What Is HMRC Code of Practice 9? Disclosure, Penalties, and Deadlines

HMRC’s Code of Practice 9 is the civil procedure HMRC uses when it suspects you have deliberately underpaid tax. It offers a way to resolve serious tax fraud without criminal prosecution: through the Contractual Disclosure Facility (CDF), you make a full confession of every tax irregularity, and HMRC agrees not to open a criminal investigation into the conduct you disclose.1HM Revenue & Customs. Code of Practice 9 – HM Revenue and Customs Investigation Where We Suspect Tax Fraud The settlement then covers all unpaid tax, interest, and penalties. Getting the response wrong, or ignoring the letter, can turn a financial settlement into a criminal case.

What the Contractual Disclosure Facility Gives You

The CDF is the contract at the centre of every COP9 case. You commit to a complete, honest disclosure of every tax irregularity, deliberate and non-deliberate; HMRC commits not to criminally investigate the conduct you disclose.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud It applies across the taxes and duties HMRC administers, including Income Tax, Corporation Tax, and VAT.3GOV.UK. Admit Tax Fraud to HMRC Using the Contractual Disclosure Facility

The protection has two limits worth knowing before you sign anything. If HMRC finds you lied, withheld information, or gave a misleading disclosure, it can revoke the immunity and use what you said against you in criminal proceedings.4HM Revenue & Customs. Fraud Civil Investigation Manual – FCIM104050 And the immunity is personal to you. HMRC is not bound to extend the same protection to a business partner, co-director, or anyone else your disclosure names, and can pursue them separately, including criminally.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud

Your 60-Day Decision

You have 60 calendar days from the date you receive the CDF letter to respond. HMRC gives you two formal options, not three: accept the offer, or reject it.3GOV.UK. Admit Tax Fraud to HMRC Using the Contractual Disclosure Facility

Accepting

Accepting means you formally admit that your tax discrepancies resulted from deliberate behaviour. You are signing an admission of tax fraud. In return, HMRC agrees not to prosecute you for the conduct you disclose, provided your disclosure is complete and honest. You must also submit an Outline Disclosure inside the same 60-day window.1HM Revenue & Customs. Code of Practice 9 – HM Revenue and Customs Investigation Where We Suspect Tax Fraud

Rejecting

Rejection is a formal denial of deliberate conduct. If your rejection does not satisfactorily address HMRC’s suspicions, HMRC may start a criminal investigation.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud Even if HMRC proceeds civilly at first, it reserves the right to escalate later. Anything you write in your rejection, and any documents you provide with it, can be used as evidence in court.

Ignoring the Letter

Silence is treated as rejection. If the 60-day deadline passes without a response, HMRC may begin a criminal investigation into the suspected fraud.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud You lose the CDF’s protection without gaining anything. HMRC already suspects you of deliberate fraud before sending the letter, and it usually has evidence to support that suspicion.

The Outline Disclosure

The Outline Disclosure is the first substantive document you send. It must accompany your acceptance form within the 60-day window and serves as a high-level summary of what went wrong.1HM Revenue & Customs. Code of Practice 9 – HM Revenue and Customs Investigation Where We Suspect Tax Fraud It should describe the deliberate behaviour honestly, identify the tax periods involved, and give a preliminary estimate of the tax owed.

Precise figures are not expected at this stage. The Outline Disclosure should reflect the best of your recollection with whatever documents you can gather inside 60 days.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud Detailed work comes later. What matters is honesty. If HMRC treats the Outline Disclosure as invalid because it is vague, incomplete, or dishonest, you have breached the contract and lost the protection from criminal investigation.4HM Revenue & Customs. Fraud Civil Investigation Manual – FCIM104050

The Full Disclosure Report

Where the irregularities are complex, HMRC will expect a full Disclosure Report: an exhaustive account of your financial history covering both deliberate and non-deliberate irregularities. A typical report includes a brief business history, a description of every irregularity and how it happened, a quantification of the amounts owed, the methodology behind the figures, and summaries of all tax, duty, interest, and penalties due.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud It must cover every capacity in which you acted, whether as an individual, sole trader, director, trustee, or partner, and it must explain your relationship with any companies, trusts, nominees, or partnerships you used.

Including non-deliberate errors is as important as disclosing the deliberate conduct. Careless mistakes and innocent misunderstandings of tax law all belong in the report. That way the final settlement covers every potential liability and HMRC cannot reopen the case over something you left out.

The Four Mandatory Documents

To complete the Formal Disclosure, you sign four documents on templates provided by HMRC. They cannot be amended:2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud

  • A Certified Statement of worldwide assets and liabilities.
  • A Certificate and Schedule of all financial accounts operated.
  • A Certificate and Schedule of all financial cards operated.
  • A Certificate of Full Disclosure, signed with your signature witnessed, declaring that your disclosure is complete, accurate, and honest.

The first three normally accompany the Disclosure Report, though HMRC can request them earlier. Signing the Certificate of Full Disclosure means you have met your obligations under the CDF contract, though it does not necessarily mark the end of the investigation.

How Penalties Are Calculated

Penalties under COP9 follow Schedule 24 of the Finance Act 2007. The starting penalty depends on the type of behaviour that caused the inaccuracy, expressed as a percentage of the “potential lost revenue”, meaning the tax that should have been paid.5Legislation.gov.uk. Finance Act 2007 – Schedule 24

For domestic matters, the standard rates are 30% for careless inaccuracy, 70% for deliberate but not concealed, and 100% for deliberate and concealed. Those are starting points. HMRC must reduce the penalty based on the quality of your disclosure, judged on how fully you told HMRC about the inaccuracy, how much you helped quantify it, and how readily you gave access to records. Reductions are larger for “unprompted” disclosures (before HMRC found the problem) than for “prompted” ones, and COP9 disclosures are prompted.6Legislation.gov.uk. Finance Act 2007 – Schedule 24 – Reductions for Disclosure

For prompted disclosures in domestic matters, the minimum penalties after reduction are 15% (careless), 35% (deliberate not concealed), and 50% (deliberate and concealed). In practical terms, full and genuine cooperation can halve your penalty. A well-organised Disclosure Report with clear cross-referencing to supporting documents demonstrates the cooperation that drives reductions; a grudging one does the opposite.

Offshore Cases

COP9 cases involving offshore income or assets attract significantly steeper penalties. Schedule 24 applies higher standard rates for “offshore matters” depending on the territory, with the worst rates for jurisdictions that do not share tax information with the UK. Standard penalties for deliberate and concealed offshore inaccuracies can reach 200% of the potential lost revenue.6Legislation.gov.uk. Finance Act 2007 – Schedule 24 – Reductions for Disclosure A separate regime, the “Requirement to Correct” introduced by the Finance (No. 2) Act 2017, adds further penalties where historic offshore non-compliance was not corrected by 30 September 2018; the standard penalty is 200% of the potential lost revenue, with a minimum of 100% for voluntary disclosure and 150% otherwise, and it can stack on top of the Schedule 24 penalty.7HM Revenue & Customs. Compliance Handbook – CH123405 – Offshore Matters – Requirement to Correct – Failure to Correct – Penalties – Amount of the Penalty

How Far Back HMRC Can Assess

In cases involving deliberate tax loss, HMRC can go back 20 years from the end of the relevant tax year, compared with the standard 4-year window for simple errors and 6 years for careless mistakes.8HM Revenue & Customs. Enquiry Manual – EM3214 – Sections 34 and 36, TMA 1970 Undeclared income from 18 years ago is still within scope. This is one reason the Disclosure Report can grow so large: HMRC expects you to reconstruct your tax position across every year in which irregularities occurred. Where records are genuinely missing, reasonable estimates supported by whatever evidence exists are expected rather than blanks.

What Happens After You Disclose

HMRC’s Fraud Investigation Service conducts a detailed technical review of the disclosure. Officials may ask to interview you about the report, and you are entitled to have your adviser present.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud HMRC will also cross-check your disclosure against third-party information from banks, financial providers, customers, and suppliers, using its statutory powers to obtain records. Discrepancies will need to be explained or corrected.

HMRC acknowledges no fixed timeline; duration depends on complexity and volume.1HM Revenue & Customs. Code of Practice 9 – HM Revenue and Customs Investigation Where We Suspect Tax Fraud Complex cases commonly run for several years. Once HMRC is satisfied, you agree the financial settlement covering all outstanding tax, duty, interest, and penalties, and make a formal offer to resolve the investigation.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud HMRC’s acceptance of that offer legally ends the investigation, provided you pay according to the agreed terms.

Paying the Settlement

HMRC expects payment in full once the settlement figure is agreed. If you cannot pay immediately, HMRC will consider a Time to Pay arrangement. Payments can be spread over up to five years without needing to demonstrate affordability, and longer arrangements may be agreed in individual cases.9GOV.UK. HMRC Loan Charge Review – Technical Note Interest continues to accrue on the unpaid balance during any arrangement.

Defaulting triggers HMRC’s full enforcement powers, including taking control of possessions, charging orders against property, adjusting your PAYE code, and direct recovery from bank accounts where the debt exceeds £1,000.10GOV.UK. What Will Happen If You Do Not Pay Your Tax Bill HMRC also has international recovery agreements with more than 87 countries, so foreign residence or overseas assets do not put you out of reach. As a last resort, HMRC can petition for bankruptcy, or for a winding-up order against a company.

Getting Professional Help

HMRC itself advises you to seek independent professional advice before responding to a COP9 letter, and suggests many people find it useful to appoint an adviser who specialises in COP9 in addition to their regular accountant.2GOV.UK. Code of Practice 9 – Where HMRC Suspects Fraud If you authorise an adviser using HMRC’s standard forms, HMRC will deal with them directly on COP9 matters. You remain personally responsible for the accuracy of everything submitted on your behalf, including the Disclosure Report your adviser prepares. The cost of representation cannot normally be claimed as a tax-deductible expense, which is worth weighing against the alternative: navigating a fraud investigation without expert help, where a single misstep in your disclosure can strip away your immunity from prosecution.