Which States Pay More Than They Receive in Federal Taxes?

Only two states currently qualify as donor states in federal taxes: Massachusetts and New Jersey. In federal fiscal year 2023, those were the only states whose residents and businesses paid more to Washington than the federal government spent inside their borders, according to the Rockefeller Institute of Government’s most recent balance of payments analysis.1Rockefeller Institute of Government. New York’s Balance of Payments with the Federal Government (2025) Every other state received at least as much as it contributed, and often considerably more.

New Jersey received $0.88 in federal spending for every dollar paid in federal taxes. Massachusetts received $0.95. No other state came in below the $1.00 break-even line.1Rockefeller Institute of Government. New York’s Balance of Payments with the Federal Government (2025)

How the Balance Is Measured

The return on tax dollar divides total federal spending in a state by total federal taxes collected from that state. Revenue includes individual income tax, payroll taxes for Social Security and Medicare, corporate income tax, and excise taxes. Spending includes direct payments to individuals such as Social Security and Medicare benefits, grants to state and local governments, federal procurement contracts, and salaries for federal employees and military personnel.2Rockefeller Institute of Government. New York’s Balance of Payments with the Federal Government – 2025 Report

One number to keep in mind: the national average return in fiscal year 2023 was $1.32. The federal government spends more than it collects, so most states get back more than a dollar. Coming in below $1.00 is unusual, and it takes a specific economic profile.2Rockefeller Institute of Government. New York’s Balance of Payments with the Federal Government – 2025 Report

Why New Jersey and Massachusetts

Both states share the profile that produces donor status. Dense, high-income populations generate large volumes of individual income tax and payroll tax revenue per capita. Concentrations of corporate headquarters and high-earning professionals in finance, technology, and healthcare push federal tax contributions well above the national average.

Neither state hosts the kind of federal footprint that channels equivalent spending back. There are no massive military installations, no clusters of federal agency headquarters, and no large per-capita distributions from federal land management. Massachusetts also has a relatively young workforce, which means residents pay into Social Security and Medicare at a much higher rate than the state draws in retirement and healthcare benefits.

The States That Used To Be on This List

New York, Connecticut, and California all sit close to the break-even line but landed above it in fiscal year 2023. New York received $1.04 per dollar, Connecticut $1.16, and California $1.02.2Rockefeller Institute of Government. New York’s Balance of Payments with the Federal Government – 2025 Report

New York’s position is misleading on its face. Strip out the tail end of pandemic-era federal spending and the state’s balance of payments falls to negative $23 billion, which would rank it 48th of 50 states.1Rockefeller Institute of Government. New York’s Balance of Payments with the Federal Government (2025) The underlying math still makes New York a heavy contributor; COVID relief pushed it just past break-even. As that spending unwinds, New York is likely to return to the donor column.

California is essentially at break-even. Its economy generates enormous federal tax revenue, but its population size also draws large amounts of federal spending on social programs, military installations, and federally funded research. Connecticut, with one of the highest median household incomes in the country, is pulled above the line by defense procurement contracts and federal insurance payments.

Any list showing five or six donor states is running on older data. In fiscal year 2020, pandemic relief funds through the CARES Act, expanded unemployment benefits, and stimulus payments were large enough that every state in the country became a net recipient for the first time since the Rockefeller Institute began tracking these figures.3Rockefeller Institute of Government. How COVID-19 Shifted the Balance of Payments Between the States and the Federal Government The map is still returning to its longer-run shape.

Where the Money Goes Instead

Federal spending is not designed to mirror federal tax contributions, which is the mechanical reason donor states exist at all. Three channels do most of the redistributing.

Social Security and Medicare payments follow the people who qualify. States with older populations and higher concentrations of retirees pull in far more in direct benefit payments than states with younger workforces. A state full of working-age professionals pays into these programs at a high rate and waits decades to see the spending come back.

Medicaid’s federal match is designed to favor lower-income states. Wealthier states, including New York, California, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and New Jersey, receive the statutory minimum federal match of 50 percent, meaning the state itself pays half of every Medicaid dollar. Mississippi receives a 76.90 percent federal match.4MACPAC. Federal Medical Assistance Percentages and Enhanced Federal Medical Assistance Percentages by State, FYs 2023-2026 That formula directly moves dollars from high-income states to lower-income ones.

Military bases, federal agency offices, and defense contractors tend to cluster in states with lower land costs and favorable political conditions, not in the high-cost northeast. Infrastructure funding under the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act allocates money partly through formulas tied to road miles, bridge conditions, and broadband gaps, and partly through competitive grants based on project need.5U.S. Department of Transportation. Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) Funding Status Newer infrastructure can actually score lower on need, sending fewer dollars back.

Why the Revenue Side Is So Concentrated

The federal income tax is progressive. For tax year 2026, the top marginal rate of 37 percent applies to taxable income above $640,600 for single filers and $768,700 for joint filers.6Internal Revenue Service. IRS Releases Tax Inflation Adjustments for Tax Year 2026, Including Amendments from the One, Big, Beautiful Bill States where a high share of residents earn in the upper brackets contribute far more per person.

Payroll taxes amplify the pattern. The Social Security tax of 6.2 percent applies to earnings up to $184,500 in 2026, a cap that more workers in high-wage states will hit.7Social Security Administration. Contribution and Benefit Base Medicare’s 1.45 percent tax has no wage cap, and an additional 0.9 percent applies to earnings above $200,000.8Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 751, Social Security and Medicare Withholding Rates Corporate headquarters matter too: the federal corporate income tax is a flat 21 percent, and revenue is attributed to the state where the company is based even when it operates nationwide.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 11 – Tax Imposed

The SALT Cap and Donor-State Taxpayers

The state and local tax deduction adds a second layer of pressure on residents of donor states. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 capped the deduction at $10,000, which hit high-tax states hardest. The One, Big, Beautiful Bill raised the cap to $40,000 starting in 2025 and $40,400 for 2026. The deduction phases down for filers with modified adjusted gross income above $505,000 in 2026 and falls back to the $10,000 floor for those earning roughly $606,000 or more.

For a New Jersey household earning $400,000 and paying $25,000 in state income and property taxes, the higher cap recovers some of the extra federal tax bite. A higher-earning household in the same state remains limited to the $10,000 floor, which pushes their effective federal rate up and widens the gap between what they pay and what their state gets back.

What Could Change the List

The balance of payments moves every year. It responds to tax law changes, demographic shifts, military base decisions, disaster spending, and one-time legislation. COVID relief was enough to erase the donor column entirely for a fiscal year. As that money finishes unwinding and the One, Big, Beautiful Bill works through the tax code, the list will shift again.

The direction is predictable. Federal spending formulas for Medicaid, transportation, and social programs direct money by need. High-wage, densely populated states will keep sending in more per capita than they draw back. New York is the most likely near-term addition to the donor list once pandemic funds run out. Barring a major change in how federal spending is allocated, the list will keep being dominated by the same wealthy northeastern and coastal states that generate the most federal tax revenue per resident.