What Is a National Sales Tax? Rate, Prebate, and How It Works

A national sales tax is a proposed federal tax collected at the register on nearly everything you buy, designed to replace the federal income tax and several other federal taxes. The most prominent version, the FairTax Act (H.R. 25), would impose a 23% tax-inclusive rate on most new goods and services beginning in 2027 and eliminate federal income, payroll, estate, and gift taxes in the process.1Congress.gov. H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025 Instead of taxing what you earn, the government would tax what you spend. Every legal resident household would receive a monthly “prebate” check to cover the tax on basic necessities, and the IRS would eventually shut down.

How the Tax Would Be Collected

The mechanics look a lot like state sales tax. Retailers collect the tax when you buy something and send it to the Treasury. You would see the tax printed on your receipt. No annual filing, no withholding from your paycheck, no April deadline for individuals.

Under the FairTax Act, the tax applies to any new property and any service purchased for personal use.2Congress.gov. Text – H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025 Used goods are exempt, so buying a secondhand car or a previously owned home would not trigger the federal tax. Business-to-business purchases, exports, and investment purchases are also excluded so the tax does not compound through the supply chain. The goal is to capture revenue once, at the point a product or service reaches its final consumer.

States would administer and collect the federal tax, piggybacking on the infrastructure they already use for their own sales taxes.1Congress.gov. H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025 The IRS would be defunded after 2027 and replaced by a smaller Sales Tax Bureau within the Treasury Department.

What the 23% Rate Actually Means

The FairTax Act sets a 23% tax-inclusive rate, which is a 30% tax-exclusive rate.1Congress.gov. H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025 Those two numbers describe the same tax measured different ways, and the distinction is a common source of confusion.

If you buy something for $100 total, $23 of that is the tax and $77 is the price of the item. Measured as a share of the total price (the way income tax rates are usually described), the rate is 23%. Measured as a percentage of the pre-tax price (the way state sales taxes are typically displayed), $23 on a $77 item is about 30%. Neither number is wrong. Proponents use the 23% inclusive figure to compare it against income tax rates. Critics prefer the 30% exclusive figure because that is how consumers see sales tax at the register.

The rate has to be high because a single consumption tax must replace revenue currently generated by income, payroll, estate, and gift taxes combined. Some economic analyses suggest the rate needed for true revenue neutrality would be somewhat higher than 23% inclusive once real-world evasion and carve-outs are accounted for. State and local sales taxes still apply on top, ranging up to roughly 10% depending on where you live, so the combined rate a shopper actually faces would be well above 30% in most of the country.

What Would and Wouldn’t Be Taxed

To generate enough revenue, the tax base has to be broad. The FairTax reaches virtually all new goods and services purchased for personal consumption, including categories most state sales taxes leave alone.2Congress.gov. Text – H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025 Healthcare services, newly constructed homes, and financial services would all carry the federal tax. Tuition for primary, secondary, and postsecondary education is carved out as “education and training,” though room, board, and extracurricular activities are not.

Used property of any kind is exempt. Buy a new car and you pay the 23% inclusive tax. Buy that same car from its second owner five years later and you pay nothing to the federal government. This would create a significant price gap between new and used goods that does not exist at the federal level today.

Digital goods and streaming services are not called out by name in the bill, but the broad definition of taxable services would likely reach them. The statute defines taxable property and services expansively: any property that is not intangible or used, and any service.2Congress.gov. Text – H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025 Intangible property is excluded from the property definition; services, including digital ones, appear to remain taxable.

The Prebate

The prebate is the mechanism designed to keep a flat consumption tax from crushing low-income households. Poorer families spend nearly all of what they earn; wealthier families save or invest a larger share. Without an offset, a family that earns $40,000 and spends all of it would effectively pay a 23% federal rate, while a family that earns $400,000 and spends half would face an effective rate of only 11.5%.

The FairTax Act addresses this by sending every qualified household a monthly check in advance, calculated to cover the tax on spending up to the federal poverty level. The bill calls this the Family Consumption Allowance.2Congress.gov. Text – H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025 The formula takes the annual poverty level for your family size, multiplies by the 23% tax rate, and divides by twelve. Using 2026 federal poverty guidelines, a family of four with a poverty level of $33,000 would receive about $633 per month.3HealthCare.gov. Federal Poverty Level (FPL)

Every household receives the same prebate regardless of income, so a billionaire gets the same monthly check as a minimum-wage worker. The effect is that consumption up to the poverty level is tax-free for everyone, and spending above that level is taxed at the full rate. To qualify, every family member must have a Social Security number and be a lawful U.S. resident.1Congress.gov. H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025

How It Differs From the Income Tax

The income tax reaches your earnings: wages, investment returns, business profits, capital gains. A national sales tax ignores all of that. You could earn a million dollars in a year and owe nothing to the federal government until you spent it. Savings, investments, and wealth accumulation would be untaxed as long as the money stayed unspent.

That is a fundamental shift in what the government incentivizes. The current system takes a cut of every dollar earned. A consumption tax discourages spending instead, which proponents argue makes it more economically efficient by removing distortions in labor and investment decisions.

The compliance change is just as dramatic. The income tax requires employer withholding, individual tracking of deductions, and IRS processing of over 150 million returns a year. Under a national sales tax, individuals would have no filing obligation at all. Retailers would handle everything. The tradeoff is that retailers absorb a much larger compliance burden, and the federal government becomes completely dependent on retail businesses for its revenue.

How It Differs From a Value-Added Tax

A national sales tax and a value-added tax (VAT) both tax consumption, but they collect the money in very different ways. A retail sales tax collects the entire amount at one point: the final sale to the consumer. A VAT collects it in pieces at every stage of production and distribution, with each business paying tax on its sales and claiming a credit for tax paid on its purchases.

The practical difference matters most for enforcement. Under a retail sales tax, the government has one shot at collecting the money. If the retailer underreports or pockets the tax, there is no cross-check because neither the consumer nor any upstream business has a reason to report the transaction. Under a VAT, every business in the chain wants documentation of the tax it paid on inputs so it can claim its credit, creating a built-in paper trail in which each participant has a financial incentive to make sure the others report honestly.

This self-policing feature is a major reason most developed countries use a VAT rather than a high-rate retail sales tax. International experience suggests retail sales taxes become increasingly difficult to enforce as rates climb above 10%, because the incentive to evade grows faster than the government’s ability to audit. The proposed 30% tax-exclusive rate would be far higher than any successfully enforced retail sales tax in the world. A VAT is also typically embedded in the sticker price, while a national sales tax would be itemized separately on every receipt. Proponents consider that visibility a feature.

Main Criticisms

The distributional impact is the most common concern. Even with the prebate, analyses of the FairTax have found it would raise the tax burden on households in the bottom 90% of the income distribution while delivering large tax cuts to the wealthiest. The top 1% would benefit the most, because they currently pay high marginal rates on earnings but spend a relatively small share of their income on consumption. Eliminating taxes on investment income, capital gains, and estates is a substantial windfall for the very wealthy that the prebate does not offset.

Enforcement is another serious concern. The entire federal revenue system would depend on retail businesses voluntarily collecting and remitting the tax, with no withholding from paychecks and no cross-reporting. At a 30% tax-exclusive rate, off-the-books cash transactions, inflated business-purchase claims, and outright fraud all become more attractive.

The transition creates its own problem. People who spent decades paying income tax on their earnings and saving the after-tax remainder would face a second round of federal tax when they spend those savings under the new system. Retirees living off already-taxed savings would be hit especially hard. Any relief for them would narrow the tax base and push the required rate higher.

The 16th Amendment Requirement

The FairTax Act includes a finding that the 16th Amendment, which authorizes the federal income tax, should be repealed. If the amendment is not repealed within seven years of the bill’s enactment, the entire national sales tax system expires automatically.2Congress.gov. Text – H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025

This sunset exists because, without repeal, nothing would stop a future Congress from reimposing the income tax on top of the sales tax, leaving Americans with both. Repealing a constitutional amendment requires approval by two-thirds of both chambers of Congress and ratification by three-fourths of state legislatures. No amendment has been repealed since Prohibition ended in 1933. Critics argue the requirement makes the proposal functionally impossible, since the sales tax would sunset before the amendment process could realistically finish.

Where the Proposal Stands

The FairTax Act has been introduced in various forms for over two decades. The current version, H.R. 25 in the 119th Congress, was introduced on January 3, 2025, and referred to the House Committee on Ways and Means.1Congress.gov. H.R.25 – FairTax Act of 2025 The bill has not advanced beyond that referral. It has not received a committee hearing, markup, or floor vote. Whether the scale of the change it proposes represents bold reform or political impracticality depends entirely on whom you ask.