Will My Insurance Rates Go Up If I File a Claim?

Yes, your insurance rates will probably go up if you file a claim, but how much depends on who was at fault, what kind of claim it is, and how your history looks before the loss. A single at-fault auto accident raises the average driver’s full-coverage premium from around $2,700 to roughly $3,850 a year, about a 43 percent jump that typically lasts three to five years. A not-at-fault claim, a comprehensive claim for hail or theft, or a first homeowners claim often costs far less, and sometimes nothing.

Fault Is the Biggest Lever

Whether you caused the accident matters more than any other factor. When an adjuster concludes you were at fault, your policy gets flagged as higher risk and a surcharge appears at your next renewal. Adjusters build that conclusion from the police report, witness statements, and each driver’s account.

If you share blame, most states use comparative negligence to assign each driver a percentage. Cross the 50 or 51 percent threshold in many of those states and you lose the ability to recover from the other driver’s insurer, which puts you in the at-fault column for rating purposes.

Not-at-fault claims land differently. A majority of states have regulations that prevent insurers from raising your rate solely because someone else hit you. A police report or witness statement confirming the other driver’s fault should keep the claim off your rated history. Protections vary by state, so check your state’s rules. Even where the law is silent, many insurers voluntarily hold rates steady on not-at-fault claims.

How Much Auto Rates Typically Rise and for How Long

The size of the increase tracks three things: how big the payout was, what your record looked like before, and where you live. The industry average is roughly 43 percent after one at-fault accident. Drivers with otherwise clean records sometimes see closer to 20 percent; those with prior incidents or expensive claims can face surcharges above 80 percent.

Payout size matters. A small fender bender moves the needle less than a multi-vehicle crash with injuries and legal costs. Insurers use tiered rating, and a total-loss claim sits at the top.

The surcharge usually sticks for three to five years from the date of the accident. Serious offenses like DUI-related crashes can affect your driving record and your premium for a decade or longer. After the surcharge period ends, your rate should drift back toward normal if you don’t file again.

Insurers also look beyond the current claim. They pull your Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange (CLUE) report, which tracks up to seven years of auto and home claims across all carriers.1Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. LexisNexis C.L.U.E. and Telematics OnDemand One claim on an otherwise clean seven-year record reads very differently from a third claim in two years. File often enough and a carrier may decline to renew. You’re entitled to one free CLUE report every 12 months, and pulling it before you shop lets you dispute errors before they cost you.

Collision Claims vs. Comprehensive Claims

The coverage that pays the claim changes how your insurer weighs it. Collision claims cover accidents where your vehicle hits another car, a guardrail, a tree, or any other object. Insurers treat these as preventable, and they carry the heaviest rating impact because they reflect driving behavior.

Comprehensive claims cover losses outside your control: hail, theft, vandalism, fire, a deer in the road. A single comprehensive claim produces a much smaller rate increase than a collision claim of the same size, and many insurers won’t raise your rate at all for an isolated comprehensive loss.

Windshield and glass claims are the gentlest category. A handful of states require insurers to waive your deductible for windshield replacement when you carry comprehensive coverage, so you pay nothing and the rating impact is minimal. Even without that rule, a first glass claim in years rarely moves your premium. Several glass claims in a short span is a different story.

Homeowners and Renters Claims Work Differently

Home claims follow similar logic with gentler numbers in some places and harsher ones in others. A single home insurance claim raises premiums an average of 5 to 6 percent. Liability and wind claims tend to land around 5 percent; theft and fire claims push closer to 6 percent.

Frequency is where home insurance gets punishing. Two or three claims within five years can lead to non-renewal, which is worse than a surcharge because it forces you into the surplus-lines market where coverage costs more and is harder to find. Water damage and liability claims hurt the most, because insurers see them as likely to recur. A single weather-related claim in a storm-prone area is treated more leniently, since neighbors probably filed too.

Home claims also appear on your CLUE report for up to seven years, so a history of frequent filing follows you to the next carrier.1Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. LexisNexis C.L.U.E. and Telematics OnDemand

When Paying Out of Pocket Is Cheaper

Not every loss is worth filing over. Compare the repair cost to the total cost of filing, which is your deductible plus the extra premium you’ll pay over three to five years of surcharges.

Here’s the arithmetic. Your deductible is $1,000 and a fender repair runs $1,400. Filing saves you $400 today. If your premium then rises $30 a month for three years, you’ve paid an extra $1,080 in surcharges, for a net loss of $680. A reasonable rule of thumb: unless the damage substantially exceeds your deductible and the repair runs above $4,000 or $5,000, run the numbers before you file. For small claims, paying out of pocket almost always comes out ahead.

Get repair estimates before you call your insurer, because the call itself can create problems.

The Inquiry That Becomes a Claim

Calling your insurer to ask about a potential claim can sometimes be recorded as an actual claim. An inquiry is a general question about your coverage. A claim is a report of a specific loss. Not every insurer draws that line the same way, and some treat any call about an actual incident as a reportable event.

If the call gets logged as a claim, it can show up on your CLUE report even if the insurer pays nothing. That phantom claim is visible to any insurer you shop with later, and it can cost you a claims-free discount you spent years earning. Most carriers have been instructed not to report pure coverage inquiries, but be explicit if you call: say it’s a hypothetical question. Better still, get independent estimates first, do the math, and only call once you’ve decided to file.

Accident Forgiveness

Accident forgiveness prevents your first at-fault accident from triggering a surcharge. Your insurer agrees not to factor the accident into your premium at renewal, which can save you hundreds of dollars a year over the surcharge period.

Eligibility usually requires five years of clean driving. Some insurers sell it as a paid add-on; others grant it automatically as a loyalty reward once you qualify. Terms vary, so read the policy language.

Two limits are worth knowing. Accident forgiveness doesn’t erase the accident from your driving record or your CLUE report, so another insurer can still see it if you switch, and the new carrier isn’t bound by your old one’s forgiveness. And it’s a one-time benefit. A second at-fault accident uses up the protection, and both incidents may be rated going forward.

What to Do If Your Rate Already Went Up

You’re not stuck with the new premium. The most effective move is also the simplest: shop around. Carriers weigh claims history differently, and a rate that doubles at one company might rise only modestly at another. Get quotes from at least three insurers after a claim-related increase. Some offer switching discounts for new customers.

If you think fault was assigned incorrectly, dispute it. Notify your insurer in writing that you disagree, ask about the internal dispute process, and provide any evidence supporting your account: dashcam footage, witness contact information, scene photos. If the fault call rests on a police report you believe is wrong, contact the investigating officer about an addendum or correction. Fighting a traffic ticket tied to the accident can also change the picture, because insurers lean heavily on citations when assigning blame.

If internal appeals go nowhere, every state has an insurance department that accepts consumer complaints, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners maintains a directory with contact information for each one.2NAIC. Insurance Departments Regulators can review whether the insurer followed proper rating procedures and, in some cases, order corrections.