What Is SAS 72? Comfort Letters, Bring-Downs, and Who Pays

An SAS 72 comfort letter is a communication from an independent auditor to the underwriters of a securities offering, giving limited assurance that certain financial information in the offering documents is reliable. Its purpose is practical: underwriters face civil liability if a registration statement contains a material misstatement, and the comfort letter helps them document the reasonable investigation that gets them out from under that exposure. Although the original SAS 72 has been superseded by PCAOB AS 6101 for public company engagements and AICPA AU-C Section 920 for nonpublic ones, the shorthand stuck, and practitioners still call these engagements SAS 72 letters.

Why Underwriters Ask for One

Section 11 of the Securities Act of 1933 makes every underwriter civilly liable when a registration statement contains a material misstatement or omission.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 77k – Civil Liabilities on Account of False Registration Statement An investor who bought the security doesn’t have to prove the underwriter knew about the error. The only real defense is showing that the underwriter conducted a reasonable investigation and had reasonable ground to believe the statements were true. A comfort letter is one of the standard building blocks of that defense.

These letters most often appear in registered public offerings, but the same framework covers foreign offerings under Regulation S, Eurodollar transactions, exempt offerings under Regulation A or Regulation D, and private placements under Rule 144A.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties In the private-placement contexts, buyers use the auditor’s findings to check that nothing material has slipped since the last audit.

What the Letter Actually Says

A comfort letter follows a predictable structure, and each part answers a distinct question the underwriter needs answered for its due diligence file.

Auditor Independence

The letter opens by confirming that the auditor is independent of the issuer under the Securities Act and SEC rules.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties Without independence, the underlying audit opinion has no weight, and neither does anything built on top of it.

Compliance as to Form

The auditor then states whether the audited financial statements and schedules in the registration statement comply, as to form, with the accounting requirements of the Securities Act and Regulation S-X.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties This is a narrow opinion about presentation, not a re-audit.

Negative Assurance on Unaudited Figures

This is the section underwriters care about most. The auditor performs specified procedures on interim and condensed financial information that appears in the registration statement but hasn’t been fully audited, and then states that nothing came to their attention suggesting the information needs material modification to conform with GAAP.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties The distinction from positive assurance matters. The auditor is not affirming the numbers are correct, only that nothing surfaced to suggest they aren’t. It’s a lower bar, but it fills a real gap, because offerings routinely include financial data more recent than the last audited period.

There is a hard cutoff. If the letter’s cutoff date falls 135 days or more after the end of the most recent audited or reviewed period, the auditor cannot provide negative assurance at all. The letter is limited to describing the procedures performed and the findings.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties Deal teams plan the offering calendar around that boundary.

Subsequent Changes

The letter also addresses whether specific line items have changed during the “change period,” which runs from the date of the most recent financial statements in the registration statement through the cutoff date. Underwriters typically want to know about changes in capital stock, increases in long-term debt, and decreases in items like net current assets, stockholders’ equity, net sales, and earnings per share.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties The procedures here are limited, usually reading board minutes and making inquiries of management, and the letter says so. Still, this is where an underwriter looks for signs the company’s financial health has moved between the audit date and closing.

What Auditors Will Not Cover

Comfort letters have firm limits. Auditors cannot comment on matters that are primarily subjective or judgmental, including the narrative portions of Management’s Discussion and Analysis. Specific dollar amounts in MD&A can be traced to the financial statements, but management’s explanations of why numbers moved are off the table.3Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AI 27 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties

Market risk disclosures under Regulation S-K Item 305 are also excluded. Auditors cannot provide negative assurance on whether those disclosures conform with SEC requirements, cannot comment on the qualitative discussion, and cannot perform procedures on sensitivity analyses or value-at-risk models.3Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AI 27 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties Underwriters sometimes push for comfort here; the standards prohibit it.

Non-GAAP financial measures sit in a gray zone. They fall outside the audit opinion, so an underwriter can ask the auditor to perform agreed-upon procedures on the reconciliation between a non-GAAP measure and its closest GAAP equivalent when that reconciliation appears in the offering document. The auditor reads the non-GAAP information and considers whether it is materially inconsistent with the audited financials, without providing GAAP-level assurance.

The Representation Letter That Comes First

Auditors will not issue a comfort letter without a written representation letter from the requesting party. What the requesting party needs to provide depends on who they are.

A named underwriter in a registered offering can request the comfort letter directly, because named underwriters have a built-in due diligence defense under Section 11.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 77k – Civil Liabilities on Account of False Registration Statement Other requesters, such as broker-dealers acting as intermediaries in a Rule 144A placement or a Regulation D offering, face an extra step. They must either obtain an opinion from legal counsel confirming they have a Section 11 due diligence defense or provide a representation letter with specific statements. That letter has to confirm that the requesting party’s review process is substantially consistent with the due diligence they would perform if the offering were registered under the Securities Act, and that they are knowledgeable about what that process entails.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties Without this documentation, the engagement doesn’t move forward.

Timing: Initial Letter and Bring-Down

Comfort letters follow the rhythm of the deal, and the timing details live in the underwriting agreement.

The initial letter is ordinarily dated on or shortly before the effective date, when the registration statement becomes effective with the SEC. Occasionally an underwriter asks for the letter at the earlier filing date.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties This first letter gives everyone a chance to review the auditor’s findings and confirm the scope meets the underwriter’s needs.

A second letter, called the bring-down letter, is dated at or shortly before closing, when the issuer delivers the securities to the underwriter for payment. The bring-down updates the earlier findings to a new cutoff date, which the underwriting agreement specifies and which typically falls one to a few business days before the letter itself.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties The auditor re-performs the specified procedures and inquiries through the new cutoff.

The letter explicitly states that the procedures did not cover the gap between the cutoff date and the letter date. Events can occur in those final days that nobody has examined, so deal teams try to keep the window narrow.

Who Pays

The issuer almost always bears the cost. Underwriting agreements typically require the issuer to pay for services provided by its independent auditor, and comfort letter fees fall within that category. Underwriters generally cover only their own legal and advertising costs. Comfort letter work can absorb significant auditor time when the offering document includes complex financial presentations or multiple interim periods, so setting fee expectations early tends to avoid friction at closing.

Why “SAS 72” Is Still the Name Everyone Uses

SAS 72 was issued by the AICPA’s Auditing Standards Board and later adopted by the PCAOB as an interim standard after the Sarbanes-Oxley Act created that body. For audits of public companies (issuers), the governing standard is now PCAOB AS 6101, which carries forward the substance of SAS 72 with updated organization and references.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 6101 – Letters for Underwriters and Certain Other Requesting Parties For engagements involving nonpublic entities, the AICPA’s AU-C Section 920 applies. Both trace directly to SAS 72, which is why the old label persists. When someone on a deal team asks for an SAS 72 letter, they mean a comfort letter under whichever of these standards governs the engagement.