What to Expect from an HMRC Compliance Check

A compliance check from HMRC is a formal review of your tax affairs to confirm you have paid the right amount. What to expect from an HMRC compliance check is a written opening letter, requests for records under statutory powers, possibly a visit to your business premises, and a closure notice at the end that either confirms your return was correct or sets out extra tax, interest, and penalties. Many checks are routine, some are random, and receiving one is not itself an accusation of fraud. It is, however, a process with real deadlines and real financial consequences, so knowing the shape of it matters.

How the Check Opens

Nothing formal happens until a letter arrives. HMRC opens a compliance check by sending written notice to you or your tax agent, identifying the tax year, the tax type under review, and what it wants to examine.1GOV.UK. HMRC Compliance Checks – Help and Support

The letter may focus on a single area of your return or on the return as a whole. Legally there is no distinction between the two: every enquiry into a return is an enquiry into the full return, even where HMRC only needs to examine part of it.2GOV.UK. Enquiry Manual – EM0091 – Introduction: Types of Enquiry: General That matters in practice, because HMRC can widen the scope of the check if new concerns emerge, even when the opening letter looked narrow.

The check has to be opened within a set window. For returns filed on or before the deadline, HMRC has 12 months from the filing date. If you filed late, the window extends to the next quarter day (31 January, 30 April, 31 July, or 31 October) after the first anniversary of the date you actually submitted. Once that window closes, HMRC generally cannot open an enquiry into that return, though separate discovery powers can still reach back further.

What HMRC Can Ask For

HMRC has broad statutory powers under Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008 to demand information and documents and to inspect business premises.3GOV.UK. Compliance Handbook – CH20150 – Information and Inspection Powers: Overview: Schedule 36 FA 2008 These powers cover every major tax, including income tax, corporation tax, VAT, capital gains tax, and PAYE.4GOV.UK. Compliance Handbook – CH201100 – How to Do a Compliance Check: General: Introduction and Scope

A formal information notice will specify what HMRC wants and set a reasonable period for you to produce it. There is no fixed statutory deadline; the notice itself sets the timeframe, and that timeframe must be reasonable given the volume and complexity of what is being requested.5UK Parliament. Finance Act 2008 Schedule 36 – Information and Inspection Powers Requests typically cover bank statements, sales invoices, expense receipts, and digital accounting records. Follow-up notices are common if the initial material raises further questions.

Ignoring a formal information notice carries consequences even if you end up owing nothing. The initial penalty is £300, followed by daily penalties of up to £60 for each day the failure continues. If non-compliance continues, a tribunal can increase the daily penalty to as much as £1,000 per day.5UK Parliament. Finance Act 2008 Schedule 36 – Information and Inspection Powers

Site Visits

For VAT, employer compliance, and excise checks, a visit to business premises is standard. Officers will examine business records and may inspect physical assets, stock, and operating procedures. Visits are almost always arranged in advance. Unannounced inspections are reserved for cases where HMRC suspects deliberate understatement and believes warning would let evidence be concealed.6GOV.UK. Compliance Handbook – CH207400 – How to Do a Compliance Check

How Far Back HMRC Can Go

Even after the enquiry window has closed, HMRC can raise a “discovery assessment” if it later finds tax was underpaid. The time limit depends on the nature of the error:

The 20-year window for deliberate errors is a powerful tool. When knowingly understated income is uncovered years later, the combination of underpaid tax, compounded interest, and penalties can be severe.

Your Rights and Best Moves During the Check

The HMRC Charter, required by the Commissioners for Revenue and Customs Act 2005, sets the standard of service you should expect throughout the process. It covers fair treatment, responsiveness, data security, and your right to appoint a representative. If an officer’s conduct falls short, you can complain formally referencing the Charter. If you disagree with a tax decision, you can request a statutory review, appeal to the independent tax tribunal, or both.8GOV.UK. The HMRC Charter

You are obliged to cooperate and to provide accurate and complete information, even when it works against your position. Concealing records or submitting false documents escalates both penalties and the risk of criminal investigation. Cooperation runs both ways, though, and you do not have to accept unreasonable demands or open-ended requests that stretch beyond the check.

Applying for a Closure Notice

If a check has dragged on with no clear end in sight, you can apply to the First-tier Tribunal for a direction requiring HMRC to close the enquiry. Under section 28A of the Taxes Management Act 1970, the tribunal must issue that direction unless HMRC can demonstrate reasonable grounds for keeping the check open.9UK Parliament. Taxes Management Act 1970 Section 28A It is one of the least-known rights taxpayers have during a check, and it gives you real leverage to force resolution.

Getting Representation

Bringing in an accountant or tax solicitor early is generally worth the cost. A representative handles communication with the officer, ensures you only disclose what is legally required, and pushes back on overreach. They also catch procedural errors, such as an information notice served outside the enquiry window or a penalty calculation using the wrong behavior category. Routing all correspondence and meetings through your representative also limits the risk that a casual remark or volunteered piece of information is used to widen the scope of the check.

How the Check Ends

A compliance check ends when HMRC issues a closure notice confirming the final tax position. If no errors are found, the notice simply confirms that your return was correct. If HMRC has identified underpaid tax, the notice sets out the additional liability, interest, and any penalties.

In many cases, HMRC and the taxpayer reach agreement on the amount owed before the closure notice is issued. That negotiated settlement is the most common outcome: you agree the underpaid tax, the interest, and the penalty, and HMRC formally closes the check. The level of cooperation and quality of disclosure directly affect the penalty reduction you receive, which gives you a genuine reason to settle rather than fight.

If agreement cannot be reached, the dispute goes to the First-tier Tribunal for independent determination. You normally have 30 days from the date a penalty or decision is issued to request a review or lodge an appeal.10GOV.UK. Disagree With a Tax Decision or Penalty Missing that deadline is not necessarily fatal — a late application with a good reason may still be accepted — but staying on top of it avoids complications.

What You Might Have to Pay

If the check finds that you underpaid tax, HMRC calculates penalties under Schedule 24 of the Finance Act 2007. The penalty is a percentage of the “potential lost revenue” — essentially, the tax that went unpaid because of the error. How much you pay depends on the nature of the mistake and whether you came forward voluntarily or HMRC had to find it.11UK Parliament. Finance Act 2007 Schedule 24 – Penalties for Errors

HMRC classifies errors into three behavior categories, each with its own maximum:

  • Careless (failure to take reasonable care): up to 30% of the potential lost revenue.
  • Deliberate but not concealed (you knew about the error but did not actively hide it): up to 70%.
  • Deliberate and concealed (you took steps to hide the underpayment, such as creating false records): up to 100%.11UK Parliament. Finance Act 2007 Schedule 24 – Penalties for Errors

Disclosure Reductions

These maximums can be reduced substantially depending on whether you disclose the error yourself (unprompted) or only admit it after HMRC raises the issue (prompted). The completeness and timeliness of your disclosure, and how much you help HMRC quantify the underpayment, determine where within the range you land.

  • Careless errors: unprompted disclosure can bring the penalty to 0%. Prompted disclosure has a floor of 15%.
  • Deliberate errors: unprompted disclosure has a floor of 20%. Prompted disclosure has a floor of 35%.
  • Deliberate and concealed errors: unprompted disclosure has a floor of 30%. Prompted disclosure has a floor of 50%.11UK Parliament. Finance Act 2007 Schedule 24 – Penalties for Errors

If you spot an error in a previous return, telling HMRC before they raise it is almost always the better financial outcome. The gap between an unprompted and prompted disclosure can halve the penalty or more.

Interest

On top of any penalty, HMRC charges interest on the underpaid tax from the date it was originally due, and it compounds. For checks reaching back several years, the interest alone can add thousands to the bill. Unlike penalties, interest cannot be reduced through cooperation or disclosure; it simply reflects the time value of money HMRC was owed.

When It Becomes a Fraud Investigation

Standard compliance checks handle carelessness and even deliberate errors through civil penalties. Where HMRC suspects outright tax fraud, it may issue Code of Practice 9 (COP9), which operates on entirely different footing.12GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – HM Revenue and Customs Investigation of Fraud

COP9 offers a choice: make a full and honest disclosure of all deliberate tax irregularities through the Contractual Disclosure Facility (CDF), and HMRC will not pursue criminal prosecution for the conduct you disclose. You have 60 days from receiving the CDF offer to accept or reject it.13GOV.UK. Admit Tax Fraud to HMRC Using the Contractual Disclosure Facility Accepting means admitting that deliberate behavior caused a loss of tax, providing full details, and cooperating to settle what you owe. Rejecting the offer, or not responding within the 60-day window, means HMRC will start its own investigation, which may be criminal, and penalties for uncooperative COP9 cases are considerably higher. Anyone who receives COP9 should speak to a specialist tax solicitor before responding.

Records Worth Keeping

Good records are the single best defense. When HMRC queries a figure and you can produce the supporting document within days, the check tends to move quickly and close without further issues. When you cannot, the officer draws inferences, and those rarely help you.

For pay and tax records tied to Self Assessment, HMRC advises keeping documents for at least 22 months after the end of the tax year the return covers, assuming you filed on time.14GOV.UK. Keeping Your Pay and Tax Records – How Long to Keep Your Records For business records and self-employment income, at least five years after the 31 January filing deadline for the relevant year is the commonly recommended minimum. Because discovery assessments can reach back 6 or even 20 years where carelessness or deliberate error is involved, holding key financial records well beyond the statutory minimum is genuinely worth the effort.