TFSA Over-Contribution: CRA 1% Monthly Tax, RC243, and Waivers

The TFSA over-contribution penalty is a tax of 1% per month on the highest amount by which your contributions exceed your available room, and it keeps running every month the excess sits in the account. You stop it by withdrawing the surplus, or you wait for January 1, when new annual room and any prior-year withdrawals are added back and may absorb what’s left. For 2026, the annual dollar limit is $7,000, and someone eligible since the TFSA launched in 2009 who has never contributed has up to $109,000 of cumulative room.1Canada Revenue Agency. Calculate Your TFSA Contribution Room

How the 1% Monthly Tax Works

Section 207.02 of the Income Tax Act imposes a tax equal to 1% of the highest excess TFSA amount you hold at any point during a calendar month.2Justice Laws Website. Income Tax Act – Section 207.02 The word “highest” matters. A deposit made on the 28th and withdrawn on the 30th still fixes the taxable amount for that entire month.

Your excess is defined in Section 207.01: contributions in the year, minus unused room from the end of the previous year, minus prior-year withdrawals, minus qualifying transfers and exempt contributions.3Justice Laws Website. Income Tax Act – Section 207.01 In plain terms, if you’ve put in more than your total available room allows, the difference is the excess.

A worked example makes it concrete. Suppose your total 2026 TFSA room is $15,000 and you contribute $20,000 in January. The excess is $5,000, and the monthly tax is $50. Leave it untouched for the year and you owe $600. Withdraw the $5,000 in April instead, and you owe $50 for each of January through April, or $200, because the excess existed in each of those months.

On January 1 of the following year, your new annual room plus any withdrawals from the prior year get added to your balance. If that fresh room is large enough, it absorbs what’s left of the excess and the 1% tax stops running into the new year. Every month the excess sat in the account before then still counts, though, and you still owe the tax for each of those months.

How Over-Contributions Usually Happen

The most common cause is withdrawing money and putting it back in the same calendar year. Withdrawals do not restore your room until January 1 of the following year.4Canada Revenue Agency. Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA), Guide for Individuals Pull $10,000 out in March and re-deposit $10,000 in August, and that re-deposit counts as a fresh contribution. Unless you had $10,000 of unused room already, you’ve just created an excess.

Holding TFSAs at more than one institution is another frequent source of trouble. Checking one bank’s balance and assuming that’s the whole picture leaves the other contributions invisible until the CRA totals them up.

The CRA’s own display of your room can also mislead you. Financial institutions report TFSA transactions to the CRA once a year, at the end of February, and your online room is updated in the spring.1Canada Revenue Agency. Calculate Your TFSA Contribution Room Contributions and withdrawals you’ve made in the current year won’t show up there yet, even though they’ve already changed your available room. The safer habit is to track your own transactions using statements from every institution where you hold a TFSA and reconcile them yourself.

Filing Form RC243

If you had an excess amount at any point during the year, you must file Form RC243, the Tax-Free Savings Account Return.5Canada Revenue Agency. RC243 Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) Return This is the return where you report the over-contribution and calculate the penalty. Don’t confuse it with Form RC343, which is only a worksheet for calculating your room and is not filed with the CRA.6Canada Revenue Agency. RC343 Worksheet – TFSA Contribution Room

You’ll also complete Schedule A (RC243-SCH-A), which walks through the highest excess amount for each month.7Canada Revenue Agency. RC243-SCH-A Schedule A – Excess TFSA Amounts Gather your Social Insurance Number and transaction records from every institution where you hold a TFSA. Most banks provide an annual TFSA transaction summary listing dates and amounts. Exact dates matter here, because a deposit made on December 31 versus January 1 can be the difference between owing another month’s tax or not.

The return is due by June 30 of the year following the over-contribution. Miss that date and the CRA will assess you based on the information it has, and add late-filing penalties and interest on top of the 1% tax.

Paying What You Owe

Payment goes to the Receiver General for Canada. The most convenient option is My Payment, the CRA’s online service for one-time debit card payments; credit cards aren’t accepted through it, and payments made before 10:00 p.m. local time are generally credited the same business day.8Canada Revenue Agency. Make a Payment – Payments to the CRA You can also pay by mail, by wire transfer through a Canadian bank, or in person at a Canada Post location.

One trap catches a lot of people: online banking bill payment through your own bank is not an accepted method for TFSA amounts owing.8Canada Revenue Agency. Make a Payment – Payments to the CRA That’s different from how most Canadians pay their income tax, so don’t assume the same process carries over.

Unpaid amounts accrue compound daily interest at the prescribed rate, which is 7% annualized for the first quarter of 2026.9Canada Revenue Agency. Interest Rates for the First Calendar Quarter 2026 That interest applies to both the 1% tax and any late-filing penalty, so delays get expensive quickly.

Asking the CRA to Waive the Tax

The Minister of National Revenue has discretion to waive or cancel all or part of the over-contribution tax. Two conditions must both be met: the excess resulted from a reasonable error, and you withdrew the excess and any income earned on it from your TFSA without delay.10Department of Justice Canada. Income Tax Act – Section 207.06 “Without delay” means as soon as you discovered or should have discovered the problem, not months later when the tax bill arrived.

What counts as a reasonable error is the harder question. The CRA has accepted situations where the TFSA issuer gave you inaccurate information, where the CRA’s own records showed incorrect room, where a retroactive pension adjustment reduced your limit after the fact, and where a taxpayer made multiple contributions and withdrawals trying to stay within the limit but miscalculated.

What the CRA generally will not accept is ignorance of the rules themselves. Forgetting that withdrawals don’t restore room until the following year, or not knowing what your limit was, typically doesn’t qualify. The line runs between an error anyone could reasonably have made on the information available and a failure to learn how the account works in the first place.

To request a waiver, send the CRA a written explanation of what happened, when you discovered the error, and what you did to fix it. Include a timeline showing your contributions, the point at which the excess arose, and the date you withdrew it. Supporting documents from your financial institution strengthen the request. The more clearly you can show a genuine mistake and prompt action once you saw it, the better your chances of having some or all of the tax cancelled.