Who Gets Builders Risk Insurance: Owner or Contractor?

Either the property owner or the general contractor can buy builders risk insurance, and the construction contract is what actually decides between them. When the contract is silent, industry-standard forms like AIA A201 default the obligation to the owner. In practice, the answer comes down to who negotiated the obligation, who wants control over the coverage terms, and who the construction lender requires to hold the policy. Premiums typically run between 1% and 5% of the total project value, so getting this wrong is expensive.

Why Either Party Has Standing to Buy It

Builders risk coverage rests on a concept called insurable interest. To take out any property policy, you have to face a real financial loss if the property is damaged. Without that financial stake, an insurer can void the policy or deny a claim after a loss.

Owners clearly have insurable interest. They hold title to the land and they’re paying for the structure going up on it. If a fire guts a half-framed building, the owner loses the value of everything already in the ground.

Contractors clear the same bar. They’re contractually obligated to deliver a finished project, and they’ve put money into labor, materials, and equipment to get there. A tornado that flattens a job site destroys lumber and concrete, and it also wipes out weeks of paid labor the contractor can’t recover without insurance. Both parties face genuine harm if something goes wrong, so both can legitimately hold the policy.

When It Makes Sense for the Owner to Buy It

Owners often prefer to carry the policy themselves for reasons that go beyond control. Holding it directly means the owner picks the insurer, sets the deductible, and chooses coverage limits without relying on the contractor’s judgment. If a dispute erupts mid-project and the contractor walks off the job, the coverage stays in place because it belongs to the owner.

Owners running multiple projects get another advantage: consistency. A single insurance relationship across several developments means uniform terms, potentially lower premiums through volume, and one broker who knows the portfolio. It also keeps the contractor from burying an insurance markup inside the project bid, which happens more often than owners realize.

When It Makes Sense for the Contractor to Buy It

Contractors frequently prefer to handle builders risk as part of their overall risk management. They’re on-site every day, so they’re best positioned to implement the safety measures insurers require and to file claims quickly when materials are stolen or damaged. A contractor with an established commercial insurance relationship can often get faster claims processing than an owner shopping for a one-off policy.

When the contractor carries the policy, the premium is typically rolled into the project bid. That simplifies things for owners who don’t want to deal with insurance logistics, but it also means the owner has less visibility into what’s actually covered. Contractors occasionally select policies with higher deductibles or narrower coverage to keep the bid competitive, which can leave the owner underprotected without realizing it.

What the Construction Contract Should Say

The contract is where this question gets answered. AIA Document A201-2017 assigns the procurement obligation to the owner by default, requiring the owner to purchase and maintain property insurance covering the work in progress for the full duration of construction. Parties can negotiate a different arrangement, but the baseline expectation in AIA contracts puts it on the owner.

Custom contracts can shift this in either direction. Some assign the obligation to the contractor. Others split it, with the owner carrying the main builders risk policy and the contractor required to carry supplemental coverage for equipment and tools. The important thing is that the contract names who buys the policy, what it covers, and what coverage limits are required. A policy should generally be written for the full completed value of the building, including permanent fixtures, not just the work completed to date.

Contracts go sideways when they’re silent on insurance. No clause assigning builders risk means both parties might assume the other one has it handled. That ambiguity alone has sunk projects after a loss, because the gap only becomes visible when someone files a claim and discovers there’s nothing to claim against.

What Happens if Neither Party Buys Coverage

When neither the owner nor the contractor buys builders risk and a covered loss occurs, every dollar of damage comes out of someone’s pocket. A fire that destroys $400,000 of work in progress means rebuilding costs, financing that rebuild without insurance proceeds, absorbing months of project delays, and almost certain disputes over who should have carried the policy.

Most construction lenders require builders risk coverage as a loan condition, so going without often isn’t even an option on financed projects. On smaller jobs, self-funded renovations, or projects where the lender’s requirements slip through the cracks, the absence of coverage creates catastrophic exposure. The owner faces lost equity in the unfinished structure, and the contractor faces the cost of re-performing work already paid for. Both parties end up pointing fingers, and the resulting litigation can stall the project far longer than the original loss did.

Who Else the Policy Protects

Whichever party buys the policy, the coverage typically reaches further than that one named insured. Subcontractors and their own subcontractors are commonly named as additional insureds, which means a plumbing sub whose work accidentally causes a water leak won’t face a separate lawsuit from the insurer to recover claim payments.

That protection works through a mechanism called waiver of subrogation. Under standard AIA contract language, the owner and contractor waive their rights to sue each other, and each other’s subcontractors, for damages covered by the property insurance policy. The insurer steps into the shoes of the insured when it pays a claim, so if the insured has waived the right to sue, the insurer inherits that waiver. This prevents the insurance company from paying a fire claim and then suing the electrician whose wiring caused the fire. Without this waiver, subcontractors would need their own expensive coverage against that kind of third-party recovery action.

Financial institutions holding construction loans are typically listed as loss payees on the policy. That designation routes insurance payouts for major losses to the lender, or jointly to the lender and owner, protecting the lender’s capital in the project. Architects and engineers with on-site interests may also receive coverage, depending on the terms negotiated.

Coverage Limits Worth Knowing Before You Decide

Who buys the policy matters less if nobody reads what it actually covers. A few boundaries catch owners and contractors off guard often enough that they belong in the purchase conversation.

Faulty workmanship is the biggest exclusion. If a framing crew installs a wall incorrectly and it has to be torn out and redone, the policy won’t pay for that rework. The cost of fixing bad work falls on whoever did it. Most policies include a resulting damage exception: if the poorly installed wall causes water intrusion that damages otherwise sound flooring and drywall elsewhere in the building, the collateral damage is typically covered. The distinction is between the defective work itself and what it damages.

Flood and earthquake are not covered under a standard builders risk policy. Both require separate endorsements that add to the premium, and in high-risk zones those endorsements can be expensive or hard to obtain. Renovation projects raise another issue: builders risk covers the new construction work, not the pre-existing structure, unless the policy is specifically endorsed to include it.

A standard policy also covers hard costs only. If a fire sets a project back four months, the owner carries additional loan interest, pays real estate taxes on a property generating no income, and loses the rental or business revenue expected after opening. Soft cost endorsements and delay-in-completion endorsements cover these financial losses, but they typically apply only to the named insured on the endorsement, which is usually the owner. A contractor who wants delay protection for its own lost revenue generally has to negotiate that into the policy or carry separate coverage.

One last timing issue affects whoever ends up buying the policy. Builders risk is temporary, and it ends on triggers like project completion, issuance of a certificate of occupancy, or the building being put to its intended use. The gap between the day builders risk ends and the day a permanent property policy begins is where owners get burned. Coordinating that handoff is part of the job of whoever carries the policy.