A throwout rule is a state corporate income tax provision that removes “nowhere sales” — revenue from customers in states where the company has no tax liability — from the denominator of the sales apportionment factor. Shrinking the denominator makes the fraction larger, so every state that does tax the company ends up claiming a bigger slice of its income. The tax rate never changes. The apportionment percentage does, and the tax bill goes up with it.
How the Calculation Works
State corporate income tax uses formula apportionment. A multistate company’s total income is multiplied by a fraction that reflects how much of its business happens in the taxing state. Most states now rely on a single-sales-factor formula, which bases apportionment entirely on where customers are located.1Multistate Tax Commission. Multistate Tax Compact The sales factor is a simple fraction: in-state sales over total sales.
A throwout rule modifies that fraction by pulling untaxable sales out of the denominator. The numerator stays the same.
Consider a company with $5,000,000 in total sales, of which $1,000,000 goes to states where it has no tax liability. A state where the company has $1,000,000 in in-state sales would ordinarily calculate a sales factor of $1,000,000 / $5,000,000, or 20 percent. Apply a throwout rule, and the $1,000,000 in untaxable sales drops out of the denominator. The new calculation is $1,000,000 / $4,000,000, or 25 percent. That is a 25 percent increase in the income base assigned to the state, produced entirely by arithmetic.
The bigger a company’s volume of sales into states where it lacks nexus, the sharper the effect. Under a single-sales-factor formula, where the sales fraction carries the entire apportionment weight, throwout translates almost directly into a larger tax bill.
Throwout vs. Throwback
States use two mechanisms to recapture nowhere income, and they work differently. A throwback rule reassigns untaxable sales to the origin state by adding them to that state’s numerator. A throwout rule instead deletes those sales from the denominator for every taxing state.2Multistate Tax Commission. Notes on Throwback Rule
Throwback concentrates recaptured income in a single origin state. Throwout spreads it proportionally across all states where the company files. Throwback rules also apply only to tangible personal property, while throwout rules extend to services and intangibles. About two dozen states use throwout rules to exclude sales of intangibles from the denominator when the company isn’t taxable at the destination.
Which Sales Are “Untaxable”
A sale qualifies for throwout when the company is not taxable in the destination state. That turns on nexus, the minimum connection between a business and a state that lets the state impose an income tax. Fall below the threshold, and the destination state cannot tax the income; a throwout state will then strip those sales from the denominator.
Public Law 86-272
The most important federal shield is 15 U.S.C. § 381, enacted as Public Law 86-272. It bars a state from taxing a company’s net income if the company’s only in-state activity is soliciting orders for tangible personal property, provided the orders are sent outside the state for approval and filled by shipment from outside the state.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 381 – Imposition of Net Income Tax Sales into a state where the company’s presence is limited to that kind of solicitation are the classic untaxable sales that throwout targets.
The line between protected solicitation and unprotected activity is narrow. In Wisconsin Department of Revenue v. William Wrigley, Jr., Co., the Supreme Court held that a de minimis exception exists but that any activity creating a “nontrivial additional connection” with the taxing state loses that character, no matter how small it looks against the company’s overall operations.4Justia. Wisconsin Dept of Revenue v William Wrigley Jr Co Providing maintenance, storing inventory, or having employees do anything beyond taking orders can destroy the immunity. One employee crossing from solicitation into service delivery can flip a state from untaxable to taxable and wipe out the throwout benefit for every sale into that jurisdiction.
What P.L. 86-272 Does Not Cover
The statute only reaches solicitation of orders for tangible personal property. It does not protect sales of services, licensing of intangibles like patents or trademarks, or any transaction involving digital goods. A company selling software subscriptions, consulting, or streaming content gets no shelter, even with zero physical presence in the customer’s state.5Multistate Tax Commission. Statement of Information Concerning Practices of Multistate Tax Commission and Supporting States Under Public Law 86-272
Online activity has narrowed the shield further. The Multistate Tax Commission has identified specific internet activities that defeat P.L. 86-272 immunity even for sellers of tangible goods, including placing data-gathering cookies on customer devices, providing post-sale assistance by chat or email, offering extended warranties, soliciting branded credit card applications, and remotely repairing or upgrading products through transmitted code. Basic e-commerce (product descriptions, shopping carts, payment processing) remains protected as long as the company doesn’t add the unprotected features.5Multistate Tax Commission. Statement of Information Concerning Practices of Multistate Tax Commission and Supporting States Under Public Law 86-272 Adding a chat support button one year can create nexus in every state where the company has customers, expanding filing obligations and eliminating the throwout exclusion for those sales in the same stroke.
Economic Nexus After Wayfair
The Supreme Court’s 2018 decision in South Dakota v. Wayfair eliminated the physical presence requirement for sales tax nexus. Its reasoning has emboldened states to apply economic nexus standards to income taxes as well, and several now assert income tax jurisdiction over companies that clear a receipts threshold, even without any physical operations in the state.
That trend shrinks the pool of untaxable sales throwout can reach. If a company exceeds an economic nexus threshold, it becomes taxable in that state, and those sales no longer qualify for throwout exclusion elsewhere. Multistate businesses now have to run two layers of nexus analysis: the traditional physical-presence inquiry (where P.L. 86-272 still matters for tangible goods) and the newer economic nexus tests that can independently create a filing obligation. The interaction varies by state and is still evolving.
Sourcing Services and Intangibles
For tangible goods, the destination is where the shipment lands. Services and intangibles are harder. States split between cost-of-performance sourcing, which assigns revenue to where the income-producing activity occurs, and market-based sourcing, which attributes it to where the customer receives the benefit.
Throwout combined with market-based sourcing has a specific consequence: a service provider without nexus in the customer’s state will see that revenue excluded from the denominator, pushing up the apportionment percentage in every state where it is taxable. Because P.L. 86-272 doesn’t protect service providers in the first place, they usually have fewer untaxable states to begin with, so the mathematical hit tends to be smaller. The compliance burden is not. Service nexus depends on facts that are harder to track than whether a sales rep visited a state.
Combined Reporting: Joyce and Finnigan
When affiliated companies file as a combined unitary group, the throwout analysis depends on whether nexus is measured at the individual entity or at the group. States have split into two camps.
Under the Joyce rule, each entity stands alone. If Company A sells into a state but only its affiliate Company B has nexus there, Company A is still treated as untaxable in that state, and its sales are eligible for throwout. Under the Finnigan rule, the group is evaluated as a unit. If any member has nexus in the destination state, all members are treated as taxable there, and fewer sales qualify for throwout exclusion.
The mismatch between Joyce and Finnigan states can produce double taxation. A company selling from a Joyce state into a Finnigan state may find the Joyce state throwing out the sale (because the individual entity lacks nexus at the destination) while the Finnigan state simultaneously taxes it (because the group has nexus). Neither state considers itself out of line under its own rules. Compliance requires mapping each entity’s nexus profile alongside the group’s collective footprint, state by state.
Foreign Sales
Whether sales to foreign customers get thrown out depends on the specific state’s rule and how it defines “not taxable.” A U.S. company generally isn’t subject to state income tax in a foreign country, so under a broad reading foreign sales could be excluded from the denominator.
State taxation of foreign commerce faces extra constitutional scrutiny. In Japan Line, Ltd. v. County of Los Angeles, the Supreme Court held that state taxes on foreign commerce must not create a substantial risk of international multiple taxation and must not impair the federal government’s ability to speak with one voice on international trade.6Cornell Law School. Foreign Commerce and State Powers A throwout rule that excluded all foreign sales could significantly inflate domestic states’ claims and raise both concerns, though the Court has accepted some double taxation as inherent in income apportionment, making the analysis more forgiving than the property-tax cases.
Constitutional Limits and Taxpayer Relief
State apportionment formulas, throwout rules included, must satisfy the four-part test from Complete Auto Transit, Inc. v. Brady: substantial nexus, fair apportionment, no discrimination against interstate commerce, and fair relation to services the state provides.7Cornell Law School. Complete Auto Transit Inc v Brady
Fair apportionment is where throwout gets tested. Under Goldberg v. Sweet, courts apply two sub-tests. Internal consistency asks whether multiple taxation would result if every state adopted the same rule. Throwout generally passes: if every state used it, every sale would still be taxable by exactly one state, the one where the company has nexus.8Library of Congress. Apportionment Prong of Complete Auto Test for Taxes on Interstate Commerce External consistency is harder. It asks whether the formula “actually reflect[s] a reasonable sense of how income is generated” in the taxing state. A taxpayer can challenge a formula by proving through clear and cogent evidence that the income assigned to the state is “out of all appropriate proportion” to the business transacted there.9Justia. Container Corp v Franchise Tax Board
The Whirlpool Decision
The leading judicial test of a throwout rule is Whirlpool Properties, Inc. v. Director, Division of Taxation, which involved New Jersey’s provision. The court found the rule facially constitutional, reasoning that it operates properly at least when the excluded income is generated partly by activities in the taxing state, when the excluded amount is insignificant relative to total income, or when property and payroll factors temper the impact of the inflated sales factor. The court treated the throwout rule as a component of an apportionment formula rather than a tax itself, and held that including income in the pre-apportionment base does not by itself mean the state is taxing that income.10Justia Law. Whirlpool Properties Inc v Director Division of Taxation
The court also pointed to a safety valve: New Jersey law gives the Director of Taxation authority to adjust the allocation factor when the standard formula does not fairly represent the company’s business activity in the state. That discretionary relief mechanism was part of why the rule survived facial challenge. The reasoning suggests a throwout rule without a comparable relief mechanism could be more vulnerable.
Petitioning for Alternative Apportionment
When a throwout rule produces a distorted result for a particular taxpayer, most states offer a mechanism to request an alternative apportionment method. The burden falls entirely on the taxpayer. The company must show that the standard formula creates distortion and that its proposed alternative fairly represents its business activity in the state. Standard apportionment is presumptively correct, so this is not a fight companies win casually. Separate accounting showing where income is actually generated geographically is the most common evidence.
These petitions are a last resort. The request typically must be made before or with the tax return, and the taxpayer usually has to supply the full alternative calculation alongside the standard one. Filing under the standard formula and then arguing later that the result was unfair is a much harder path to relief. Identify throwout distortion during compliance planning, and build the alternative apportionment case before the return is due rather than after an audit notice.