What Are COI Requirements? Endorsements, Limits, and Traps

Certificate of insurance (COI) requirements are the coverage types, dollar limits, and policy endorsements you demand from a vendor, contractor, or tenant before they begin work or occupy space, documented on an ACORD 25 form and backed by the actual insurance policy behind it. Getting them right means two things at once: setting the correct minimums in your contract, and verifying that what arrives on the certificate reflects endorsements that genuinely exist on the policy. The certificate itself “confers no rights upon the certificate holder” and “does not constitute a contract” with the insurer. The policy language is what pays claims.

What a COI Actually Proves

A COI is a one-page snapshot of who is insured, by which carrier, for how much, and until when. It does not change, expand, or limit the underlying policy. Every standard COI carries a disclaimer stating it “does not affirmatively or negatively amend, extend or alter the coverage afforded by the policies below.” If the certificate says one thing and the policy says another, the policy controls.

That is why requirements have to reach past the certificate into the policy. The ACORD 25, maintained by the Association for Cooperative Operations Research and Development, gives you a uniform layout so you can find the same fields in the same places on any broker’s output. The description of operations box at the bottom is where endorsements get referenced, and it is the single most important free-text field on the form. A blank or vague description box means an incomplete certificate, no matter how healthy the limits look.

One housekeeping item before the substance: each listed insurer has an NAIC number, assigned by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, that lets you confirm the carrier is licensed.1National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Industry Financial Filing An insurer that cannot pay claims is worse than no insurer at all, so verification of the carrier belongs in your review.

Coverage Types and Minimum Limits

Your contract should name each policy type you require and set a floor for its limits. The common building blocks:

Commercial General Liability

CGL is the backbone of most COI requirements. The limits section includes several figures you need to specify:

  • Each Occurrence: the maximum the insurer pays for any single covered event. Contracts frequently require $1,000,000 per occurrence as a floor.
  • General Aggregate: the total the insurer pays for all covered claims during the policy period, typically $2,000,000.
  • Products-Completed Operations Aggregate: a separate aggregate for claims from products sold or work completed, also commonly $2,000,000.
  • Personal and Advertising Injury: coverage for claims like defamation or advertising-related copyright infringement, usually matching the per-occurrence limit.

A shortfall anywhere here is non-compliance. A vendor showing $500,000 per occurrence against a $1,000,000 contractual minimum has breached the agreement from day one.

Commercial Auto Liability

Auto coverage appears either as a combined single limit (CSL) or as split limits. A CSL is one dollar amount covering all bodily injury and property damage from a single accident. Split limits break that into a per-person injury cap, a per-accident injury cap, and a per-accident property damage cap. Most commercial contracts prefer a CSL because it is simpler to verify. A common minimum is $1,000,000 CSL.

Workers’ Compensation and Employer’s Liability

Workers’ compensation on a COI confirms statutory coverage in the state where work is performed. The statutory portion shows no dollar limit because it pays whatever state law requires. Employer’s liability does show limits, typically a per-accident limit, a disease policy limit, and a disease per-employee limit. Baseline figures are often $100,000/$500,000/$100,000, but contracts regularly require $1,000,000 across all three.

Umbrella or Excess Liability

When your total required limits exceed what the primary policies carry, umbrella or excess coverage fills the gap by sitting on top of the CGL, auto, and employer’s liability policies and paying after those underlying limits exhaust. If you require $5,000,000 total and the primary CGL provides $1,000,000 per occurrence, the umbrella needs to supply the remaining $4,000,000.

Dates That Cover the Whole Job

Every coverage row has effective and expiration dates. Confirm those dates span your entire contract period, not just the day the certificate was issued. A policy that expires two months into a twelve-month engagement is a compliance failure built in from the start.

Endorsements That Have to Be on the Policy

Limits are the easy part. The endorsements are where most disputes begin, because a reference in the description box only has value if the carrier actually issued the endorsement.

Additional Insured Status

Being named as the certificate holder does not give you coverage under the vendor’s policy. For that you need additional insured (AI) status, delivered through a specific endorsement attached to the policy. AI status extends the vendor’s liability coverage to you for liability arising from the vendor’s work, which lets you tap the vendor’s policy as a first line of defense when their operations cause a loss.

The most commonly referenced endorsement is ISO form CG 20 10, “Additional Insured – Owners, Lessees or Contractors – Scheduled Person or Organization.” CG 20 10 covers the additional insured for injury or damage that occurs while the named insured’s work is in progress. It does not reach claims that arise after the work is finished. Completed operations coverage needs a separate endorsement, which is why many contracts require both CG 20 10 and CG 20 37.

Listing your name in the description box means nothing without a valid endorsement actually attached to the policy. The COI is evidence that the endorsement should exist. If the carrier never issued it, you have no coverage regardless of what the certificate says. This is the single most common COI compliance failure.

Primary and Non-Contributory

Contracts frequently require the vendor’s insurance to be “primary and non-contributory.” That language means the vendor’s policy pays first on a covered claim involving the additional insured, without looking to the additional insured’s own insurance for contribution. Without this designation, the two insurers can argue over shares and drag you into the coverage dispute.

ISO form CG 20 01, “Primary and Noncontributory – Other Insurance Condition,” modifies the CGL’s “other insurance” clause so coverage for the additional insured is explicitly primary. It does not itself grant AI status, so it has to be paired with CG 20 10 or CG 20 37. The description box should reference both.

Waiver of Subrogation

Subrogation is the insurer’s right to pursue a third party after paying a claim. A waiver of subrogation (WoS) endorsement blocks that right, preventing the vendor’s insurer from turning around and suing you to recover what it paid. Waivers are standard in landlord-tenant agreements, general contractor-subcontractor arrangements, and long-term vendor contracts. The waiver is only as good as the endorsement on the actual policy; a reference in the description box without an issued endorsement is nothing.

Traps That Defeat the Requirements

Self-Insured Retentions

A self-insured retention (SIR) is a dollar amount the named insured must pay out of pocket before the policy responds. Unlike a deductible, where the insurer pays the claim first and recoups the deductible later, an SIR means the insurer does nothing until the insured exhausts the retention. For an additional insured this is dangerous: if the named insured cannot fund the SIR, the policy never kicks in.

The ACORD 25 has no dedicated checkbox for SIRs. They can appear in the description box but are easy to miss or omit. In one case, an additional insured discovered that a vendor’s $1,000,000 CGL policy was subject to a $2,000,000 SIR, which effectively made the policy excess rather than primary and forced the additional insured into costly litigation. Ask the broker directly whether any listed policy carries an SIR, and consider capping any permitted SIR in your contract at a figure like $10,000 or $25,000.

Shared Aggregates on Construction Policies

A standard CGL has one general aggregate that applies across every job the contractor works on during the policy period. If the aggregate is $2,000,000 and the contractor is running five projects, a large claim on one can drain the limit available to the others. By the time your claim arises, the coverage you were promised may already be spent.

The fix is a per-project aggregate endorsement, ISO form CG 25 03, “Designated Construction Project(s) General Aggregate Limit,” which assigns a separate aggregate equal to the policy’s general aggregate to each designated project. The ACORD 25 includes a checkbox in the CGL section indicating whether the aggregate applies per project rather than per policy. Any job with meaningful risk should require it.

Cancellation Notice Language

The ACORD 25 says the insurer will “endeavor to” mail notice to the certificate holder if a policy is cancelled before its expiration date. That language is weaker than it reads. Contracts commonly require 30 days’ advance written notice of cancellation and 10 days’ notice for nonpayment of premium, and those harder commitments are typically delivered through a specific policy endorsement rather than the certificate’s default wording. If guaranteed notice matters to you, confirm the endorsement is on the policy.

Writing Requirements Into the Contract

Clear requirements produce clean certificates. Spell out in the contract:

  • Each policy type you require and the minimum limits for each, including per-occurrence, aggregate, and umbrella figures.
  • Every required endorsement by name and ISO form number where applicable: CG 20 10, CG 20 37, CG 20 01, CG 25 03, and any waiver of subrogation.
  • The exact legal name and address to use for the certificate holder and the additional insured.
  • Any cap on self-insured retentions.
  • The cancellation notice period you expect and the endorsement that must deliver it.

Ambiguous requests produce non-compliant certificates and burn time on revisions. Vendors send your language to their broker, who checks it against their current policies and either issues the ACORD 25 directly or arranges endorsements and limit increases first. Turnaround runs from a few hours for simple certificates to several days when endorsements need to be added or the insurer must approve policy changes.

Reviewing What Arrives

Receiving the COI is not acceptance. Before the vendor starts work, run through every field:

  • Dates: effective and expiration dates cover your entire contract period.
  • Limits: each listed limit meets or exceeds the contractual minimum, including per-occurrence, aggregate, and umbrella.
  • Endorsements: the description of operations box explicitly references the required AI endorsements, the waiver of subrogation, and primary and non-contributory status. A blank or generic box is incomplete.
  • Insurer verification: the NAIC number resolves to a licensed carrier with a sound financial rating.
  • Self-insured retentions: no SIR language appears, or any SIR falls within what the contract allows. If the box is silent, ask the broker to confirm in writing.

For high-value contracts, request copies of the actual policy endorsements rather than relying on the description box. The certificate is evidence; the endorsement is the coverage.

Lapses, Fraud, and Ongoing Management

COIs expire when their underlying policies expire. A vendor whose insurance lapses mid-contract leaves you exposed for whatever happens during the gap. Track every certificate’s expiration date and request renewal COIs well before current ones expire. Even a short gap means you are absorbing the vendor’s risk during that period.

Non-compliance is not a technicality. Accepting a COI with insufficient limits or missing endorsements means you have taken on financial risk the contract was designed to transfer. The consequences arrive with the claim.

Altered or forged certificates are a criminal matter in most states. Presenting a COI that misrepresents coverage, inflates limits, or fabricates endorsements constitutes insurance fraud, and most states classify fraudulent insurance acts as felonies carrying prison time, fines, and restitution to anyone financially harmed.2National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Statutes Making the Unauthorized Transaction of Insurance a Criminal Act Fraud is not limited to obvious forgeries. A contractor who asks a broker to issue a COI showing endorsements that were never added to the policy, or a vendor who digitally alters a legitimate certificate to inflate limits, is committing a fraudulent act. Even negligent misrepresentation can expose the issuing party to civil liability for the certificate holder’s losses.

Your best protection is independent verification. Contact the insurer or broker directly rather than relying on the document alone, and for anything high-value, insist on seeing the endorsements themselves.