What Is a Security-Based Swap? Definition, Types, and Regulators

A security-based swap is a derivative contract whose value is tied to a single security, a single loan, or a narrow-based security index. The category matters because of who regulates it: the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 placed these contracts under the Securities and Exchange Commission, while swaps on broad indices, interest rates, and commodities stay with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. If the reference point of a derivative is one issuer or a tightly concentrated basket, it is almost certainly a security-based swap, and SEC rules on registration, reporting, execution, and clearing apply to it.

How the Law Defines It

Section 3(a)(68) of the Securities Exchange Act sets the definition. A contract qualifies if it first meets the general swap definition under the Commodity Exchange Act and then is based on any one of three things:

  • A narrow-based security index, including any interest in or value derived from that index.
  • A single security or loan, including any interest in or value derived from it.
  • The occurrence or nonoccurrence of an event relating to a single issuer (or the issuers in a narrow-based index), where that event directly affects the issuer’s financial statements, financial condition, or financial obligations.

That third trigger is what pulls single-name credit default swaps into SEC territory. A CDS payout fired by a specific company’s bankruptcy is, by definition, triggered by an event directly affecting one issuer’s financial obligations.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 78c Definitions and Application

The statute also recognizes “mixed swaps.” These meet the security-based swap definition but also reference something outside it, such as an interest rate, currency, or commodity. Mixed swaps are jointly overseen by the SEC and CFTC.2SEC.gov. Security-Based Swap Markets

When an Index Counts as Narrow-Based

A swap on the S&P 500 is a regular swap under CFTC jurisdiction. A swap on a small or concentrated basket is a security-based swap under SEC jurisdiction. The dividing line comes from four quantitative tests in Section 3(a)(55)(B) of the Securities Exchange Act. An index is narrow-based if it fails any one of them:

  • It has nine or fewer component securities.
  • Any single component accounts for more than 30 percent of the index’s weighting.
  • The top five components together account for more than 60 percent of the weighting.
  • The lowest-weighted components that collectively make up 25 percent of the index have a combined average daily trading volume below $50 million (or $30 million if the index has 15 or more components).

Tripping even one test is enough.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 78c Definitions and Application The liquidity test catches people off guard. An index can have 20 components with no stock dominating the weighting and still be classified as narrow-based because the bottom quarter by weight trades thinly.

The Main Types in Practice

Single-Name Credit Default Swaps

The single-name CDS is the most prominent security-based swap. A protection buyer pays periodic premiums, usually quoted in basis points of the notional amount, to a protection seller. The seller agrees to compensate the buyer if a defined credit event, typically bankruptcy or failure to pay, occurs on a specific issuer’s debt. Because the contract references one issuer’s obligations, it sits squarely inside the SEC’s security-based swap jurisdiction.

These contracts figured heavily in the 2008 financial crisis, which is a central reason Dodd-Frank brought them under federal oversight. Before 2010, single-name CDS traded with no public reporting, no central clearing, and no dealer registration.

Equity Swaps on a Single Stock or Narrow Index

An equity swap lets two parties exchange the total return of a stock or index for a fixed or floating rate payment. One side receives price appreciation and dividends while paying something like SOFR plus a spread; the other side takes the opposite position. The party on the total-return side gets synthetic exposure to the equity without owning it.

If the underlying is a single stock or a narrow-based index, the equity swap is a security-based swap. If the underlying is a broad-based index, the contract falls under CFTC jurisdiction instead.

Mixed Swaps

Some contracts straddle the categories. A swap that pays out based on the credit risk of a single issuer and also references a foreign currency exchange rate meets the security-based swap definition but reaches beyond it. Those contracts are mixed swaps and answer to both the SEC and the CFTC.2SEC.gov. Security-Based Swap Markets

Who Regulates Security-Based Swaps

Title VII of Dodd-Frank built the regulatory architecture. The SEC regulates security-based swaps. The CFTC regulates the broader swap market, including contracts on broad-based indices, interest rates, and commodities. The two agencies share authority over mixed swaps.2SEC.gov. Security-Based Swap Markets The core compliance dates landed in late 2021, with dealer registration taking effect on October 6, 2021, and transaction reporting under Regulation SBSR beginning on November 8, 2021.3SEC.gov. Data Collection Initiation Date and Contingent Phase-In Termination

Three regulatory requirements shape the market. Dealers and large non-dealer participants must register with the SEC under Section 15F of the Exchange Act and comply with capital, margin, business conduct, and recordkeeping rules. Every transaction must be reported to a registered Security-Based Swap Data Repository under Regulation SBSR, with much of that data publicly disseminated.4SEC.gov. Regulation SBSR – Reporting and Dissemination of Security-Based Swap Information And security-based swaps subject to a trade execution requirement must be executed on a registered Security-Based Swap Execution Facility or a national securities exchange, under rules the SEC finalized in November 2023 that took effect February 13, 2024.5SEC.gov. Rules Relating to Security-Based Swap Execution and Registration of Security-Based Swap Execution Facilities

The SEC also has authority under Section 3C of the Securities Exchange Act to require that certain security-based swaps be cleared through a central clearinghouse, which stands between the counterparties and guarantees both sides of the trade. Which specific products must be cleared continues to develop through SEC review. Commercial end-users that use swaps to hedge business risk can elect out of mandatory clearing if they meet the conditions in Section 3C(g), including not being a “financial entity” and notifying the SEC how they generally meet obligations on non-cleared trades.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 78c-3 – Clearing for Security-Based Swaps

How They’re Taxed

Security-based swaps do not get the 60/40 tax treatment that applies to Section 1256 contracts. The Internal Revenue Code explicitly excludes equity swaps, credit default swaps, equity index swaps, and similar agreements from the Section 1256 definition.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1256 – Section 1256 Contracts Marked to Market Gains and losses are generally taxed at ordinary income rates rather than the blended capital gains rate futures traders receive. Character and timing turn on the specific terms of the swap and how the taxpayer uses it, so the analysis for any particular position can get complicated.