What Are Improper Payments and What Happens If You Get One?

If you receive an improper payment from the federal government — money sent in the wrong amount, for the wrong reason, or to the wrong person — contact the agency that issued it as soon as you can, keep records of everything, and ask about repayment or waiver options before the debt gets handed off to the Treasury Department for collection. Most of these errors are administrative, not fraud, but ignoring one almost always makes it worse.

What Counts as an Improper Payment

An improper payment is any federal disbursement sent in the wrong amount, to the wrong recipient, or for the wrong reason. The category also covers payments the agency cannot verify because paperwork is missing or incomplete, even when the recipient was actually eligible.1U.S. Department of Labor. DOL Payments Integrity Reporting Overview Overpayments and underpayments both qualify, as do payments to people who turned out to be ineligible.

Most improper payments are not fraud. In unemployment insurance, for instance, common causes include claimants misunderstanding state rules, missing records, and employers failing to respond to verification requests on time.1U.S. Department of Labor. DOL Payments Integrity Reporting Overview A payment can even look correct when it goes out and be reclassified later when new information surfaces. That distinction matters: administrative errors typically mean a request to return funds; fraud triggers criminal penalties.

First Step: Contact the Agency That Issued the Payment

Whether you spotted the extra money yourself or received a notice in the mail, the fastest path to resolution starts with the issuing agency. Before you call, pull together:

  • The payment amount and the date it hit your account
  • Any identifying number from the check stub, bank statement, or notice
  • Your original award letter, benefit statement, or contract showing what you were supposed to receive

Having these details in front of you lets the agency locate the transaction without a lot of back-and-forth. Most agencies run online portals and dedicated phone lines for payment discrepancies, and the specific process varies by program. For Social Security overpayments, the Social Security Administration takes reports through its online account system and at 1-800-772-1213.2Social Security Administration. Repay Overpaid Benefits

Don’t let a notice sit. The federal government has powerful collection tools, and delay narrows your options.

Repayment Options

You don’t have to pay the full amount back in a lump sum. Many agencies offer installment plans. Social Security lets you request a lower monthly recovery rate by submitting Form SSA-634, which you can upload through your online account.2Social Security Administration. Repay Overpaid Benefits If you no longer receive benefits, call to set up a payment plan or ask whether the agency will accept a settlement.

For other federal programs the mechanics differ, but the principle is the same: ask about repayment terms before the debt is referred to the Treasury Department for collection.

When You Can Request a Waiver

If the overpayment wasn’t your fault, you may not have to repay it at all. Federal law provides a waiver process for Social Security overpayments: the agency will not pursue recovery if you were “without fault” and if recovery would either defeat the purpose of the program or be against equity and good conscience.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 USC 404 – Overpayments and Underpayments

The “without fault” determination weighs several things: whether you understood your reporting obligations, whether you knew about events that should have been reported, what efforts you made to comply, and any physical, mental, educational, or language limitations affecting your ability to comply.4Social Security Administration. 408.912 When Are You Without Fault Regarding an Overpayment The agency’s own mistake doesn’t automatically clear you, but it’s a factor.

Deadlines matter. For federal employee pay overpayments, a waiver application must be filed within three years of the date the erroneous payment was discovered.5Office of Personnel Management. Fact Sheet – Waiving Overpayments Check the specific program’s rules; waiver standards and windows differ.

What Happens If You Ignore the Notice

An unpaid federal debt doesn’t go away. Once the issuing agency determines you owe money and you haven’t arranged to repay, the debt can be referred to the Treasury Offset Program. The program matches people with delinquent federal or state debts against outgoing federal payments and withholds funds to satisfy what’s owed. In fiscal year 2024, it recovered more than $3.8 billion.6Bureau of the Fiscal Service. Treasury Offset Program

For federal benefit payments like Social Security, the offset is capped at the lesser of three amounts: the full debt, 15 percent of your monthly benefit, or the amount by which your monthly benefit exceeds $750.7eCFR. 31 CFR 285.4 – Offset of Federal Benefit Payments to Collect Past-Due Debts Tax refunds can also be seized. The practical point: contact the agency first and negotiate, rather than waiting for the offset machinery to start pulling from your benefits or refund.

Tax Implications of Returning the Money

Returning an overpayment in the same calendar year you received it is usually simple at tax time. Repaying in a later year is where it gets tricky. If you included the overpayment as income on a prior year’s return and later repaid more than $3,000, the IRS lets you choose whichever method produces less tax: deduct the repaid amount on your current return, or recalculate the prior year’s tax without the income and claim the difference as a credit under the claim of right doctrine.8Internal Revenue Service. 21.6.6 Specific Claims and Other Issues – Section 21.6.6.2.10.2 Claim of Right IRC 1341

To use the credit, keep documentation showing the amount you had to repay, proof of actual repayment (canceled checks, bank statements, or paycheck deductions), and records showing how the income appeared on your original return. For repayments of $3,000 or less, you can only deduct the amount as an itemized deduction in the year you repaid it. If you received a Form 1099-G reporting the overpayment as income and have since returned the funds, contact the issuing agency and ask for a corrected form.

Why This Happens So Often

Receiving an improper payment doesn’t mean you’ve been accused of anything. In fiscal year 2025, federal agencies estimated roughly $186 billion in improper payments across 64 programs at 15 agencies.9U.S. Government Accountability Office. Agencies Estimated Improper Payments Increased to $186 Billion A large portion traces to administrative error and missing paperwork rather than wrongdoing by recipients. Treat a notice as a problem to resolve, not an accusation to fight, and work the process from the first phone call forward.