What Is the New Unrealised Capital Gains Tax Legislation?

There is no federal unrealized capital gains tax in effect. Congress has floated the idea in two live proposals aimed at the wealthiest Americans, but neither has been enacted as of 2026. The most-discussed version, the Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act, would require taxpayers worth more than $100 million to pay an effective tax rate of at least 25 percent on all income, including the paper gains on assets they still hold. A newer bill, the Billionaires Income Tax Act, was introduced in September 2025 and sits in the Senate Finance Committee.1Congress.gov. S.2845 – Billionaires Income Tax Act All Info Under current law, you still owe capital gains tax only when you sell.

Where the Proposals Stand Right Now

Two separate bills reflect two different designs. The Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act, introduced as H.R.6498 in the 118th Congress, would set a 25 percent floor on the effective tax rate of covered taxpayers, calculated on total income including unrealized gains.2Congress.gov. Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act That bill expired without a vote. The Billionaires Income Tax Act (S.2845), introduced in the 119th Congress, would instead tax gains on an accrual basis every year, similar to how some financial instruments are already treated.1Congress.gov. S.2845 – Billionaires Income Tax Act All Info It was referred to committee in September 2025 and has not advanced.

President Biden’s 2023 budget floated a similar minimum-tax concept at a 20 percent rate; later versions pushed the rate to 25 percent.3Congress.gov. Mark-to-Market Taxation of Capital Gains None of these versions have become law. Everything that follows describes what the legislation would do if enacted, not what is owed today.

Who Would Actually Pay It

The proposals target a very small group. Under the Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act, you would be a “covered taxpayer” if your total net worth exceeds $100 million at the end of the tax year. The tax phases in at that threshold and applies fully once net worth passes $200 million.4Congress.gov. Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act – Full Text The Billionaires Income Tax Act reaches individuals with more than $100 million in annual income or more than $1 billion in assets for three consecutive years.5U.S. Senate Committee on Finance. Wyden, Cohen, Beyer Introduce the Billionaires Income Tax Act

Fewer than 1,000 taxpayers would be affected under either measure. If your net worth is below $100 million, neither proposal would change your tax obligations. Realization-based capital gains rules would continue to apply exactly as they do today.

How Each Version Would Work

The two bills use different mechanics. The Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act sets a floor: if your total effective tax rate, calculated on all income including the increase in value of unsold assets, falls below 25 percent, you owe the difference. A covered taxpayer who already pays above that rate through ordinary income taxes, realized capital gains taxes, and other levies owes nothing extra.4Congress.gov. Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act – Full Text

The Billionaires Income Tax Act works on a mark-to-market basis. Covered taxpayers would recognize gains and losses on tradable assets each year as if those assets had been sold, and the gain would be added to taxable income and taxed at existing rates.3Congress.gov. Mark-to-Market Taxation of Capital Gains The mark-to-market version taxes gains at whatever bracket rate applies; the minimum-tax version only bites when the effective rate is otherwise too low.

Under both approaches, the tax applies to the net change in value across all covered assets. Losses on some holdings offset gains on others before any tax is calculated.

Which Assets Would Be Counted

The proposals reach broadly. Publicly traded securities such as stocks, bonds, and exchange-traded funds are the easiest case because they have a daily market price. The proposed legislation also reaches private company interests, real estate, and any other property that contributes to a taxpayer’s net worth. Cryptocurrency, treated as property under existing IRS guidance, would fall within the same framework.

The breadth is deliberate. If categories were exempt, holdings would shift into them. The proposals aim to capture the full picture of wealth growth rather than only the portion sitting in a brokerage account.

Valuing Assets That Don’t Trade Publicly

Publicly traded assets get their year-end market price. Illiquid holdings are harder. The Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act uses a formula for non-tradable assets: start with the greatest of original cost, adjusted cost basis, or most recent fair market valuation, then increase that figure by a deemed appreciation rate tied to the five-year average Treasury yield plus two percentage points.4Congress.gov. Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act – Full Text A fresh appraisal is not required each year, though a professional valuation can be used if it produces a more accurate number.

The bill also creates a Special Limited Deferral Option, or SLDO, for illiquid assets. Tax on non-tradable holdings is tracked in a separate account, and actual cash payment is deferred until a liquidity event such as a sale. The taxpayer accrues the obligation in the meantime.4Congress.gov. Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act – Full Text The point is to avoid forcing someone to sell a private business just to pay tax on paper gains.

Paying the Bill and Getting Money Back When Values Drop

Even at this wealth level, the bill assumes taxpayers may not have the full cash amount available. The Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act lets the first year’s liability be spread over nine equal annual installments. Every year after that, the tax can be paid over five annual installments. Each installment is due alongside the regular annual return. Missing an installment or filing for bankruptcy accelerates the entire unpaid balance.4Congress.gov. Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act – Full Text The installment schedule is an election; paying the full amount upfront is allowed.

What if you pay tax on a gain that later evaporates? The bill addresses this. If asset values decline, the taxpayer receives a credit or refund against prior minimum tax payments. The refund is capped at what has already been paid in, so the government does not write checks for pure market losses. To smooth out yearly swings, credits are spread across multiple years the same way payments are.6U.S. House of Representatives. Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Fact Sheet

How Death Would Be Treated

Under current law, heirs receive a stepped-up basis equal to the asset’s fair market value at the date of death, and any lifetime gains escape income tax permanently.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1014 – Basis of Property Acquired From a Decedent Section 1482 of the Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act would change that. Death, bequest, or gift would be treated as a taxable transfer for any covered taxpayer, or anyone who had been a covered taxpayer in the preceding ten years. Tax would be owed on the difference between each asset’s estimated value and its adjusted basis at that moment.4Congress.gov. Billionaire Minimum Income Tax Act – Full Text Charitable contributions of appreciated assets would also trigger gain recognition. The ten-year lookback prevents a taxpayer from dropping below the $100 million threshold shortly before death to avoid the rule.

The Constitutional Question

Whether Congress can tax income that has not been realized through a sale is unsettled. In 1920, in Eisner v. Macomber, Justice Pitney wrote that “mere growth or increment of value in a capital investment is not income” and that income must be “severed” from the underlying capital before it can be taxed.8Justia U.S. Supreme Court. Eisner v. Macomber, 252 U.S. 189 (1920) If that reasoning still controls, taxing unrealized gains would require a constitutional amendment.

The Supreme Court had a chance to revisit the question in Moore v. United States in 2024 and declined. Moore involved the Mandatory Repatriation Tax, which taxed shareholders on their foreign corporation’s undistributed earnings. The Court upheld the tax but limited its holding to situations where a corporation had realized income that was then attributed to shareholders. Justice Kavanaugh’s majority opinion “sidestepped the issue of whether Congress can constitutionally tax unrealized income.”9Congress.gov. Supreme Court Declines to Decide Whether Sixteenth Amendment Requires Realization

The separate opinions previewed the fight. Justice Barrett argued that the Sixteenth Amendment’s reference to income “derived” from a source contains an implicit realization requirement. Justice Thomas agreed, writing that there must be a distinction between income and the source it comes from. Justice Jackson disagreed entirely, contesting that the Amendment requires realization at all.9Congress.gov. Supreme Court Declines to Decide Whether Sixteenth Amendment Requires Realization Any enacted unrealized-gains tax would face an immediate constitutional challenge, and the Court would then have to decide the question it avoided in Moore.

What to Do If You’re Near the Threshold

The political interest in taxing unrealized gains keeps returning. The Billionaires Income Tax Act introduced in September 2025 shows that sponsors continue refining and reintroducing the concept each Congress. Sponsors estimate the tax would affect fewer than 1,000 people and raise more than $500 billion over a decade.5U.S. Senate Committee on Finance. Wyden, Cohen, Beyer Introduce the Billionaires Income Tax Act

For taxpayers anywhere near the $100 million threshold, preparation is practical rather than urgent. Keep detailed records of asset basis and year-end valuations. Understand how each holding would be classified under the proposed frameworks, especially the split between tradable and non-tradable assets. If a version passes, the installment schedules and the SLDO deferral for illiquid assets offer some cash-flow flexibility, but the compliance work would begin right away.