What Are Excess Business Holdings for Private Foundations?

A private foundation, combined with its disqualified persons, generally cannot own more than 20% of the voting stock of a for-profit business. Anything above that line counts as excess business holdings for private foundations, and Section 4943 of the Internal Revenue Code taxes it at 10% of the excess each year, escalating to 200% if the foundation does not sell down before the IRS acts. Neither tax is deductible.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 275 – Certain Taxes

What Counts as a Business Enterprise

The rule reaches any trade or business carried on for profit, in any legal form: corporation, partnership, LLC, or sole proprietorship. What matters is whether the activity produces income from selling goods or performing services rather than simply holding investments.

Two categories sit outside the definition entirely and therefore outside the ownership limits:3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings – Section: Definitions, Special Rules

  • A largely passive business, meaning any trade or business that earns at least 95% of its gross income from passive sources such as dividends, interest, rents, and royalties. A holding company collecting investment returns fits here.
  • A functionally related business that directly carries out the foundation’s charitable purpose. A foundation dedicated to job training that runs its own vocational workshop does not count that workshop against the cap.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4942 – Taxes on Failure to Distribute Income – Section: Functionally Related Business

Real estate is where the line gets tested. Passively collecting rent on a commercial building is fine. Developing property, negotiating leases, and managing tenants is an active business subject to the cap.

Who Counts Alongside the Foundation

The 20% ceiling is combined. The foundation’s own stake is added to whatever “disqualified persons” hold in the same company, which stops insiders from splitting shares between themselves and the foundation to slip under the line.

Disqualified persons under Section 4946 include:5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4946 – Definitions and Special Rules

  • Substantial contributors, meaning anyone who has given the foundation more than $5,000 in total when that amount also exceeds 2% of all contributions the foundation has ever received.6eCFR. 26 CFR 1.507-6 – Substantial Contributor Defined
  • Foundation managers, including officers, directors, trustees, and employees with authority over the relevant activity.
  • Anyone owning more than 20% of the voting power, profits interest, or beneficial interest in an entity that is itself a substantial contributor.
  • Family members of an individual disqualified person: spouse, ancestors, children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, and the spouses of those descendants. Siblings are not included.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4946 – Definitions and Special Rules – Section: Members of Family
  • Corporations, partnerships, or trusts in which disqualified persons hold more than 35% of voting power, profits interest, or beneficial interest.
  • For Section 4943 purposes, another private foundation effectively controlled by the same people or funded substantially by the same contributors.

The 20%, 35%, and 2% Thresholds

The base cap is 20% of voting stock in a corporation. For partnerships, the equivalent measure is profits interest; for trusts and other unincorporated ventures, it is beneficial interest.8Internal Revenue Service. Taxes on Excess Business Holdings Disqualified persons’ holdings fill the cap first, and whatever room is left is what the foundation may hold.

In practice: if disqualified persons hold 12% of a company’s voting stock, the foundation can hold up to 8% before creating excess. If the foundation actually holds 15%, then 7% is excess and taxable.

The 35% Rule When Outsiders Control the Business

The combined cap rises from 20% to 35% when the foundation can prove to the IRS that people who are not disqualified persons have effective control of the business.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings – Section: 35 Percent Rule Effective control means those independent parties have actual power to direct management and set policy. It is not enough that disqualified persons happen to hold a minority stake; the foundation has to affirmatively demonstrate outsiders run the company.

The 2% De Minimis Safe Harbor

A foundation has no excess holdings in a corporation where it (together with certain related private foundations) owns 2% or less of the voting stock and 2% or less of the value of all outstanding shares.10Internal Revenue Service. IRC Section 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings This safe harbor works independently of the 20% and 35% limits, so disqualified persons’ holdings do not matter here. A small investment position in a publicly traded company does not require tracking every insider’s separate holdings in the same stock.

Non-Voting Stock and Ownership Through Other Entities

Non-voting stock is treated differently depending on where voting control sits. If disqualified persons hold 20% or less of the voting stock, the foundation can hold non-voting stock freely. Once disqualified persons cross the 20% voting threshold, though, any non-voting stock the foundation holds also becomes excess.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings The design closes off a workaround where insiders take voting control and the foundation parks capital in non-voting shares.

Ownership through intermediaries also counts. If the foundation holds an interest in a partnership or trust, and that entity owns stock in a business enterprise, the foundation is treated as owning its proportionate share of the underlying business. The same proportional attribution applies to disqualified persons who hold their stakes through other entities.11Internal Revenue Service. Attribution of Ownership Rules – Definition of Disqualified Persons Foundations with layered investment structures have to trace through each layer to determine their true percentage in any given business.

The Taxes: 10% and 200%

The penalty structure escalates deliberately to push foundations toward quick disposition.

The Initial 10% Tax

The IRS imposes a tax equal to 10% of the value of the foundation’s excess business holdings for each tax year that ends during the taxable period.12Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings – Section: Initial Tax The value used is the peak amount of excess during the year, measured as of the day within the tax year when the excess was at its greatest.8Internal Revenue Service. Taxes on Excess Business Holdings Selling down partway through the year does not erase a tax already triggered.

The tax repeats every tax year the excess persists, so waiting is expensive.

The 200% Additional Tax

If excess holdings remain at the close of the taxable period, a second tax equal to 200% of the remaining excess applies.13Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings – Section: Additional Tax The penalty is severe enough that holding on to the excess costs more than selling at a loss.

Both taxes fall on the foundation itself. Unlike the self-dealing rules under Section 4941, Section 4943 does not impose a separate penalty on foundation managers personally.

Grace Period for Gifts and Bequests

Foundations often end up over the limit through a gift or bequest they had no hand in choosing. The tax code gives them five years to dispose of the excess without triggering the tax.14eCFR. 26 CFR 53.4943-6 – Five-Year Period to Dispose of Gifts, Bequests, Etc. During that window, the newly received interest is treated as if held by a disqualified person rather than the foundation, so it does not count toward the cap.

The grace period applies only to interests received by gift, bequest, or similar non-purchase means. A foundation that buys a business interest and creates excess in the process gets no grace period at all.

The five-year clock runs from the acquisition date, not from whenever the foundation notices the problem. A foundation receiving a business interest through an estate should start planning the disposition immediately, even while probate is ongoing.

The Five-Year Extension

For unusually large, diverse, or complex holdings, the IRS may grant a further five years, for ten in total. The foundation has to clear several hurdles before the initial window closes:15Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings – Section: 5-Year Extension

  • Show diligent efforts to sell during the first five years, and that a fair-price sale was not possible given the size or complexity of the interests.
  • Submit a written disposition plan to the IRS.
  • Send the same plan to the state attorney general or other official with supervisory authority over the foundation, and forward any response to the IRS.
  • Obtain an IRS determination that the plan can reasonably be carried out within the extension.

Closely held businesses without a ready pool of buyers are where extensions typically come up. A large block of stock in a family company cannot always be moved quickly without destroying its value.

The Philanthropic Business Exception

Section 4943(g), added by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, allows a private foundation to own 100% of a business if the arrangement genuinely channels all profits to charity with no insider involvement. The provision is sometimes called the Newman’s Own exception, after the food company and foundation whose structure prompted it.16Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 4943 – Taxes on Excess Business Holdings – Section: Exception for Certain Holdings Limited to Independently-Operated Philanthropic Business

Every condition must be met each tax year:

  • The foundation holds all voting stock in the business at all times during the year.
  • Every ownership interest was acquired by gift, bequest, or other non-purchase means.
  • The business distributes an amount equal to its net operating income to the foundation within 120 days after the close of its tax year. Net operating income is gross income minus directly connected deductions, income taxes owed by the business, and a reasonable working capital reserve.
  • No substantial contributor to the foundation, and no family member of a contributor, serves as a director, officer, manager, employee, or contractor of the business.
  • At least a majority of the foundation’s board consists of people who are not directors or officers of the business and are not family members of substantial contributors.
  • The business has no outstanding loans to substantial contributors or their family members.

The conditions are strict because the exception is powerful; it lets a foundation run a full commercial enterprise tax-free. Missing any requirement in a given year snaps the standard excess business holdings rules back into effect for that year, along with the 10% tax.

Asking the IRS to Waive the 10% Tax

Section 4962 gives the IRS discretion to abate the initial 10% tax when the foundation can show two things: the violation resulted from reasonable cause rather than willful neglect, and the excess was corrected within the required time frame.17Internal Revenue Service. Abatement of Chapter 42 First Tier Taxes Due to Reasonable Cause

The standard is ordinary business care and prudence, and it is harder to meet than many foundations expect. Not knowing about the rule is not enough. Relying on verbal advice from a tax advisor is not enough either; the IRS and courts look for a reasoned written legal opinion that addresses the specific issue.17Internal Revenue Service. Abatement of Chapter 42 First Tier Taxes Due to Reasonable Cause A foundation that receives a large stock bequest, immediately consults counsel, gets a written opinion, and starts pursuing buyers has a credible abatement case. A foundation that lets the problem sit for years does not.

The 200% follow-on tax is not eligible for reasonable-cause abatement in the same way; it is designed as the deadline, not as something to negotiate away.

Reporting and Ongoing Monitoring

Private foundations report their business holdings annually on Form 990-PF. A foundation that owes the 10% or 200% tax must also file Form 4720 to calculate and pay the penalty.18Internal Revenue Service. Private Foundation Excise Tax Return (Form 4720) This applies whether the excess came from a deliberate purchase or a surprise bequest.

Compliance is not a one-time review. A foundation that sits clean today can be in violation tomorrow if a disqualified person buys additional stock, a family member inherits shares, or the company issues new stock that shifts the ownership percentages. Foundations near the limit should track ownership changes among all disqualified persons at least quarterly and keep documentation of what they find.