Agreed-upon procedures standards are the attestation rules that tell a CPA how to perform, document, and report on a set of procedures that the engaging party has agreed should be run against a specific subject matter. For nonissuers, the governing standard is AT-C Section 215 as revised by Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements (SSAE) No. 19, issued by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants and effective for engagements dated on or after July 15, 2021.1AICPA & CIMA. AICPA Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 19 For public companies, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board’s AT Section 201 applies instead.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AT Section 201 – Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements The two frameworks share the same core concept but diverge on important points, especially who can read the final report.
What the Standards Require the Practitioner to Do
The defining rule of AUP standards is that the practitioner performs only the procedures the parties agreed to and reports the factual findings. No opinion. No conclusion. No assurance about whether the subject matter is fairly stated.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AT Section 201 – Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements If the agreed procedure is to check whether 25 invoices have matching purchase orders, the report says how many matched and how many did not. Drawing conclusions from that is the reader’s job.
That constraint is what separates an AUP engagement from an audit or a review. In an audit the practitioner designs the tests and opines on the financial statements. In a review the practitioner provides limited assurance. In an AUP engagement the practitioner follows a script and reports what the script produced.
Setting Up the Engagement Under SSAE No. 19
Before any procedures run, the standards require the parties to reach a documented understanding of the scope, the specific procedures, the limitations, and the reporting arrangements. This lives in the engagement letter.
Agreeing on the Procedures
SSAE No. 19 changed how the procedures themselves get built. Under the prior standard, the parties had to specify the procedures upfront and the practitioner could not help design them. The revised standard allows the practitioner to assist in developing the procedures and to refine them as the engagement progresses.1AICPA & CIMA. AICPA Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 19 That reflects a practical reality: engaging parties often lack the technical background to frame effective procedures on their own.
Whoever drafts them, the procedures must be specific enough that another qualified practitioner could replicate them and reach the same findings. “Review the accounts receivable for reasonableness” fails that test. “Select a sample of 30 accounts receivable balances over $10,000 and trace each to a corresponding signed customer invoice” meets it.
Independence
AT-C Section 105, which sets concepts common to all attestation engagements, requires the practitioner to be independent of the responsible party.3AICPA & CIMA. AICPA SSAEs – Currently Effective If the practitioner is not independent, that fact must be disclosed in both the engagement letter and the final report.
Performing and Documenting the Procedures
During execution, the practitioner runs the agreed procedures and nothing else. Spotting something interesting mid-engagement does not authorize a side investigation. Any additional work requires going back to the engaging party, explaining what was found, and getting formal agreement to add procedures through an amendment.
The standards require documentation that links each agreed-upon procedure to the evidence obtained and to the resulting factual finding.3AICPA & CIMA. AICPA SSAEs – Currently Effective The workpapers must be detailed enough that another practitioner reviewing the file can trace what was done and how each finding was reached. In practice, most firms retain AUP workpapers for at least five to seven years, though federal grant work may require longer.
Materiality
AUP engagements generally do not involve the materiality judgments used in audits. The practitioner reports every exception, regardless of dollar amount, because the parties decide what matters. Some regulatory programs build materiality thresholds into their AUP requirements — for instance, the Securities Investor Protection Corporation allows practitioners to ignore differences at defined dollar thresholds on certain SIPC-7 line items when those limits are agreed in the engagement letter and disclosed in the report.4Grant Thornton. Materiality Limits for a SIPC-7 AUP Engagement Outside those specific carve-outs, all exceptions get reported.
What the Report Must Contain
The AUP report has mandatory elements. Leaving any of them out can render the report non-compliant with the standard.
- Identification of the subject matter and the responsible party associated with it.
- A complete list of every procedure performed, each followed immediately by the factual findings from that procedure. Nothing is summarized or omitted.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AT Section 201 – Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements
- A prominent disclaimer stating that the practitioner does not express an opinion or conclusion about the subject matter, and noting that additional procedures might have surfaced other matters.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AT Section 201 – Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements
- A statement addressing the practitioner’s independence from the responsible party, with disclosure if the practitioner was not independent.
General-Use and Restricted-Use Reports
One of the largest changes SSAE No. 19 brought concerns who can read the report. The prior standard restricted every AUP report to the specified parties who had agreed on the procedures. SSAE No. 19 now permits general-use reports, meaning anyone can read and rely on the report.1AICPA & CIMA. AICPA Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements No. 19 Restricted-use reports remain available where circumstances warrant, but restriction is no longer the default.
This applies only to nonissuer engagements. The PCAOB’s AT Section 201 still restricts issuer AUP reports to specified parties.2Public Company Accounting Oversight Board. AT Section 201 – Agreed-Upon Procedures Engagements If the engagement involves a public company, the restricted-use framework governs.
Party Responsibilities Under the Revised Standard
SSAE No. 19 also reshuffled some responsibilities among the parties.
The Engaging Party
Under the prior standard, every specified party — including intended users beyond the engaging party — had to formally acknowledge that the procedures were sufficient for their purposes. SSAE No. 19 eliminated that requirement. Now only the engaging party acknowledges the appropriateness of the procedures for the intended purpose, typically through a representation letter provided before the report is issued.5AICPA & CIMA. SSAE No. 19 At a Glance That change simplifies multi-party engagements considerably. The engaging party also carries the risk if the procedures turn out to be inadequate to test what actually needed testing.
The Responsible Party
The responsible party controls the subject matter being tested. Under the prior standard, the practitioner had to request a written assertion from the responsible party about the subject matter. SSAE No. 19 removed that requirement entirely.5AICPA & CIMA. SSAE No. 19 At a Glance The responsible party still must provide access to all information and personnel needed to run the agreed procedures, but the formal written assertion is no longer required.
The Practitioner
The practitioner must maintain independence, exercise due professional care, comply with applicable ethical standards, preserve professional skepticism, and keep documentation sufficient to support every finding. These duties run throughout the engagement, not just at the start.
When Government Auditing Standards Add Requirements
AUP engagements involving federal funds may need to comply with Government Auditing Standards (the Yellow Book, or GAGAS), issued by the U.S. Government Accountability Office.6U.S. GAO. Yellow Book: Government Auditing Standards GAGAS layers on top of the AICPA standards.
The 2024 Yellow Book revision, effective for periods beginning on or after December 15, 2025, imposes several additional requirements on AUP attestation engagements:7U.S. GAO. Government Auditing Standards: 2024 Revision
- Practitioners not working for a government audit organization must be licensed CPAs or work for licensed CPA firms. Some states with multiclass licensing systems also recognize other licensed accountants.
- If the practitioner becomes aware of noncompliance with laws, regulations, contracts, or grant agreements that is material to the subject matter, it must be reported, even if the noncompliance falls outside the agreed-upon procedures.
- Reports claiming GAGAS compliance must include a statement that the engagement was conducted in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
- The audit organization must design and implement a system of quality management by December 15, 2025, with an evaluation of the system completed by December 15, 2026.
The noncompliance-reporting rule creates an obligation that does not exist under the AICPA standard alone. Under AT-C Section 215, a practitioner who stumbles across fraud while running an unrelated procedure has no duty to investigate or report it beyond communicating with the engaging party. Under GAGAS, material noncompliance must be reported regardless of whether the procedures were designed to find it.
Consequences of Non-Compliance
Practitioners who fail to follow the standards face professional discipline. AICPA ethics enforcement can impose a range of sanctions depending on the severity of the violation:8AICPA & CIMA. Definitions of Ethics Sanctions/Disposition
- Corrective action for less severe violations, which may require up to 80 hours or more of continuing professional education, submission of subsequent workpapers for review, or pre-issuance review of reports by an outside party.
- Public admonishment from the Joint Trial Board for violations that do not warrant suspension but merit public notice.
- Suspension of up to two years or expulsion. During suspension, the member cannot identify themselves as an AICPA member on letterhead or other materials and cannot vote or hold committee positions. The AICPA can also direct the member to complete specific CPE courses or submit to monitoring during the suspension period.
Automatic suspension or expulsion, without a hearing, can occur if a member’s CPA license is revoked, if the member is convicted of certain crimes, or if another governmental body takes disciplinary action against the member.8AICPA & CIMA. Definitions of Ethics Sanctions/Disposition State boards of accountancy can independently revoke or suspend a practitioner’s license, and malpractice claims from engaging parties or report users remain a real risk when a practitioner departs from the standards.