The taper tantrum was a sharp sell-off in U.S. bond markets in mid-2013, set off when Federal Reserve Chair Ben Bernanke suggested the central bank might soon slow the pace of its bond purchases. Yields on 10-year Treasury notes climbed from under 2% to roughly 3% over about four months, mortgage rates jumped, and capital fled emerging markets, pushing several of them into currency crises. The domestic economy absorbed the shock with little visible damage, but the episode permanently changed how the Fed talks about winding down stimulus.
What Set It Off
Going into 2013, the Fed was buying roughly $85 billion a month in Treasuries and agency mortgage-backed securities under its third round of quantitative easing, an open-ended program launched in September 2012.1Federal Reserve. Timeline of Balance Sheet Policies Those purchases held long-term rates down and pushed investors into riskier assets, including emerging-market debt and currencies. A simple carry-trade strategy in emerging-market currencies had returned about 28% cumulatively from late 2008 through April 2013.2Federal Reserve. U.S. Interest Rates and Emerging Market Currencies
On May 22, 2013, Bernanke testified before the Joint Economic Committee. In the Q&A, he said that “if we see continued improvement … in the next few meetings we could take a step down in our pace of purchases.”3Federal Reserve. Testimony on the Economic Outlook The comment landed earlier than markets had priced in.4FRED Blog, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. No Taper Tantrum This Time Bond prices started falling the same day.
The sell-off intensified a month later. At the June 19 FOMC press conference, Bernanke laid out a specific path: moderating purchases later in 2013, continuing reductions through the first half of 2014, and ending them around mid-2014.5Federal Reserve. FOMC Press Conference Transcript, June 19, 2013 He described the shift as “letting up a bit on the gas pedal” rather than hitting the brakes. The 10-year yield jumped 13 basis points on June 19 and another 11 on June 20, and U.S. stocks lost almost 4% over the two days.6J.P. Morgan Chase Institute. Taper Tantrum Report
How Far Yields Moved
Between May 21 and September 5, 2013, nominal 10-year Treasury yields rose from 1.94% to 2.98%, a move of roughly 100 basis points.7Federal Reserve. Taper Tantrum Research Paper Measured from April’s low of 1.70%, the full climb was more than 130 basis points over four months, the largest comparable move in the prior decade.6J.P. Morgan Chase Institute. Taper Tantrum Report By December 2013 the 10-year sat near 3%.4FRED Blog, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. No Taper Tantrum This Time
Rates linked to Treasuries moved with them. Thirty-year fixed mortgage rates, which had averaged 3.35% in early May, hit 3.93% by June 20.8Los Angeles Times. Freddie Mac Mortgage Rates Thirty-year mortgage rates and corporate bond yields each rose by about 100 basis points over the full window.7Federal Reserve. Taper Tantrum Research Paper Bond-market volatility, as measured by the MOVE index, spiked alongside yields. Analysts at the Bank for International Settlements found that the volatility reduced dealer market-making capacity, widened bid-ask spreads, and cut liquidity, amplifying the move beyond what fundamentals alone would explain.9Bank for International Settlements. Working Paper No. 606
Why the U.S. Economy Held Up
U.S. equities took an initial hit. The S&P 500 fell as much as 6% between May 21 and June 24, 2013, then recovered. By year-end 2013 the index was up roughly 11% from its May 21 level, even with yields still elevated.7Federal Reserve. Taper Tantrum Research Paper
The broader economy came through better than expected. Federal Reserve research found no observable drag on aggregate GDP growth or employment, both of which slightly outperformed pre-tantrum forecasts. Inflation was unchanged. The one visible casualty was residential investment, which dipped about 2% between the fourth quarter of 2013 and the first quarter of 2014 before returning to trend.7Federal Reserve. Taper Tantrum Research Paper
Why Emerging Markets Were Hit Hard
The international story was different. As U.S. yields rose, investors pulled money out of emerging markets, reversing years of inflows chasing returns above near-zero American rates.
In an August 2013 note, Morgan Stanley analyst James Lord called the five most exposed economies the “Fragile Five”: Brazil, India, Indonesia, South Africa, and Turkey.10Times of India. Fragile Five Days Long Gone as Funds Pile Into India, Indonesia11Business Insider. Morgan Stanley Fragile 5 Emerging Markets They shared large current account deficits, high inflation, weak growth, and heavy reliance on foreign capital.12Peterson Institute for International Economics. Taper Tantrum Revisited
Dallas Fed research separated emerging markets by “reserve adequacy” (foreign-exchange reserves minus short-term foreign-currency debt and the current account deficit). Between May and September 2013, countries below a 7% threshold saw their currencies drop nearly 15% against the dollar, versus 2% for better-positioned economies. Their corporate bond spreads widened by 120 basis points, versus 40 for the stronger group. To stop capital flight, central banks in the vulnerable countries raised rates by more than 100 basis points by year-end 2013.13Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. Taper Tantrum and Emerging Markets Research Indonesia’s central bank alone hiked by 175 basis points from June onward, and India assembled a $60 billion reserve buffer through gold import restrictions and diaspora investment incentives.14Financial Times. Fragile Five Emerging Markets
How It Ended, and When Tapering Actually Began
By September, primary-dealer surveys put the probability of a taper announcement at the September 17–18 FOMC meeting at 58%.15Federal Reserve. FOMC Meeting Transcript, September 2013 The Committee instead held off, saying it wanted “more evidence that progress will be sustained.” The 10-year yield dropped 15 basis points, stocks rose, and emerging-market currencies rallied.6J.P. Morgan Chase Institute. Taper Tantrum Report That decision effectively ended the acute phase of the sell-off.
Tapering itself began three months later. On December 18, 2013, the FOMC voted 9–1 to cut monthly purchases by $10 billion, bringing the total from $85 billion to $75 billion. Boston Fed President Eric Rosengren dissented, citing elevated unemployment and low inflation. Markets took it in stride, and both the Dow and the S&P 500 closed at record highs that day.16CNBC. Fed Begins Taper Program The Fed then cut $10 billion per meeting through 2014, ending the program on October 29, 2014.1Federal Reserve. Timeline of Balance Sheet Policies
What Policymakers Took From It
The IMF concluded that “clear and effective communication concerning exit from unconventional monetary support is critical to help reduce the risk of excessive market volatility,” and credited the Fed’s revised approach after May 2013 with keeping the actual taper orderly. For emerging markets, the IMF recommended larger reserve buffers, tighter macroprudential policies in advance of shocks, and acting “early and decisively” when turbulence arrived.17International Monetary Fund. Emerging Markets Volatility: Lessons From the Taper Tantrum
Many emerging economies did build those buffers. By the end of 2020, most held higher central bank reserves, carried less foreign-currency debt, and ran smaller current account deficits than they had in 2013. Only Turkey and Argentina remained in the low-reserve-adequacy category.13Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. Taper Tantrum and Emerging Markets Research
The clearest test came in late July 2021, when the Fed again signaled it would begin reducing bond purchases. The 10-year Treasury yield sat around 1.3% and barely moved. According to the St. Louis Fed, the difference was that the 2021 signal matched market expectations, while the 2013 remark had caught investors off guard.4FRED Blog, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. No Taper Tantrum This Time Surprises move markets. Telegraphed shifts do not.