The employer’s liability exclusion in CGL policies strips general liability coverage for bodily injury to your own workers, pushing those claims onto your workers’ compensation and employers liability insurance instead. In the standard ISO Commercial General Liability form (CG 00 01), it appears as exclusion “e,” and it reaches further than the words “employee injury” suggest. It blocks claims by the worker’s family, claims routed through a third party, and claims where you happen to wear a second hat beyond employer.
What the Exclusion Blocks
Exclusion “e” removes CGL coverage for bodily injury to your employee when the injury arises out of and during the course of employment by you or performance of duties related to your business.1New York State Office of General Services. Commercial General Liability Coverage Form Courts read “arising out of” broadly, looking for a causal link between the work and the harm rather than requiring the injury to happen mid-task. A warehouse worker who throws out their back lifting inventory is clearly inside the exclusion. So, in most readings, is the same worker who slips in your parking lot walking to lunch, because the connection to employment is enough.
Two features of the wording do most of the heavy lifting. The exclusion applies whether you are liable “as an employer or in any other capacity,” and it extends to any obligation to share damages with or repay someone else who must pay damages because of the injury.1New York State Office of General Services. Commercial General Liability Coverage Form Those two phrases are what make the exclusion so hard to work around.
Who Counts as an Employee
The exclusion only fires against people who meet the policy’s definition of “employee.” That definition does more work than it looks like it does, and the differences between categories decide whether you have coverage.
Leased Workers
A leased worker is someone a labor leasing firm provides to you under contract to perform duties related to your business. The policy folds leased workers into the “employee” definition, so an injury to a leased worker on your job is excluded exactly as if they were on your payroll. This closes the obvious workaround of running long-term staff through a staffing firm and then expecting the CGL to pick up the injury claim.
Temporary Workers
Temporary workers are defined as people furnished to you to substitute for a permanent employee on leave or to handle short-term or seasonal workload. The policy carves them out of the “employee” definition, so the employer’s liability exclusion does not reach them, and your CGL can potentially respond to their injury claims. Misclassifying a leased worker as a temporary one is a dangerous mistake: if the staffing arrangement looks long-term and ongoing, the worker is probably leased, and treating them as temporary will not change how the exclusion applies.
Volunteer Workers
Later editions of the ISO CGL form added a definition for volunteer workers: people who donate their work, act under your direction, and receive no compensation from you or anyone else. Volunteers are not employees under the policy, so the exclusion does not block their claims. For organizations that depend on volunteer labor, that is a meaningful piece of coverage. Older policy editions may not include the volunteer worker definition at all, so check the specific form on your policy before assuming it applies.
Family Members of the Injured Worker
The exclusion also bars claims brought by the employee’s spouse, child, parent, brother, or sister when those claims flow from the work-related injury.1New York State Office of General Services. Commercial General Liability Coverage Form Many jurisdictions let a spouse bring a loss-of-consortium claim or a parent sue for loss of support in connection with a worker’s injury. Those derivative lawsuits land outside your CGL coverage just as firmly as the employee’s own claim. If a serious workplace injury triggers a spouse’s lawsuit against you, your CGL insurer owes no defense and no indemnity.
Third-Party Over Claims
This is where the exclusion causes the most unpleasant surprises. A third-party over claim runs like this: your employee is hurt on the job, collects workers’ compensation benefits, and then sues a third party such as a property owner, equipment manufacturer, or general contractor for additional damages. That third party turns around and files against you, arguing you were partly to blame and should contribute to or reimburse what they pay.
The exclusion anticipates exactly that chain. Because it blocks “any obligation to share damages with or repay someone else who must pay damages because of the injury,” your CGL insurer has no duty to defend you or pay the third party’s contribution or indemnity claim.1New York State Office of General Services. Commercial General Liability Coverage Form Without that language, employers could route employee injury costs through their CGL by way of a third party. Many states reach a similar result through the exclusive remedy doctrine, but the exclusion operates on its own and applies even in states that allow some form of third-party contribution against employers.
Dual Capacity Lawsuits
A small number of states recognize the dual capacity doctrine, which lets an employee sue the employer when the employer holds a second role beyond being the employer. The textbook example is an employer that also manufactured the equipment that injured the worker; the employee argues the product liability claim stands apart from the employment relationship and the exclusive remedy rule should not shield it.
The exclusion was written to shut this down for CGL purposes. Its wording extends to liability you have “as an employer or in any other capacity.”1New York State Office of General Services. Commercial General Liability Coverage Form Even if your state recognizes dual capacity and the employee’s lawsuit proceeds, the CGL still will not respond, because the injury arose out of and during employment. The intended coverage for a dual capacity suit is the employers liability portion of your workers’ compensation policy, not the CGL.
Where Coverage Can Still Respond
Two features of the policy can bring coverage back in specific situations: the separation of insureds condition and the insured contract exception.
Separation of Insureds
The CGL’s separation of insureds condition says the policy applies to each named insured as if that insured were the only one on the policy. When two or more named insureds share a policy and the employee of Named Insured A sues Named Insured B, the exclusion is tested from B’s perspective alone. The injured worker is not B’s employee, so the exclusion does not bar B’s coverage. Courts have read “the insured” in the exclusion to mean the specific insured against whom the claim is made, not every insured on the policy. The exclusion is designed to keep your own workers’ injury claims off your CGL, not to strip coverage when a different insured faces a claim from someone else’s employee.
The Insured Contract Exception
Exclusion “e” carries one carve-back: it does not apply to liability you assume under an “insured contract.” The policy’s definition of insured contract covers leases of premises, sidetrack agreements, easement or license agreements, elevator maintenance agreements, obligations required by ordinance to indemnify a municipality, and the portion of a business contract in which you assume another party’s tort liability for bodily injury or property damage to a third person.1New York State Office of General Services. Commercial General Liability Coverage Form
The last category is the one that matters most on construction and service contracts. When a subcontractor agrees in writing to indemnify the general contractor for job-site injuries, and one of the subcontractor’s own employees is hurt, the GC’s indemnity claim against the sub would normally be blocked by the employer’s liability exclusion. The insured contract exception restores CGL coverage for that assumed obligation. The exception is limited to tort liability, meaning liability that would exist even without the contract, and the wording of the indemnity clause has to clearly assume that tort liability. Vague or overbroad clauses may fail to qualify, and disputes over whether a given agreement is an insured contract are among the most heavily litigated issues in CGL coverage.
State law can also knock the exception out. Roughly 45 states have anti-indemnity statutes that limit or void indemnification agreements in construction contracts, typically where one party is being indemnified for its own negligence. If the underlying indemnity obligation is unenforceable, there is nothing for the insured contract exception to pick up, and the exclusion applies in full. Some states extend their anti-indemnity rules to additional insured requirements as well, treating a promise to insure another party against that party’s own negligence the same as a direct indemnity. Before relying on the insured contract exception, confirm the indemnity clause is enforceable in the state where the work is performed.
Stop Gap Coverage in Monopolistic States
Four states require employers to buy workers’ compensation exclusively through a state fund: North Dakota, Ohio, Washington, and Wyoming. The state fund policies pay medical costs and wage replacement for injured workers but do not include the employers liability coverage that private workers’ comp policies carry by default. The result is a gap: the CGL excludes employee injury claims, and the state fund policy does not pick them up.
A stop gap endorsement fills the hole by adding employers liability coverage. For a business that operates only in a monopolistic state, the endorsement attaches to the CGL. For a business with operations in both monopolistic and non-monopolistic states, the endorsement typically attaches to the workers’ compensation policy covering the other states. If you operate in North Dakota, Ohio, Washington, or Wyoming, verify at every renewal that a stop gap endorsement is on your program. The cost is small; the exposure, once a lawsuit lands, is not.