comp — the acceptable shortened version for everyday use. Still plural possessive.
- Workmen’s compensation — historically correct and still legally valid where it appears in older statutes, but dated.
- Workman’s comp — colloquial and outdated. Common in speech, rare in writing.
- Worker’s compensation — grammatically off. The possessive should be plural.
When Each Term Shows Up
Colloquial speech is less precise than paperwork. Employees commonly tell a doctor they’re “filing for workman’s comp,” yet the actual First Report of Injury form at the state agency will read “workers’ compensation.” Insurance adjusters process claims using the modern term to stay consistent with reporting software and regulatory filings. When you’re talking casually, nobody will correct you. When you’re filling out paperwork, use the plural possessive.
Expect to see the older phrasing in a few specific places:
- Federal tax code sections written decades ago and never revised.
- Older state constitutional provisions.
- Long-standing insurance policy language that references historical statutes.
- Casual conversation, especially among workers in trades where the older term stuck.
None of this changes the underlying program. A claim filed under a statute that says “workmen’s compensation” delivers the same benefits as a claim filed under a statute that says “workers’ compensation.”
What the Program Does, Regardless of Name
Workers’ compensation is employer-funded insurance covering job-related injuries and illnesses. Employers carry the policy, and injured employees receive benefits without having to prove anyone was at fault. The system generally provides three categories of benefits, with specifics varying by state:
- Medical treatment: Doctor visits, surgery, hospital stays, prescriptions, and physical therapy related to the work injury. You typically don’t pay copays or deductibles.
- Wage replacement: A portion of your lost income while you’re unable to work. Most states set this at roughly two-thirds of pre-injury wages, subject to a weekly cap.
- Vocational rehabilitation: If your injury prevents a return to your previous job, many states offer retraining, education assistance, or placement services.
Some states also provide specific payments for permanent impairment ratings (like losing a finger or suffering permanent hearing loss) and death benefits for surviving family members when a workplace injury is fatal.
In exchange for these no-fault benefits, employees generally give up the right to sue their employer for the injury. This is the exclusive remedy doctrine, and it’s the foundation of every state’s system. Workers get guaranteed medical care and income without the cost and uncertainty of a lawsuit. Employers get protection from potentially large jury verdicts. You can still sue third parties who contributed to the injury, such as a defective equipment manufacturer, but your employer is generally shielded.
Federal Programs Use the Same Pattern
Federal civilian employees don’t go through state systems. They’re covered by the Federal Employees’ Compensation Act, administered by the Department of Labor’s Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs. FECA pays a disabled federal employee two-thirds of regular monthly salary for total disability, or three-fourths for employees with dependents.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 5 USC 8105 – Total Disability Maritime workers fall under the Longshore and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act, which covers longshoremen, harbor workers, ship repairers, and shipbuilders.3U.S. Department of Labor. Longshore and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act, 33 USC 901-950 Both federal programs use the modern “workers'” phrasing in their official names, even though the tax code section exempting their benefits still reads “workmen’s.”
The Short Answer
If someone asks whether it’s workman’s comp or workers’ comp, the writing-and-paperwork answer is workers’ comp, with the apostrophe after the s. The speaking-casually answer is that both terms communicate the same idea and nobody will misunderstand you. The legal answer is that the terminology doesn’t change what you’re entitled to. What matters is reporting the injury to your employer promptly, filing a formal claim with your state agency within the statute of limitations, and keeping records of your medical treatment and lost wages. The name on the form is cosmetic. The deadlines on the form are not.