A charge from “That Coffee Place” on your credit card statement is a purchase at a coffee shop or cafĂ© doing business under that name. If the amount looks slightly higher than the menu price you remember, the difference is most likely a credit card surcharge, which about a third of small merchants now add to card transactions.1J.D. Power. 2025 US Merchant Services Satisfaction Study Whether that surcharge is legitimate depends on how it was disclosed, what card you used, and what state you were in.
Why the Total Is Higher Than the Menu Price
Every credit card transaction costs the merchant a processing fee, commonly called interchange or a “swipe” fee. For small businesses those fees generally run from 1.5% to 2.9% of the transaction, though the National Retail Federation puts the range at 2% to 4%.2Payments Dive. Third of US Small Businesses Add Credit Card Surcharges On a single latte the amount is small. Across a day of transactions it isn’t, and a growing number of coffee shops pass the cost to the customer as a separate line item.
J.D. Power’s 2025 U.S. Merchant Services Satisfaction Study, which surveyed 3,841 small businesses, found that 34% of small merchants surcharge credit card payments. Newer and smaller merchants are the most likely to do it.1J.D. Power. 2025 US Merchant Services Satisfaction Study So if the total on your statement is a few cents to a few percent higher than the sticker price, a surcharge is the most likely explanation.
When a Coffee Shop Is Allowed to Add a Surcharge
Card-network rules, federal law, and state law all apply at the same time. A shop has to satisfy every layer.
Card Network Caps and Disclosure
Visa caps surcharges at 3% or the merchant’s actual discount rate, whichever is lower, and requires the fee to be labeled as a “merchant fee” and disclosed on the receipt as a separate line item. The merchant must also notify Visa and its processor at least 30 days before starting to surcharge.3Visa. Merchant Surcharging QA Mastercard’s cap is 4%, with the same 30-day notification requirement and similar disclosure rules.4Mastercard. Merchant Surcharge Rules Both networks prohibit surcharges on debit and prepaid cards, even when a customer selects “credit” at the terminal.
Federal Rules
Federal law prohibits surcharges on debit card transactions outright. The FTC’s Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees, in effect since May 12, 2025, adds a disclosure layer: the nature, purpose, and amount of a fee must be clearly disclosed and included in the total price shown before the customer pays. If a business requires credit card payment with no fee-free alternative, the surcharge is treated as mandatory and must be baked into the displayed price. Vague labels like “processing fees” that obscure what the charge is are not allowed.5FTC. Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees Frequently Asked Questions
State Rules
A handful of states are stricter than the network caps.
- Connecticut, Maine, and Massachusetts prohibit credit card surcharges entirely.6NCSL. Credit or Debit Card Surcharges Statutes
- New York allows surcharges but bans the practice of adding a percentage at the register. As of February 2024, businesses must either post the total credit-card-inclusive price or display a two-tiered price (credit price alongside cash price) before checkout.7Governor of New York. Governor Hochul Announces New Law to Clarify Disclosure of Credit Card Surcharges
- New Jersey caps the surcharge at the seller’s actual processing cost and requires the specific amount, not just the existence of a fee, to be disclosed before charging. Restaurants must post the amount on signs and menus, including online menus and QR codes.8New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs. Credit Card Surcharges FAQ
- Colorado caps surcharges at 2%.
- California’s statutory ban was struck down by the Ninth Circuit in 2018 on First Amendment grounds for merchants who transparently communicate the fee, and the state Attorney General now applies that ruling broadly.9California Office of the Attorney General. Credit Card Surcharges
Signs the Charge Is Legitimate, and Signs It Isn’t
Pull up your receipt and compare it to the statement.
A properly handled surcharge shows up as a clearly labeled separate line item on the receipt, at a percentage no higher than the applicable cap, on a credit card transaction only. You should have seen it disclosed before you paid, whether on a sign, on the menu, or on the terminal screen.
Some red flags to look for:
- The surcharge was applied to a debit card or prepaid card. This violates both card-network rules and federal law, regardless of what button you pressed at the terminal.
- The fee is buried in the total with no line item on the receipt.
- The percentage exceeds the network cap (3% Visa, 4% Mastercard) or your state’s cap (2% in Colorado, actual cost in New Jersey).
- You’re in a state that prohibits surcharges (Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts).
- The fee is labeled as something else, such as a “convenience fee” or “non-cash adjustment.” Convenience fees legally apply only when you use a payment channel that isn’t the merchant’s standard one, like paying a utility bill by card when checks are the norm. Paying for coffee at a coffee shop’s own register isn’t that. Under the FTC’s rule, misrepresenting the nature or purpose of a fee is a violation regardless of state.10NerdWallet. Credit Card Convenience Fees and Surcharges5FTC. Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees Frequently Asked Questions
One boundary worth noting: a “cash discount” isn’t a surcharge. If the menu shows the credit price and cash customers pay less, that’s legal in all 50 states and isn’t a violation even in states that ban surcharging.11NFIB. Credit Card Surcharging Guide
What To Do if the Charge Looks Wrong
Start with the receipt. If the surcharge is disclosed, labeled, and within the applicable cap, you paid for what you bought and the charge is legitimate, even if unwelcome.
If the surcharge wasn’t disclosed before you paid, or was applied to a debit or prepaid card, or exceeded the cap, you have options:
- Ask the coffee shop for a refund first. That’s the fastest route.
- Report the merchant to the card network. Visa and Mastercard both take complaints about surcharge violations and enforce through audits and fines.3Visa. Merchant Surcharging QA
- Dispute the charge with your card issuer, especially if a debit card was surcharged.
- File a state complaint. New York’s Division of Consumer Protection takes complaints at 1-800-697-1220 or online. New Jersey’s Division of Consumer Affairs takes them at 800-242-5846.7Governor of New York. Governor Hochul Announces New Law to Clarify Disclosure of Credit Card Surcharges8New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs. Credit Card Surcharges FAQ
- In California, a willful surcharge that isn’t refunded within 30 days of a written demand sent by certified mail can expose the retailer to up to three times the actual damages.6NCSL. Credit or Debit Card Surcharges Statutes
If none of the red flags apply and the merchant name still doesn’t ring a bell, treat it as any other unfamiliar charge: check with anyone else who uses the card, then call your card issuer to dispute it if it’s genuinely unrecognized.