Underwater Stock Options: Taxes, Expiration, and Repricing

Underwater stock options — employee options whose strike price sits above the current share price — don’t trigger a tax bill, and they don’t produce a deductible loss either. You still hold them, they keep vesting on their original schedule, and if the stock climbs back above your strike price before the option expires, they’re worth something again. The real decisions come up in three situations: you’re thinking about leaving your job, your company offers to exchange or reprice the options, or you already paid tax on an earlier exercise and the stock has since collapsed.

What “Underwater” Actually Means

Your option has a strike price, locked in on the grant date, that you’d pay per share to exercise. The option has exercise value only when the market price is above that strike. When the market price falls below it, the option is underwater: exercising would mean paying more for the shares than they’re worth on the open market.

Say your grant lets you buy at $50 and the stock trades at $30. Spending $50 to own something worth $30 doesn’t make sense, so you don’t exercise. The option still exists. It continues vesting. It keeps whatever time remains on its term. Underwater is not the same as canceled.

Tax Treatment While You Hold Them

The rule is simple: if you don’t exercise, you don’t owe anything. Both Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) and Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs) create a taxable event only when you exercise or sell the resulting shares.1Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 427, Stock Options Nothing hits your W-2 or 1099 for an option you’re just holding.

For ISOs, a qualifying exercise normally creates an Alternative Minimum Tax adjustment equal to the spread between fair market value and your exercise price.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 421 – General Rules When the spread is zero or negative, there’s nothing to add. No regular tax, no AMT.

You Cannot Deduct the Lost Value

People often ask whether the drop in value is a write-off. It isn’t. Federal law allows a deduction when a security becomes worthless, and the definition of “security” is broad enough to include a right to receive corporate stock.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 165 – Losses But the deduction equals what you paid for the security minus zero. You paid nothing for an employee option grant, so the deductible loss is also zero. The economic hit is real; the tax recognition isn’t.1Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 427, Stock Options

If You Already Paid AMT and Then the Stock Collapsed

This is the one scenario where underwater options tie into a real tax problem. You exercised ISOs when the stock was above your strike, paid AMT on the paper spread, and then the price fell below what you paid. You’ve sent the IRS money for gains that evaporated, and you’re holding shares worth less than your basis.

The AMT you paid on an ISO exercise generates a minimum tax credit. You carry it forward indefinitely and apply it against future regular tax liability in years where your regular tax exceeds your tentative minimum tax. You claim it on Form 8801.4Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8801 The credit doesn’t expire, but recovery is often slow because it can only offset the gap between your regular tax and your tentative minimum tax in any given year. Full recovery can take several years.

For 2026, the AMT exemption is $90,100 for single filers and $140,200 for married couples filing jointly, with phaseouts starting at $500,000 and $1,000,000.5Internal Revenue Service. IRS Releases Tax Inflation Adjustments for Tax Year 2026 If you paid AMT on an ISO exercise in a prior year, check whether you’ve been filing Form 8801 every year since. The credit sits unused when people stop claiming it.

A separate point for anyone who early-exercised and filed a Section 83(b) election: you have a real cost basis in those shares. If you sell them at a loss, you can recognize a capital loss. That’s a different situation from holding unexercised underwater options.

What Happens If You Leave Your Job

This is where underwater options get painful. Most equity plans give departing employees a limited window to exercise vested options after their last day. The standard is 90 days, though some plans allow as little as 30 and some as long as a year.

If your options are underwater during that window, there’s no reasonable move. Exercising means paying more than the shares are worth, so you walk away and let them expire. Unvested options are typically forfeited the day you leave, whether you quit, were laid off, or were terminated for cause. The exact terms live in your equity plan and grant agreement, so pull those documents before you give notice.

The ISO 90-Day Rule

For ISOs, federal law requires exercise within three months of leaving the employer to keep the favorable ISO tax treatment.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 422 – Incentive Stock Options If your company offers an extended post-termination exercise window, any exercise after month three converts the option into an NSO. The spread at exercise then becomes ordinary income subject to income and payroll tax rather than potentially qualifying for capital-gains treatment.

When the options are underwater, the conversion doesn’t matter because you wouldn’t exercise anyway. If the stock rebounds inside an extended window, though, the conversion matters a lot, and it’s a surprise worth avoiding.

Private Company Options

At a private company the dynamic is worse. There’s no public market for the shares, so you can’t easily verify current value, and even if you did exercise, you’d be paying cash for shares you can’t sell. Many employees at private startups end up forfeiting options that represented a large piece of their compensation simply because the economics don’t work at departure time.

If Your Company Offers to Reprice or Exchange

When a lot of employees are holding underwater options, those options stop doing the job they were granted to do. Companies respond in one of two ways: directly repricing existing options to a lower strike, or running an option exchange program where employees surrender underwater options for new options, Restricted Stock Units (RSUs), or occasionally cash.

Exchange programs are a form of tender offer. The company files a Schedule TO with the SEC and provides detailed disclosure about the exchange ratio, new terms, risks, and the company’s financial condition.7U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Tender Offer Rules and Schedules Participation is voluntary. You decide whether to tender.

A 409A Caution

Any repricing has to be structured to stay inside the stock option exemption from Section 409A. NSOs are normally exempt because the strike equals fair market value at grant, and a repricing treated as a new grant at current fair market value generally preserves that. If a modification adds deferral features or otherwise falls outside the exemption, the option holder faces immediate income inclusion plus a 20% additional tax and interest on the deferred amount.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 409A – Inclusion in Gross Income of Deferred Compensation Under Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Plans That penalty hits you, not the company. Read the disclosure carefully.

What to Weigh Before You Tender

A few things matter more than the exchange ratio on paper:

  • New options versus RSUs. RSUs vest into actual shares with no exercise price, so there’s no underwater risk, but they create ordinary income the moment they vest and you lose control over the timing. With options, you choose when to exercise and trigger tax.
  • Cash. Cash in an exchange is immediately taxable as ordinary income, and you give up all future upside.
  • Time left on your current grant. If your existing options have seven or eight years before expiration and the stock has been volatile, holding them may give you a reasonable chance of recovery without surrendering anything.
  • Re-vesting. Replacement grants typically come with a new vesting schedule. If you might leave within that period, you could end up worse off than keeping the already-vested underwater options you had.

The exchange tends to make the most sense when the stock has little realistic chance of climbing back to the original strike and you plan to stay long enough to vest the new award.

If the Options Expire Underwater

Every option has an expiration date. ISOs are capped at ten years from grant by federal law.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 422 – Incentive Stock Options NSOs have no statutory maximum, but most plans set them at ten years too. If the stock never crosses your strike before that date, the options expire and your rights end.

A cashless exercise, where a broker exercises and immediately sells enough shares to cover the strike, isn’t available for underwater options. The sale wouldn’t cover the strike price, and no broker will run the transaction. You’d have to come out of pocket to buy shares worth less than you’re paying, which no one does.

Expiration itself produces no deductible tax loss, because your basis in the option was zero.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 165 – Losses The options drop off your equity statement and nothing happens on your return.

When to Act and When to Wait

The most overlooked fact about underwater options is that they still have time. A ten-year option in year two has eight years for the stock to move. The option’s time value can be meaningful even when its intrinsic value is zero, and holding costs you nothing. Panic exits are usually mistakes.

There are a few situations where you should pay close attention rather than wait:

  • You’re thinking about leaving. Check your grant agreement for the post-termination exercise period and factor the likely forfeiture into the decision.
  • Your company announces an exchange program. Read the Schedule TO. Compare what you’re giving up to what you’re getting, including the re-vesting period.
  • You exercised ISOs in a prior year and paid AMT. File Form 8801 every year until you’ve recovered the credit.4Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 8801
  • You early-exercised shares with an 83(b) election and the stock has fallen. You do have a basis in those shares and can recognize a capital loss on sale.

Equity compensation rules vary by plan and by state. If your options are a meaningful share of your net worth, running the specifics past a tax professional before you exercise, tender, or leave is worth the fee.