Home appraisers look for the facts that drive a property’s market value: its size and layout, the condition of its structure and major systems, any permanent improvements, obvious safety hazards, and how it stacks up against recently sold homes nearby. The appraiser’s job is to produce an independent opinion of value the lender can rely on, so almost everything they examine either feeds the comparison to other sales or flags a condition that could block the loan.
Comparable Sales Drive the Number
The valuation itself rests on the sales comparison approach. The appraiser pulls recently sold homes similar to yours in size, condition, location, and features, then adjusts for the differences to arrive at a value for your property. Fannie Mae requires a minimum of three closed comparable sales, ideally within the past 12 months.1Fannie Mae. Comparable Sales The report shows the straight-line distance from your property to each comparable and the directional indicator.
When recent sales are scarce, which happens often in rural areas or neighborhoods with unusual homes, the appraiser can use older sales but must explain why they remain the best available indicators of value.1Fannie Mae. Comparable Sales Adjustments go in both directions: an extra bathroom in your home adds value against a comparable without one; a renovated kitchen in a comparable subtracts value when yours is original. The final opinion sits inside the range those adjusted comparables establish.
Exterior and Structure
The walkthrough starts outside. The appraiser examines the foundation, walls, and overall structural integrity, noting visible foundation cracks, significant settling, or signs of water intrusion. Siding is evaluated for condition and quality. Windows get checked for operation and weather protection, and exterior doors are noted for their condition.
The roof matters more than most owners expect. The appraiser estimates its remaining useful life from the visible condition, roofing material, and approximate age. For FHA-insured loans, the roof must have at least two years of remaining physical life; if it does not, the appraiser flags it in the report.2HUD Archives. HOC Reference Guide – Roofs and Attics Missing shingles, visible leaks, or sagging sections all get documented and can require repair before the loan closes.
Interior Space and Square Footage
Inside, the appraiser verifies the total square footage and counts bedrooms and bathrooms against public records. The floor plan is assessed for functional utility: how rooms flow, whether the layout works for daily living, whether any quirks will limit resale appeal. Quality flooring, intact walls, and sound ceilings all help the valuation; drywall damage and heavily stained carpeting work against it.
Not every space counts toward the finished square footage. Under the ANSI Z765 standard commonly used in residential appraisals, a room must have a ceiling height of at least seven feet to be included in the finished area. Spaces below that, along with unfinished basements and unheated rooms, are excluded from the primary living area total. The appraiser may still assign some value to those spaces, but they are reported separately.
Accessory Dwelling Units
If your property includes an accessory dwelling unit, meaning a separate living space such as a guest house, garage apartment, or basement suite, the appraiser decides whether it fits inside a one-unit classification or pushes the property into multi-unit territory. Fannie Mae looks at factors like whether the ADU has its own utility meter, a separate entrance, a kitchen with a sink and stove hookup, and sleeping and bathing areas. The ADU must be smaller than the primary dwelling, and only one ADU is permitted on the parcel for the property to stay classified as a one-unit home.3Fannie Mae. Special Property Eligibility Considerations
Mechanical Systems
Appraisers are not home inspectors. They do not disassemble equipment, but they do confirm that the major systems are present and functioning. Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning get a basic operational check. The electrical panel is observed for modern standards: circuit breakers rather than an outdated fuse box, for instance. Plumbing gets a hands-on test. Faucets are run, toilets are flushed, and the appraiser watches for obvious leaks or poor water pressure.
A home without a working heat source or functional plumbing can fail minimum property requirements for federally backed loans. HUD’s standards require that heating, cooling, ventilation, and plumbing all meet or exceed building code.4eCFR. 24 CFR Part 200 Subpart S – Minimum Property Standards VA loans go further: the heating system must maintain at least 50 degrees Fahrenheit in areas with plumbing, and if the primary heat is a wood-burning stove, a conventional backup heating system must be permanently installed.5VA Home Loans. Basic MPR Checklist
Private Wells and Septic
Properties on private water and sewer face extra scrutiny. Under FHA rules, a domestic well must sit at least 50 feet from the septic tank and at least 100 feet from the drain field. Shared wells require 75 feet of separation from any sewage disposal element. Springs, lakes, rivers, and sand-point wells are not eligible water sources for FHA mortgage insurance.6U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook Know these distances before the appraiser arrives. A well too close to the septic system can stop the loan outright.
Health and Safety
Every appraisal includes a basic safety check, but the bar sits higher for government-backed loans. FHA, VA, and USDA all impose minimum property requirements beyond what a conventional appraisal considers. The appraiser looks for hazards to occupant health or safety, including inadequate ventilation, missing handrails where a fall is a real risk, and environmental contaminants on or near the property.4eCFR. 24 CFR Part 200 Subpart S – Minimum Property Standards
Working smoke detectors are required, typically on each level and in sleeping areas, consistent with local building code. Crawl spaces and attics must be accessible for visual inspection. Crawl spaces must have at least 18 inches of clearance, be free of debris, and have proper ventilation to prevent moisture damage and structural decay.7HUD.gov. FHA Appraisal and Underwriting Manual – Property Analysis For VA loans, the appraiser must also confirm each unit has a continuing supply of safe drinking water and adequate sewage disposal.5VA Home Loans. Basic MPR Checklist
Lead-Based Paint in Older Homes
In homes built before 1978, the appraiser checks for peeling, chipping, or flaking paint. Lead-based paint was widely used until the federal ban took effect in 1978, so deteriorating paint in older homes is treated as a potential lead hazard.8US EPA. How Can I Tell if My Home Contains Lead-Based Paint For FHA-insured loans, defective paint surfaces in a pre-1978 home must be repaired using lead-safe work practices before the loan can close. The rule covers all painted surfaces inside and out, not only those confirmed to contain lead, because testing every surface during an appraisal is not practical.
VA Termite Inspections
VA loans add a requirement other loan types do not. A wood-destroying pest inspection is required for properties in areas where the probability of termite infestation is classified as “very heavy” or “moderate to heavy” on the federal Termite Infestation Probability Map.9Veterans Benefits Administration. Circular 26-22-11 Active infestation or structural damage from past infestation usually triggers required treatment and repairs before the loan can move forward.
Permanent Improvements and Renovations
The appraiser documents additions and renovations that genuinely add value: finished basements, built-in decks, remodeled kitchens, bathroom upgrades. To count, the improvement has to be a permanent fixture, not personal property. A built-in deck adds value. A portable hot tub does not. A finished basement counts if it is integrated into the home’s heating system and meets ceiling height requirements; an unheated, unfinished space is reported separately.
The appraiser also notes whether major work appears to have been done with proper building permits. Unpermitted work, whether an enclosed porch, an added bedroom, or a converted garage, can be excluded from the valuation or create problems during the sale. If you have renovated, have permit records and contractor invoices ready for the appraiser.
Solar Panels
Solar panels are treated differently depending on ownership. If you bought the panels outright or have fully paid off any financing, the appraiser may include their value. If the panels are leased or covered by a power purchase agreement, their value cannot be included because you do not actually own them.10Fannie Mae Single Family. Appraising Properties With Solar Panels Panels financed through a loan where the panels themselves serve as collateral for that separate debt also do not contribute to appraised value. If ownership status is unclear, the lender may need to run a property records search before any value is attributed.
Neighborhood and Location
Factors outside your property line matter too. Proximity to schools, parks, shopping, employment centers, and public transportation all influence how your home compares to similar properties elsewhere. Nearby nuisances, including busy highways, commercial sites, environmental hazards, or visibly deteriorated properties, pull values down.
The comparable sales the appraiser chooses should come from the same neighborhood or a similar one, and the report lists the specific distance in miles between your property and each comparable, with the directional indicator.1Fannie Mae. Comparable Sales When the closest comparables are far away or in noticeably different neighborhoods, the appraiser must explain why they remain valid. Local market trends also factor in. The appraiser notes whether values in your area are rising, stable, or declining.
If the Number Comes in Low
A low appraisal creates a gap between your purchase price and what the lender will finance. On a $600,000 offer that appraises at $580,000, you would need to bring the extra $20,000 in cash, renegotiate the price with the seller, or walk away.
Most purchase contracts include an appraisal contingency that lets the buyer terminate and recover the earnest money deposit if the home appraises below contract price. Waive that contingency and you may be on the hook for the difference or lose your deposit.
If you think the appraisal contains errors, such as wrong square footage, missed upgrades, or poorly chosen comparables, you can request a reconsideration of value through your lender. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recognizes three valid grounds: factual errors or omissions, inadequate comparable properties, and evidence of prohibited bias.11Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Mortgage Borrowers Can Challenge Inaccurate Appraisals Through the Reconsideration of Value Process Federal interagency guidance encourages lenders to set clear timelines and procedures, though no specific federal deadline is mandated.12Federal Reserve. Interagency Guidance on Reconsiderations of Value of Residential Real Estate Valuations Gather supporting documentation such as overlooked comparable sales, permit records, or photos showing conditions the appraiser may have missed. Your lender submits the request. You cannot contact the appraiser directly.