Further audit procedures are the testing an auditor performs in response to the assessed risks of material misstatement, and they include two categories of work: tests of controls and substantive procedures. Substantive procedures themselves split into analytical procedures and tests of details. The auditor decides which procedures to run, when to run them, and how much testing is enough by matching each choice to the risk in the account or assertion being tested.1Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2301 – The Auditor’s Responses to the Risks of Material Misstatement
Nature, Timing, and Extent
Every further procedure gets designed along three dimensions. Nature is the type of procedure selected. A high-risk balance may warrant confirming amounts with a third party; a stable, predictable one may be tested well enough with an analytical procedure. Timing is when the work happens. Lower-risk accounts can sometimes be tested before year-end, while higher-risk areas are typically tested at or very close to the period-end date. Extent is sample size and coverage. Higher risk pushes toward larger samples, more locations, or in extreme cases every item in the population.
Under PCAOB standards, the auditor must design and perform procedures that respond to the assessed risks for each relevant assertion of each significant account and disclosure. The higher the assessed risk, the more persuasive the evidence needs to be.1Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2301 – The Auditor’s Responses to the Risks of Material Misstatement
Tests of Controls
Tests of controls evaluate whether the company’s internal controls actually work as intended. The auditor performs them when planning to rely on those controls to reduce the assessed control risk, which can make the audit more efficient for high-volume routines like sales processing or payroll.
Controls testing is mandatory in two situations. When the auditor plans to assess control risk below the maximum, the auditor must obtain evidence that the selected controls were designed effectively and operated effectively throughout the entire period of reliance. Tests of controls are also required whenever substantive procedures alone cannot supply enough evidence for a particular assertion, which commonly happens with highly automated systems where transaction data exists only in electronic form.1Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2301 – The Auditor’s Responses to the Risks of Material Misstatement
Four methods are used to test controls:
- Inquiry. Asking staff how a control is applied and under what circumstances.
- Observation. Watching personnel perform the control activity in real time.
- Inspection. Reviewing documentation that the control operated, such as a signed authorization, an exception report, or a system access log.
- Reperformance. The auditor independently executes the control step to verify it produces the expected result. This is the most persuasive method because it does not depend on the client’s own records or explanations.
When a control fails during testing, the auditor can no longer rely on it. The practical consequence is a larger scope of substantive testing for every account balance that control was supposed to protect.
Substantive Procedures
Substantive procedures test the numbers directly rather than the process behind them. The auditor must perform substantive procedures for each relevant assertion of each significant account and disclosure, regardless of the assessed level of control risk. Even when controls are excellent, some direct testing of the numbers is always required.1Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2301 – The Auditor’s Responses to the Risks of Material Misstatement
Substantive work takes two forms: substantive analytical procedures and tests of details. Different combinations of the two can satisfy the evidence requirement for any given assertion, and the auditor picks the mix based on the account and the risk.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2305 – Substantive Analytical Procedures One important limit: for significant risks, the auditor must perform tests of details specifically responsive to those risks. Analytical procedures alone are not enough for the highest-risk areas.1Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2301 – The Auditor’s Responses to the Risks of Material Misstatement
Substantive Analytical Procedures
Analytical procedures build an independent expectation for what a balance or ratio should be, then compare that expectation to the recorded amount. They work best when the relationship between data points is predictable and the underlying data is reliable. For a stable manufacturer, comparing gross margins by product line against prior periods and known cost changes can flag misstatements efficiently.
An effective analytical procedure moves through four steps:
- Develop an expectation using prior-period data, industry benchmarks, known business changes, or non-financial data.
- Set a tolerable difference, meaning the maximum gap the auditor would accept without following up.
- Compare the recorded amount to the expectation and calculate the actual difference.
- Investigate any difference that exceeds the tolerable threshold to determine whether it reflects a misstatement or a legitimate business change.
Persuasiveness depends heavily on the precision of the expectation. An estimate built from detailed, independently verifiable data carries more weight than one built from unaudited internal forecasts. Disaggregated data, such as revenue by month and product line rather than a single annual total, generally produces a tighter expectation.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2305 – Substantive Analytical Procedures
Tests of Details
Tests of details examine the supporting documentation behind individual transactions or balances, linking the general ledger back to source documents. They carry more weight for accounts that are subjective, unpredictable, or involve complex estimates. Common techniques include:
- Confirmation. A direct written response from a third party, such as a bank confirmation for cash or a customer confirmation for accounts receivable.
- Inspection. Examining physical assets, such as counting inventory, or reviewing documents, such as a property deed to verify ownership.
- Recalculation. Independently verifying mathematical accuracy, such as recomputing depreciation expense or interest accruals.
Vouching Versus Tracing
Two techniques test opposing assertions, and the direction determines which. Vouching starts with a recorded transaction in the general ledger and works backward to the supporting source document. If a recorded sale can be traced back to a shipping document and a customer order, the auditor has evidence the transaction occurred. Vouching tests the existence assertion.
Tracing runs the other way. The auditor starts with a source document, such as a shipping report, and follows it forward into the general ledger to confirm it was recorded. If goods were shipped but never invoiced, tracing catches the gap. Tracing tests the completeness assertion. Mixing up the direction is where mistakes happen in practice.
Sampling
Examining every transaction is impractical for most accounts, so tests of details typically rely on sampling. The sample must be representative of the full population so results can be reasonably projected. Misstatements found in the sample get extrapolated to estimate the total likely error in the account, and that projected misstatement feeds into the overall evaluation of whether the financial statements are materially misstated.
Dual-Purpose Tests
A single test can sometimes satisfy both objectives at once. While testing whether sales transactions were properly authorized (a control), the auditor can also verify that recorded amounts agree to shipping documents (a substantive test). When performing a dual-purpose test, the auditor must evaluate the results separately for each objective, drawing conclusions about both the control’s effectiveness and the accuracy of the recorded amount.1Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2301 – The Auditor’s Responses to the Risks of Material Misstatement A control failure in the sample does not automatically mean the dollar amounts are wrong, and the reverse also holds, but both conclusions must be documented independently.
Interim Testing and Roll-Forward Procedures
Substantive procedures are sometimes performed before the balance sheet date to spread out the work and surface problems early. Interim testing creates a gap. If accounts receivable were tested as of September 30 but the financial statements are dated December 31, three months of activity went untested.
To close that gap, the auditor performs roll-forward procedures over the remaining period. These typically involve comparing balances at the interim date to year-end balances, investigating unusual changes, and running targeted testing on transactions during the remaining period. The higher the risk of misstatement, the less appropriate interim testing becomes. For significant risks, period-end testing is almost always necessary. If evidence from the remaining period contradicts earlier conclusions, the auditor must revise risk assessments and may need to repeat at year-end the procedures originally performed at the interim date.1Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2301 – The Auditor’s Responses to the Risks of Material Misstatement
Responding to Fraud Risks
Fraud risk changes what further procedures include. Beyond the standard work, the auditor is expected to build unpredictability into the audit so company personnel cannot anticipate exactly what will be tested and when. Predictable routines create opportunities for concealment.
Unpredictability enters through steps like surprise inventory observations on unannounced dates, cash counts without prior notice, testing accounts or locations normally considered immaterial, and adjusting sampling thresholds to levels the company would not expect.3Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2401 – Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit These elements should change from year to year, or they become predictable themselves.
Revenue recognition carries a presumed fraud risk under PCAOB standards. Common responses include comparing revenue by month and product line against prior periods, confirming contract terms directly with customers, inquiring about unusual sales arrangements near period-end, and physically observing shipping activity at the close of the reporting period.3Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 2401 – Consideration of Fraud in a Financial Statement Audit
Using Specialists
Some balances require expertise the audit team does not have. Fair value measurements of complex financial instruments, actuarial calculations for pension liabilities, and environmental remediation estimates commonly involve specialists. Under PCAOB standards, a specialist is someone with special skill or knowledge in a field other than accounting or auditing. Tax professionals and IT specialists who participate in the audit do not fall under this definition.4Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 1210 – Using the Work of an Auditor-Engaged Specialist
Before relying on a specialist’s work, the engagement partner assesses the specialist’s qualifications, including professional certifications, relevant experience, and reputation in the field. The auditor also evaluates the specialist’s objectivity, looking for any relationships with the company that could compromise impartial judgment. Using a specialist does not reduce the auditor’s responsibility. The auditor still evaluates whether the specialist’s work supports the conclusions about the relevant assertion.4Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AS 1210 – Using the Work of an Auditor-Engaged Specialist