A private road maintenance agreement is a recorded contract among the property owners who share a private road, setting out who pays for upkeep, how repair decisions get made, and what happens when an owner refuses to contribute. If you own or are buying a home reached by a private road, this document matters for a very practical reason: most mortgage lenders require one before they’ll fund the loan, and without it the road itself tends to fall apart because no one has a clear obligation to fix it.
When Your Lender Requires One
The mortgage process is where most buyers first run into this requirement. Rules differ sharply by loan program, so the type of financing you’re using drives whether an agreement is mandatory, merely expected, or technically optional.
Conventional Loans (Fannie Mae)
Fannie Mae has the strictest rule. For any property on a community-owned or privately maintained street, the lender must confirm that an adequate, legally enforceable agreement or covenant for road maintenance exists and is recorded in the local land records. The agreement has to spell out each owner’s share of repair costs, the remedies when an owner fails to pay, and a term that is perpetual and binds future owners.1Fannie Mae. Site Section of the Appraisal Report
There is one exception. If your state has a statute that already defines property owners’ responsibilities for maintaining private roads, a separate agreement isn’t required.1Fannie Mae. Site Section of the Appraisal Report A lender can also sell a loan to Fannie Mae without a conforming agreement, but only by agreeing to cover any losses Fannie Mae incurs from the road’s condition or access problems. That indemnification exposure is why most lenders insist on the agreement anyway.
FHA Loans
FHA doesn’t explicitly require a maintenance agreement. It requires that private streets be protected by permanent recorded easements and provide all-weather access, meaning a surface that supports emergency vehicles and typical passenger cars in any weather.2U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. HUD HOC Reference Guide – Private Roadways In practice, many FHA lenders still want to see an agreement, because it gives them confidence the all-weather standard will hold up over time.
VA Loans
The VA dropped its maintenance agreement requirement in 2022. Under Circular 26-22-17, properties on private roads or shared driveways no longer need a joint maintenance agreement or HOA agreement; the only requirement is a recorded permanent easement or right-of-way from the property to a public road.3Department of Veterans Affairs. Circular 26-22-17 – Private Roads and Shared Driveways That change made VA financing on private-road properties much easier to close.
USDA Loans
USDA rural development loans follow a model similar to FHA, generally requiring permanent recorded easements for ingress and egress rather than a formal maintenance agreement. Given that USDA loans target rural properties where private roads are common, the lighter requirement is a practical fit.
What the Agreement Needs to Cover
A workable agreement goes well beyond a handshake promise to split costs. The more specific the document, the fewer disputes it produces, and the more likely it is to satisfy a lender’s review.
Scope of Maintenance
The document should distinguish routine upkeep (grading a gravel surface, filling potholes, clearing drainage, managing roadside vegetation) from major work (full repaving, culvert replacement, significant drainage projects). Snow and ice removal belongs in its own section, with a trigger point such as a defined snowfall accumulation and a named plowing service or decision-maker. Without those distinctions, every project turns into an argument about which bucket it falls into.
Cost Allocation
There are a few common approaches, each with trade-offs:
- Equal shares. Every owner pays the same amount. Simple to administer.
- Road frontage. Each owner’s share is proportional to the length of road bordering their property.
- Usage-based. Owners who generate more traffic pay more. Logical but hard to measure, and prone to disputes.
The agreement also needs to say how money is collected. Some associations build a reserve through annual assessments so funds are ready when a major repair comes due. Others collect only when a specific need arises, which is simpler but can produce large, unexpected bills at repaving time.
Consequences for Nonpayment
Enforcement is what gives the agreement teeth. Typical mechanisms include late fees, suspension of voting rights, and in some agreements the right to record a lien against a delinquent owner’s property. Whether a lien provision is enforceable depends on state law and how the clause is drafted, which is one reason this document shouldn’t be assembled from a template.
Decision-Making and Dispute Resolution
Spell out how repair decisions get made. A majority vote of owners is common for routine matters, with a supermajority (often two-thirds) for major expenses or amendments to the agreement. One vote per owner is standard, and allowing proxy voting keeps decisions from stalling when someone is away. For disputes that can’t be resolved by vote, require mediation or binding arbitration before any lawsuit. Litigation among neighbors over a shared road is expensive and corrosive, and a mandatory mediation clause keeps most conflicts out of court.
Running With the Land
The single most important clause makes the agreement “run with the land.” That legal concept binds not just the current signers but every future owner of every property covered. Without it, the agreement effectively dies as properties change hands. To run with the land, a covenant generally must be in writing, express clear intent to bind future owners, and relate directly to the use of the property. Recording the agreement with the county ensures future buyers have notice of it.
Emergency Access
The agreement should require that the road remain passable for fire apparatus and ambulances at all times, and reference the local fire code standards your jurisdiction applies. If maintenance slips below those standards, you can face code enforcement issues, and insurance carriers may question coverage for losses that responders couldn’t reach.4ICC Digital Codes. Appendix D: Fire Apparatus Access Roads
What Happens Without an Agreement
The financing hit comes first. Without a recorded maintenance agreement, conventional Fannie Mae loans are essentially off the table unless the lender agrees to indemnify Fannie Mae, which most won’t do.1Fannie Mae. Site Section of the Appraisal Report That eliminates the largest pool of mortgage products in the country, shrinks the buyer pool for your property, and pulls down its market value. FHA and VA may still work, but even FHA lenders often want to see an agreement.
Then the road deteriorates. With no mechanism to collect money or schedule repairs, maintenance depends on whoever volunteers or pays out of pocket. That burden tends to fall on one or two owners, which breeds resentment, and the remaining owners either don’t notice, don’t care, or can’t afford to contribute. Nothing in place compels them.
Shared roads also create shared liability. If a visitor is hurt in a crash caused by a known pothole, or a delivery driver damages their vehicle on a washout, owners along the road can face negligence claims under ordinary premises liability rules. An agreement helps by assigning clear responsibility for inspections and repairs; without one, injured parties tend to sue every owner and let a court sort out who should have done what. Some road associations also carry a shared liability insurance policy, which is worth discussing with an insurance agent.
How to Put an Agreement in Place
Start by identifying every property owner who uses or has an easement over the road. That includes owners whose land fronts the road and anyone further back who crosses it to reach a public road. Missing even one owner weakens the agreement, because that person isn’t bound and can’t be compelled to pay.
Hold a meeting to work through the core terms: cost-sharing method, current and anticipated maintenance needs, voting rules, and dispute procedures. Bring real cost estimates from a paving or grading contractor so the conversation is grounded in actual numbers.
Then hire a real estate attorney to draft the document. Skip the internet templates. The attorney needs to make the agreement satisfy Fannie Mae’s requirements in case any owner ever wants a conventional mortgage, comply with your state’s rules on easements and covenants, and include a properly drafted “runs with the land” clause. Fees vary by complexity and location but commonly run from a few hundred dollars to $1,500 or more, usually split among participating owners.
Every owner signs, signatures get notarized, and the final document is recorded with your county’s land records office (sometimes called the Recorder of Deeds or County Clerk). Recording is what makes the agreement enforceable against future buyers. An unrecorded agreement may bind the current signers but offers no protection when properties change hands.
When a Neighbor Won’t Sign
This is where most agreements stall. You can’t force a neighbor to sign a contract, so you work with the options you have.
Check whether your state has a statute that assigns maintenance obligations to easement holders regardless of any agreement. In those states, you can pursue a non-participating owner’s share through small claims court or a contribution action without their signature.
If no such statute helps, the remaining owners can sign among themselves. The holdout isn’t bound, but the signers and their future buyers are, and the arrangement may satisfy a lender for the participating properties. The holdout’s own property will likely be harder to sell or finance, which sometimes changes the calculation.
If the road is actively deteriorating and a neighbor refuses to contribute, some states let the other owners perform the work and sue the non-contributing owner for their proportionate share. The rules for recovering those costs vary significantly from state to state, so this is the point where a real estate attorney’s advice is worth the fee.