A cleared swap is a derivatives contract that two parties execute and then submit to a registered clearinghouse, which steps between them and becomes the counterparty to each side. The Commodity Exchange Act defines the term as “any swap that is, directly or indirectly, submitted to and cleared by a derivatives clearing organization registered with the Commission.”1Legal Information Institute. 7 USC 1a(7) – Definition: Cleared Swap Clearing turns a private bilateral contract into one guaranteed by a regulated intermediary, so one side’s failure no longer takes the other side down with it.
How Clearing Changes the Contract
A swap is a contract to exchange streams of future payments based on a notional amount and a schedule. Corporations and financial institutions use them to manage exposure to interest rates, currencies, and credit. Before 2008, most swaps stayed bilateral from execution to maturity. If your counterparty failed, you absorbed the loss.
Central clearing changes that through novation. Once a clearinghouse accepts a swap, the original contract between buyer and seller is legally extinguished and replaced with two new contracts. The clearinghouse becomes the seller to the original buyer and the buyer to the original seller. Neither original party faces the other’s credit anymore. Both face the clearinghouse.
In the United States, a clearinghouse that handles swaps operates as a derivatives clearing organization, or DCO. A DCO substitutes its own credit for that of the original parties, nets obligations across its members, and transfers credit risk through its margin and default framework. To stay registered, a DCO has to meet 17 core principles covering financial resources, risk management, default procedures, participant fund protection, and governance.2Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Clearing Organizations
Why Clearing Became Mandatory
The 2008 crisis exposed how deeply bilateral swap exposures linked major dealers to each other and to everyone who traded with them. When one dealer wobbled, counterparties suddenly discovered losses they had not priced for. Congress responded in the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 by adding a clearing requirement to the Commodity Exchange Act. Under Section 2(h)(1)(A), it is now unlawful to enter into a swap that has been designated for mandatory clearing unless the swap is actually submitted to a registered DCO.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 7 USC 2 – Jurisdiction of Commission; Liability
The CFTC administers the clearing requirement for most swaps, including interest rate swaps and broad-based index credit default swaps.4Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Clearing Requirement The SEC has separate jurisdiction over security-based swaps, meaning swaps on individual securities or narrow-based security indices, such as single-name credit default swaps.5U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. The Regulatory Regime for Security-Based Swaps
Which Swaps Must Be Cleared
The CFTC designates specific classes of swaps for mandatory clearing based on standardization and liquidity. Only contracts a registered DCO can effectively risk-manage are covered. The designated classes split into interest rate swaps and credit default swaps.6eCFR. 17 CFR 50.4 – Classes of Swaps Required To Be Cleared
Interest Rate Swaps
Four kinds of interest rate swaps fall within the mandate. Fixed-to-floating swaps in major currencies, referencing benchmarks such as BBSW, EURIBOR, and CDOR, with tenors that can run as short as 28 days or as long as 50 years depending on currency. Basis swaps, where both legs float, currently covered in Australian dollars and euros. Short-dated forward rate agreements in euros, Polish zloty, Norwegian krone, and Swedish krona. And overnight index swaps referencing rates like SOFR, SONIA, €STR, and TONA; U.S. dollar SOFR swaps must be cleared for terms from 7 days to 50 years.
The specifications matter because a swap only triggers the mandate if it matches a designated class. An interest rate swap with customized terms that fall outside those parameters may not require clearing.6eCFR. 17 CFR 50.4 – Classes of Swaps Required To Be Cleared
Credit Default Swaps
The clearing mandate for credit default swaps applies only to untranched index products. In North America, that means the CDX.NA.IG and CDX.NA.HY indices at specified tenors. In Europe, the iTraxx Europe, iTraxx Europe Crossover, and iTraxx Europe HiVol indices. Single-name credit default swaps are not subject to the CFTC’s clearing mandate.6eCFR. 17 CFR 50.4 – Classes of Swaps Required To Be Cleared
How a Swap Reaches the Clearinghouse
A cleared swap typically begins with execution on a swap execution facility or through bilateral negotiation. From there it is submitted to a DCO. Most end-users cannot access a DCO directly. They work through a futures commission merchant, or FCM, that is also a clearing member of the DCO.
The FCM is the operational bridge. It accepts your orders, posts margin on your behalf at the DCO, and guarantees your obligations to the clearinghouse. If you default, the FCM is responsible to the DCO for your positions.7Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Comptrollers Handbook: Futures Commission Merchant Activities This intermediary layer lets the DCO deal only with a controlled universe of well-capitalized clearing members.
Once the DCO accepts the trade, novation occurs. The original contract is terminated, two new contracts replace it, and the DCO sits in the middle managing credit risk through margin and its default resources.
Margin: Initial and Variation
Margin is how a DCO makes sure it can cover losses if a clearing member fails. Two kinds work together.
Initial Margin
Initial margin is collateral posted upfront to cover potential losses during the time it would take to close out a defaulting member’s positions. For swaps other than agricultural, energy, and metals contracts, the DCO must assume a minimum liquidation period of five business days. The DCO’s margin model has to produce requirements that cover potential losses at a confidence level of at least 99 percent, based on historical data.8eCFR. 17 CFR 39.13 – Risk Management
DCOs use proprietary models to calculate initial margin. Major clearinghouses have moved toward filtered historical simulation and value-at-risk approaches for interest rate swaps, while some products still rely on CME Group’s SPAN methodology, which calculates the worst portfolio loss under a range of price and volatility scenarios.9CME Group. CME SPAN Methodology Overview These clearinghouse models are separate from the ISDA Standard Initial Margin Model, which was built for non-cleared derivatives between dealers.10International Swaps and Derivatives Association. About the ISDA SIMM Initial margin is typically segregated from the DCO’s and the FCM’s own funds, so it stays protected if either becomes insolvent.
Variation Margin
Variation margin reflects the daily change in a swap’s market value. Each business day the DCO marks every cleared position to market. If the swap has moved against you, you owe the DCO the difference; if it has moved in your favor, the DCO pays you. For cleared swaps, variation margin typically functions as an actual settlement payment rather than collateral held against future losses, so unrealized gains and losses do not accumulate over the life of the trade.
Eligible Collateral
DCOs accept highly liquid assets as margin. At a minimum that means cash in U.S. dollars and major currencies, plus U.S. Treasury securities. Some also accept government-sponsored agency debt, certain equities, and letters of credit for initial margin.11The Options Clearing Corporation. Primer: What Is Margin? Non-cash collateral takes a haircut: the DCO deducts a percentage from the asset’s market value to account for the risk it could lose value during a liquidation. Collateral posted in a currency different from the swap’s settlement currency takes an additional haircut for foreign exchange risk.
The Default Waterfall
The test of central clearing is what happens when a clearing member defaults. DCOs maintain a layered sequence of resources, called the default waterfall, that absorbs losses in a set order.
- The defaulting member’s own initial margin is used first.
- Next, the defaulting member’s contribution to the pooled guarantee fund is consumed.
- The DCO then puts a tranche of its own capital at risk before reaching surviving members. This “skin in the game” aligns the clearinghouse’s incentives with sound risk management.
- Only after those layers are exhausted do losses spread to the remaining clearing members through their guarantee fund contributions.
The structure concentrates losses first on the party that caused them, then on the clearinghouse itself, and only as a last funded resort on the broader membership.
Who Can Avoid Clearing
Not every market participant has to clear. The Dodd-Frank Act built in exceptions for commercial hedgers and for transactions inside a corporate group.
End-User Exception
A counterparty may elect the end-user exception if it is not a financial entity and is using the swap to hedge or mitigate commercial risk.12eCFR. 17 CFR 50.50 – Non-Financial End-User Exception to the Clearing Requirement Commercial risk covers exposures that come from running a business: commodity prices, interest rates on operating debt, currency fluctuations on international sales. Banks, hedge funds, and other financial entities generally cannot use it.
To elect the exception, the reporting counterparty notifies a swap data repository (or the CFTC directly, if no repository is available) for each swap, identifying the electing party and describing how it generally meets its financial obligations under non-cleared swaps.13Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Final Rule on End-User Exception to the Clearing Requirement for Swaps SEC filers face an extra governance step: an appropriate committee of the board of directors must review and approve the decision to enter into swaps that are exempt from clearing.12eCFR. 17 CFR 50.50 – Non-Financial End-User Exception to the Clearing Requirement The exception also lifts the trade execution requirement, so the end-user can execute bilaterally rather than on a swap execution facility.
Inter-Affiliate Exemption
Two companies within the same corporate group can elect not to clear swaps between themselves if certain conditions are met. Both entities must elect the exemption, the swap must be documented in a trading relationship agreement, and the transactions have to be covered by a centralized risk management program.14eCFR. 17 CFR 50.52 – Affiliated Entity Exemption From the Clearing Requirement The affiliate relationship requires majority ownership and consolidated financial reporting under GAAP or IFRS.
Small Financial Institutions
The CFTC exempted banks, savings associations, farm credit system institutions, and credit unions with total assets of $10 billion or less from the definition of “financial entity.” That makes these small institutions eligible to use the end-user exception, even though they would otherwise be barred from it as financial entities.13Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Final Rule on End-User Exception to the Clearing Requirement for Swaps
Reporting Still Applies
Clearing is one piece of the post-crisis transparency framework; reporting is another, and it applies whether or not a swap is cleared. Swaps executed on a swap execution facility or by a swap dealer must have their creation data reported to a swap data repository by the end of the next business day after execution. Non-dealer, non-facility counterparties have until the end of the second business day.15eCFR. 17 CFR Part 45 – Swap Data Recordkeeping and Reporting Requirements Amendments, assignments, and terminations have to be reported as they happen. When a DCO accepts a swap for clearing, the DCO itself takes on the reporting obligation for the resulting cleared contracts.