What Unlicensed Insurance Agents Can and Cannot Do

What unlicensed insurance agents can and cannot do comes down to a single test: anything that counts as selling, soliciting, or negotiating a policy requires a producer license, and everything else โ€” clerical work, administrative support, informational customer service, and a surprising amount of day-to-day agency activity โ€” does not. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners draws that line in its Producer Licensing Model Act, and most states have adopted some version of it.1National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Producer Licensing Model Act

The Line That Triggers a License

Three activities require a license. The NAIC defines them this way:1National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Producer Licensing Model Act

  • Selling: exchanging an insurance contract for money on behalf of a carrier.
  • Soliciting: attempting to sell insurance, or urging someone to apply for a particular coverage from a particular carrier.
  • Negotiating: advising a buyer or prospective buyer on the substantive benefits, terms, or conditions of a specific insurance contract.

Any task that involves one of those three actions is off-limits to an unlicensed employee. Anything that doesn’t is clerical and permitted. The NAIC’s implementation guidelines fill in the detail with concrete examples, and those examples form the backbone of most state rules on the subject.2National Association of Insurance Commissioners. State Licensing Handbook – Chapter 5 Activities Requiring Licensure

States don’t all draw the line in exactly the same place. A handful allow salaried employees of licensed insurers to do noticeably more, including explaining policy elements and giving verbal quotes, as long as the employee works under direct supervision and isn’t paid on commission. Check your own state’s insurance code before assuming a national standard.

Clerical and Administrative Work

The bulk of what unlicensed staff do keeps the agency running. The NAIC guidelines spell out a long list of permitted activities:3National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Implementation Guidelines – Licensable Activities Appendix B

  • Receiving and recording information from applicants or policyholders, updating customer records, and maintaining files.
  • Filling out applications on instructions from a licensed producer and passing the completed form to that producer for review and signature.
  • Preparing binders, certificates, endorsements, ID cards, and policies for a licensed producer’s review and signature.
  • Pulling information from credit agencies, the DMV, and other insurers to support underwriting decisions.
  • Opening mail, sorting correspondence, and managing the filing system.

The common thread: the employee gathers, organizes, or records information for a licensed producer to act on. They don’t make coverage decisions or interpret what the information means for a client’s protection.

Customer Calls and Coverage Questions

Unlicensed employees are often the first voice a client hears, and they can handle more than people assume. They can answer questions about office hours, payment methods, and document status. They can schedule appointments with producers, set renewal reminders, and confirm receipt of paperwork.3National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Implementation Guidelines – Licensable Activities Appendix B

They can take incoming calls about changes to an existing policy: a new vehicle, a replacement driver, additional property. They record the information and pass it along, or process the change through an automated system a producer oversees. What they cannot do is advise the caller on whether the change affects coverage or recommend additional protection.

The guidelines specifically permit unlicensed staff to inform an insured about coverage “as indicated in policy records.” That means reading back what the policy says. It does not mean interpreting ambiguous language, recommending different coverage, or telling the caller whether a particular loss would be covered.3National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Implementation Guidelines – Licensable Activities Appendix B

This is where staff most often brush the line. A customer asks “Am I covered for that?” and the natural impulse is to answer. A well-trained employee hears that as the start of a negotiation and hands the call to a licensed colleague.

Payments, Certificates, and Rate Quotes

Three specific tasks generate frequent questions.

Unlicensed employees can accept premium payments at the agency for existing binders, endorsements, or policies. The guidelines list this as a permissible clerical activity.3National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Implementation Guidelines – Licensable Activities Appendix B The restriction: no coverage discussion during the transaction. A client who walks in to pay and asks whether their deductible is high enough needs to be routed to a producer.

Certificates of insurance work similarly. An unlicensed employee can prepare and send a certificate based on existing policy records. Signing it is a different matter, because the signature is a professional attestation about the coverage and crosses into licensed territory.

Rate quotes surprise people. Unlicensed staff can provide rate information to callers by reading from a published rate chart, a printed list, or a computer database of standard rates, and can quote a rate on a requested policy change by looking it up in the system.3National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Implementation Guidelines – Licensable Activities Appendix B The distinction is mechanical versus advisory. Looking up a number and reading it back is clerical. Explaining whether that rate is competitive, recommending a higher limit, or comparing products across carriers is solicitation or negotiation.

Marketing and Outreach

Unlicensed employees can run most of an agency’s marketing function. Social media, newsletters, advertisements, community events, email campaigns, direct mail, website upkeep, blog posts on general insurance topics โ€” all permitted. Distributing brochures and general information is fine too, provided the employee doesn’t drift into conversations about the terms of a specific contract while handing them out.3National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Implementation Guidelines – Licensable Activities Appendix B

Content must stay informational, not advisory. “Did you know homeowners insurance can cover water damage? Contact us for a free review” is fine. “You should increase your liability limits to $500,000 because most people are underinsured” crosses into solicitation, because it recommends a specific coverage action. Agencies should review marketing materials before publication to confirm compliance.4Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Marketplace Compliance for Agents and Brokers

How Unlicensed Staff Can Be Paid

Compensation is one of the places agencies get into trouble. The general rule across most states: unlicensed insurance employees cannot receive commissions or any compensation directly tied to the amount of insurance sold. Fixed salary, hourly wages, and flat bonuses unrelated to sales volume are fine. A percentage of premiums written is not.

Referral fees occupy a gray zone that varies by state. Many states allow a licensed agent or broker to pay an unlicensed person a flat fee for referring a potential customer, but only if two conditions hold: the referral didn’t include any discussion of specific policy terms, and the fee isn’t contingent on whether the prospect buys a policy. A flat $25 per name is generally permissible. A $100 payment only if the referral results in a sale looks like a commission and runs afoul of most states’ rules. Document any referral program clearly and confirm it against your state’s insurance code.

The Federal Background Bar

Before anyone becomes an unlicensed employee at all, a federal statute sets a hiring floor. Under 18 U.S.C. ยง 1033, anyone convicted of a criminal felony involving dishonesty or breach of trust is prohibited from working in the business of insurance if the work affects interstate commerce. The bar covers acts like embezzlement, fraud, and theft, and it applies to unlicensed employees, not just licensed agents.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 1033 – Crimes by or Affecting Persons Engaged in the Business of Insurance

A person with a disqualifying conviction can still work in insurance, but only after obtaining written consent from an insurance regulatory official, commonly called a Section 1033 waiver. The application typically goes through the insurance commissioner in the state where the person will primarily work.

The penalties cut both ways. An individual who works in insurance without the required waiver faces up to five years in federal prison. An employer who knowingly allows it faces the same criminal exposure plus a civil penalty of up to $50,000 per violation or the amount of compensation involved, whichever is greater.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 1034 – Civil Penalties and Injunctions for Violations of Section 1033

Supervision Is a Licensed Producer’s Job

Everything an unlicensed employee does in an agency happens under the supervision of a licensed producer. The producer is responsible for keeping the employee inside the lines, which means training staff to recognize when a conversation is drifting toward coverage advice and to hand off the call at that point.

Written guidelines help. The problem rarely comes from malice; it comes from well-meaning employees answering a question that sounded routine. If bad advice reaches a client and the client relies on it, the supervising producer and the agency can be held liable, which is where most enforcement actions originate. Clear boundaries, documented in writing and reinforced through training, are what keep an agency’s unlicensed workforce productive without putting the license at risk.