What Is the Borrower Defense Program? Eligibility, Relief, Taxes

Borrower defense to repayment is a federal program that cancels some or all of your federal Direct Loans when the school you attended misled you, broke its enrollment contract, or engaged in other misconduct tied to the loans you took out. You apply to the Department of Education, explain what the school did, and if the Department agrees, it wipes out the qualifying loan balance and can refund what you already paid.

Which Loans Qualify

Only federal Direct Loans are eligible for a borrower defense discharge. That covers Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized Loans, Direct PLUS Loans for graduate students and parents, and Direct Consolidation Loans.¹

Older loan types are not automatically shut out. If you hold Federal Family Education Loans (FFEL) or Perkins Loans, you can still pursue a claim, but you first need to consolidate them into a Direct Consolidation Loan. Parent PLUS borrowers can file too, either directly or after consolidating.¹

Private student loans are excluded entirely. If your only debt is with a private lender, borrower defense is not available regardless of what your school did.

What Counts as Misconduct

The standard the Department applies depends on when your loans were first disbursed. The rules have been rewritten more than once, and a federal court injunction issued in August 2023 has blocked the newest version from taking effect.²

Loans First Disbursed Before July 1, 2017

For older loans, you need to show that the school did (or failed to do) something that would give rise to a legal cause of action under the law of the state where the school operated. In practice this usually means fraud, misrepresentation, or unfair business practices under that state’s consumer protection statutes.³

Loans First Disbursed Between July 1, 2017 and July 1, 2020

For this window, the Department applies a federal standard. You can establish a claim through any of three paths, proved by a preponderance of the evidence:⁴

Substantial misrepresentation. The school or its recruiters made a false, misleading, or deceptive statement you reasonably relied on when you enrolled or borrowed. Inflated job placement rates, false claims about accreditation or credit transferability, and misleading salary projections all fit.
Breach of contract. The school failed to deliver what your enrollment agreement promised, such as clinical training or specific coursework.
A favorable court or administrative judgment against the school on the relevant conduct.

Loans First Disbursed On or After July 1, 2020

A November 2022 regulation was meant to govern these loans, but the 2023 injunction has blocked it, and as of early 2026 the injunction remains in place. The Department has said it will keep adjudicating applications under the older rules while the block stands. If your loans fall in this window, file anyway; the Department will apply whichever regulation it determines fits.²

There Is No Filing Deadline

Borrower defense has no general statute of limitations. You can apply regardless of how long ago you attended the school. The one narrow exception under the 2017–2020 framework: if you’re trying to recover money already collected (rather than just canceling remaining debt), the breach-of-contract path has a six-year limit from the date of the breach.⁴

How to Apply

You file online through StudentAid.gov. Before starting, pull together your enrollment records: dates of attendance, program or major, credential pursued, and your FSA ID.² A transcript or diploma helps pin down the timeframe.

The heart of the application is a written narrative describing exactly what the school did, including who said what, when they said it, and how it was communicated to you.⁵ Specificity matters. Names of recruiters, admissions staff, or financial aid officers carry more weight than vague recollections, and approximate dates beat “sometime that year.”

Evidence that strengthens a claim:

Promotional materials such as brochures, flyers, or archived web pages making misleading claims about outcomes or program quality.
Emails, texts, or letters from school staff containing false statements or high-pressure pitches.
Enrollment agreements or contracts, especially for breach-of-contract claims.
Documentation showing the school lacked equipment, labs, instructors, or clinical placements it had advertised.

You upload everything through the portal. A thorough first submission cuts down on follow-up requests from the Department, which slow the review.⁵

When You May Not Need to Apply

For a handful of schools, the Department has already investigated, found widespread misconduct, and issued group discharges that cancel loans automatically. If you attended one of these during the covered years, the Department notifies affected borrowers by email and you don’t have to file:⁶

Corinthian Colleges, any campus, from its founding in 1995 through its closure in April 2015.
ITT Technical Institute, January 1, 2005 through its closure in September 2016.
Marinello Schools of Beauty, January 2009 through its closure in February 2016.
Westwood College, January 1, 2002 through November 17, 2015.
American Career Institute campuses in Massachusetts.

What Happens While Your Claim Is Pending

You get a confirmation email after filing, and the application goes into a review queue.² Inside the application, in the forbearance and stopped collections section, you can ask the Department to pause your loan payments and halt collection activity on any defaulted loans. Keep making payments until your servicer confirms the hold, or you risk falling into default in the meantime.⁷ Once the hold is active, wage garnishment and Treasury offsets on those loans also stop.

Review times vary. Claims tied to schools where the Department has already built a factual record move faster; claims that require investigation from scratch can take months or longer. The decision comes by email.²

What You Get If Approved

An approval discharges some or all of the federal loan balance tied to the school. A full discharge cancels the entire remaining principal and accrued interest. Where the Department finds the misconduct caused only partial harm, it may grant a partial discharge calculated as a percentage of the outstanding balance.

You may also receive a refund of amounts you already paid on the discharged loans, including money taken through garnishment or tax refund offsets. The Department updates credit reporting agencies to remove negative marks tied to those specific loans, which helps if the loans had gone delinquent or into default.

Pell Grant Eligibility Restoration

If you used Pell Grants at the school that defrauded you, a successful discharge can restore some of your lifetime Pell eligibility. The federal cap is the equivalent of six years of Pell funding, and the Department adjusts the calculation to exclude Pell Grants you received at the offending school. For anyone planning to re-enroll at a legitimate school, that can free up meaningful funding. The Department notifies students by email when the adjustment is made.⁸

The 2026 Tax Consequences

This one catches borrowers off guard. The American Rescue Plan Act made student loan forgiveness tax-free at the federal level, but that provision expired on December 31, 2025. Starting in 2026, debt discharged through borrower defense may be treated as taxable income by the IRS. If $40,000 in loans is forgiven, you could owe federal income tax on that amount as if you had earned it.

The size of the bill depends on your income bracket and how much debt is cancelled. Large balances can produce a five-figure tax liability. State treatment varies, with some states conforming to the federal approach and others keeping their own exclusions.

If you expect a discharge in 2026 or later, plan for it. Setting money aside, adjusting withholding, or making estimated payments can prevent a surprise at filing time. If you get a discharge and can’t pay the resulting tax, the IRS offers installment agreements and may consider an offer in compromise where you genuinely can’t afford the full amount. Talking to a tax professional before the discharge is finalized is worth the cost.

If Your Claim Is Denied

A denial isn’t necessarily the end. You have 90 days from the date of the written denial to request reconsideration on one of three grounds:⁹

An administrative or technical error in how the Department processed or evaluated your application.
For loans first disbursed before July 1, 2017, a request to have your claim evaluated under the applicable state law standard if that wasn’t done.
New evidence not included in your original application and not referenced in the denial decision.

You submit the request on a form signed under penalty of perjury, along with any additional supporting evidence. The Department may ask for more documentation during the reconsideration review.⁹ The 90-day window is strict. Read the denial letter closely to identify exactly why the claim was rejected, then decide whether any of the three grounds fit before time runs out.

1
Federal Student Aid. Borrower Defense Applicable Loans
2
Federal Student Aid. Borrower Defense Loan Discharge
3
eCFR. 34 CFR 685.206 – Borrower Responsibilities and Defenses
4
eCFR. 34 CFR 685.222 – Borrower Defenses and Procedures for Loans First Disbursed On or After July 1, 2017, and Before July 1, 2020
5
Federal Student Aid. Borrower Defense to Repayment Application
6
Federal Student Aid. Borrower Defense Findings
7
Federal Student Aid. How Do I Request a Hold on Defaulted Loan Debt Collection When I Apply for Borrower Defense
8
Federal Student Aid. Guidance on COD Processing of Pell Grant Restoration for Eligible Loan Discharges
9
eCFR. 34 CFR 685.407 – Reconsideration