Tax Audit Checklist for Your Employee Benefits Program

If the IRS or Department of Labor opens an examination of your retirement or health plan, the auditor’s first move is to compare what your plan documents promise against what your records show actually happened. An employee benefits plan audit checklist covers six document sets: signed governance documents and amendments, Form 5500 filings and participant disclosures, payroll and contribution records, nondiscrimination testing and operational files, the fidelity bond, and evidence of any corrections you have already made. Sponsors who keep these organized year-round face far shorter examinations and much lower penalty exposure than those who scramble after the notice arrives.

Plan Governance Documents

Every audit starts with the plan’s legal foundation. Auditors want the original signed plan document plus every amendment adopted since inception. Under IRC Section 401(a), a qualified plan must be in writing and satisfy specific requirements to keep its tax-exempt status.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 401 – Qualified Pension, Profit-Sharing, and Stock Bonus Plans If your company uses a pre-approved plan, the adoption agreement must be fully executed and dated. A missing signature or an undated adoption agreement is the kind of defect that can unravel a plan’s qualified status.

Beyond the plan text, gather the board resolutions or corporate minutes that authorized the plan and each amendment. These prove the governing body actually approved the changes rather than HR updating a document on its own. Auditors specifically check whether amendments were adopted before their effective dates or within the applicable remedial amendment period. If you cannot produce a signed, dated version of the plan and its amendments, the IRS may treat the plan as disqualified, making trust assets taxable and destroying participants’ tax deferrals.

Keep these files in one central location. When an auditor asks for “the plan document and all amendments,” the goal is to hand over a single organized binder or electronic folder, not to spend three weeks searching filing cabinets and former administrators’ inboxes.

Form 5500 Filings and Participant Disclosures

Form 5500 is the primary annual filing required under ERISA Section 104 and IRC Section 6058(a).2Internal Revenue Service. Form 5500 – Annual Return/Report of Employee Benefit Plan Pull copies of every 5500 filed during the review period along with all schedules that applied: Schedule H for financial information, Schedule R for retirement plan data, Schedule C for service provider information, and any others. Filings are archived in EFAST2, so historical copies are retrievable, but keeping your own organized set speeds the process.3Department of Labor. Instructions for Form 5500 Annual Return/Report of Employee Benefit Plan

Auditors also verify that participants received the disclosures they are owed. The Summary Plan Description gives employees a plain-language overview and must accurately reflect the plan’s terms. When significant changes are made, a Summary of Material Modifications should have been distributed within 210 days after the close of the plan year in which the change occurred.4Internal Revenue Service. 401(k) Resource Guide – Plan Participants – Summary Plan Description Summary Annual Reports must go out each year as well. Keep proof of distribution for all of these, whether mailing receipts, electronic delivery confirmations, or signed acknowledgments.

Late filing penalties stack from two directions. The IRS charges $250 per day for a late Form 5500 under IRC Section 6652(e), capped at $150,000 per return.5Internal Revenue Service. 401(k) Plan Fix-It Guide – You Haven’t Filed a Form 5500 This Year The DOL can impose a separate penalty of up to $2,670 per day under ERISA Section 502(c)(2).6U.S. Department of Labor. Fact Sheet: Adjusting ERISA Civil Monetary Penalties for Inflation These run simultaneously, so a single late filing generates thousands of dollars in combined exposure within weeks.

Payroll Records and Participant Files

Operational records reveal whether the plan actually follows its own rules day to day. This is where audits get intense. The core items to have ready:

  • Payroll records showing employee deferrals and employer matching contributions tied to the formulas in the plan document. If the plan says the employer matches 50% of the first 6% of compensation, auditors test whether that math holds across the participant population.
  • Participant files with enrollment forms, beneficiary designations, and signed distribution or loan request forms. Auditors use these to confirm that only eligible employees participate and that benefits were paid according to the vesting schedule.
  • Trust financial statements showing the plan’s assets, investment earnings, and administrative expenses paid from the fund. Consistency between payroll data and trust records prevents red flags about deposit timing or contribution accuracy.

Timely Deposit of Participant Contributions

Late deposits of employee deferrals and loan repayments are one of the most common audit findings, and the rule is stricter than many sponsors realize. Under DOL regulations, participant contributions become plan assets on the earliest date they can reasonably be separated from the employer’s general assets. For plans with fewer than 100 participants, a safe harbor treats deposits made within seven business days of the payroll date as timely. For larger plans there is no safe harbor; the “earliest date reasonably possible” standard applies. In no event can the deposit happen later than the 15th business day of the month following the payroll date.7GovInfo. 29 CFR 2510.3-102 – Definition of Plan Assets – Participant Contributions

Auditors typically request a side-by-side comparison of payroll dates and deposit dates. If payroll runs Friday and contributions do not hit the trust until the following Thursday, that pattern will draw attention. Consistent three-day turnaround looks routine. Deposits clustering near the 15th-business-day deadline look like a company using participant money as a short-term float.

Nondiscrimination Testing

Traditional 401(k) plans must be tested annually to confirm that contributions by rank-and-file employees are proportional to those made for owners and managers. The Actual Deferral Percentage and Actual Contribution Percentage tests compare deferral and contribution rates of highly compensated employees against everyone else. If a test fails and corrective action is not completed within the applicable correction window, the plan’s tax-qualified status can be at risk.8Internal Revenue Service. 401(k) Plan Fix-It Guide – The Plan Failed the 401(k) ADP and ACP Nondiscrimination Tests

Have the actual test results for each year under review, not just a summary. Auditors want the data inputs, the calculation methodology, and any corrective distributions or additional employer contributions. For 2026, the annual deferral limit under IRC Section 402(g) is $24,500, and the annual additions limit under Section 415(c) is $72,000.9Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Topics – 401(k) and Profit-Sharing Plan Contribution Limits Contributions above these limits create operational failures that need to be identified and corrected.

Hardship Distribution Documentation

If the plan permits hardship withdrawals, documentation behind each one gets close scrutiny. The IRS allows employers to rely on the participant’s written representation that the financial need cannot be met through other resources, provided the employer has no actual knowledge to the contrary. That written statement belongs in the participant’s file. The distribution amount cannot exceed what is needed to cover the hardship itself, including any taxes the participant will owe on the withdrawal.10Internal Revenue Service. Retirement Topics – Hardship Distributions

Plans that use the safe-harbor categories (medical expenses, home purchase costs, tuition, eviction or foreclosure prevention, funeral expenses, and certain home repair costs) can rely on a summary substantiation method rather than collecting full financial records. Even then, the participant’s written representation must be on file. Approved hardship distributions with no supporting paperwork lead directly to corrective action.

Forfeiture Account Usage

When participants leave before fully vesting, their unvested account balances become forfeitures. Under IRS regulations, those forfeited amounts must be used within 12 months after the end of the plan year in which the forfeiture occurs. The plan document should specify the permissible uses: paying plan administrative expenses, reducing future employer contributions, or reallocating to other participants’ accounts on a nondiscriminatory basis. Missing the deadline creates an operational failure. So does using forfeitures in a way the plan does not authorize. Auditors check the forfeiture account balance against the plan’s stated rules and the timing of actual expenditures.

Fidelity Bond Coverage

Every person who handles plan funds or property must be covered by a fidelity bond. This is a statutory requirement under ERISA Section 412, not optional insurance. The bond must equal at least 10% of the amount of funds handled in the preceding reporting year, with a minimum of $1,000 per plan and a maximum of $500,000. Plans holding employer securities face a higher maximum of $1,000,000.11Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1112 – Bonding

Auditors will ask for a copy of the bond and check whether coverage matches the plan’s asset size. A plan with $8 million in assets needs at least $500,000 in coverage (10% would be $800,000, but the cap applies). A plan with $3 million needs at least $300,000. A bond amount that has not been updated in years while assets grew is a finding. The fidelity bond protects the plan against theft and fraud by fiduciaries; it is not the same as fiduciary liability insurance, which is optional and covers negligence and management errors. The DOL requires the bond; the insurance is your call.12U.S. Department of Labor. Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2008-04

Cybersecurity Records

The Department of Labor has made cybersecurity a formal part of its audit focus. EBSA guidance outlines 12 best practices that fiduciaries and recordkeepers should follow, including a documented cybersecurity program, annual risk assessments, encryption of sensitive data in storage and in transit, and a written incident response plan.13U.S. Department of Labor. Cybersecurity Program Best Practices During an audit, the DOL may ask for evidence that you vetted your recordkeeper’s security controls, conducted cybersecurity awareness training, and have documentation of how you would respond to a breach.

This area catches many sponsors off guard because they assume cybersecurity is the recordkeeper’s problem. The DOL’s position is that fiduciaries have an independent obligation to evaluate and monitor their service providers’ security practices.

Health Plan Compliance

An examination of your employee benefits program does not stop at the retirement plan. If you sponsor a group health plan, the audit may also cover the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act and the ACA employer mandate.

Under the MHPAEA final rules, plans must conduct comparative analyses of their non-quantitative treatment limitations to demonstrate that restrictions on mental health and substance use disorder benefits are no more restrictive than those applied to medical and surgical benefits. Plans must show the factors and evidentiary standards used to design each limitation, the data collected to evaluate its impact, and any actions taken to address material differences in access.14U.S. Department of Labor. Fact Sheet: Final Rules Under the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) If your plan uses prior authorization for behavioral health services, an auditor may ask for the comparative analysis showing those requirements are not more burdensome than what applies to comparable medical benefits.

Applicable Large Employers (those with 50 or more full-time or full-time equivalent employees) must file Forms 1094-C and 1095-C reporting coverage offers. Common audit triggers include misidentifying ALE status, failing to aggregate related companies under common ownership as required by IRC Section 414, and inconsistencies in the coverage and affordability codes. If you have received a Letter 226-J proposing an employer shared responsibility payment, the underlying 1094-C and 1095-C filings and their supporting data are what you will need to respond.

How Long to Keep Records

ERISA Section 107 requires records supporting any required filing to be retained for at least six years from the date the report was due or actually filed. That covers Form 5500 filings, nondiscrimination test results, participant communications, financial statements, and fidelity bond documentation. For records showing how individual benefits were calculated, ERISA Section 209 effectively requires retention until all benefits are fully paid and any audit window has closed. Keep plan-level filing records for a minimum of six years; hold participant-level records much longer.

Fix Errors Before the Auditor Finds Them

Discovering plan errors before or during an audit does not have to end in disaster. Three federal programs let sponsors fix problems with reduced consequences, and auditors generally view a sponsor’s use of these programs as evidence of good-faith compliance.

IRS Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System

EPCRS offers three pathways depending on timing and severity. The Self-Correction Program lets sponsors fix certain operational failures without contacting the IRS or paying a fee, provided the sponsor had compliance practices and procedures in place when the failure occurred. Under SECURE 2.0 Act Section 305, the correction window for eligible inadvertent failures is now indefinite, as long as the IRS has not already identified the failure and the correction is completed within a reasonable period.15Internal Revenue Service. Guidance on Section 305 of the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 That is a significant expansion from the old rule, which imposed a deadline tied to the third plan year after the failure.

The Voluntary Correction Program requires a formal submission to the IRS through Pay.gov, including Form 8950, a description of the failures, a proposed correction method, and a user fee. For 2026 submissions, user fees range from $2,000 for plans with up to $500,000 in net assets to $4,000 for plans exceeding $10 million.16Internal Revenue Service. Voluntary Correction Program (VCP) Fees The IRS issues a compliance statement upon approval, and the sponsor must complete the correction within 150 days. Once a VCP submission is pending, the IRS will generally refrain from auditing the plan on those issues while the application is being processed.17Internal Revenue Service. EPCRS Overview

If errors are found during an audit rather than beforehand, the sponsor enters the Audit Closing Agreement Program instead. Sanctions under Audit CAP are always greater than the VCP user fee and are based on factors like the number of affected employees, how long the failure lasted, and whether internal controls existed that should have caught the problem.18Internal Revenue Service. Audit Closing Agreement Program (Audit CAP) – General Description That gap is precisely why discovering and correcting errors before the audit notice arrives saves real money.

DOL Delinquent Filer Voluntary Compliance Program

For overdue Form 5500 filings, the DFVCP offers dramatically reduced penalties compared with the statutory maximums. The basic penalty is $10 per day, capped at $750 per filing for small plans and $2,000 per filing for large plans. Per-plan caps are $1,500 for small plans and $4,000 for large plans.19U.S. Department of Labor. Delinquent Filer Voluntary Compliance Program Compare those numbers with the DOL’s standard penalty of up to $2,670 per day. Note that the DFVCP only addresses the DOL penalty; it does not relieve the separate IRS penalty under IRC Section 6652(e).

DOL Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program

The VFCP covers 19 categories of fiduciary breaches, including late participant contribution deposits, prohibited transactions with parties in interest, benefit payments based on improper asset valuations, and payment of excessive compensation to service providers.20U.S. Department of Labor. Fact Sheet: Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program The sponsor must fully correct the violation, typically by restoring to the plan the principal amount involved plus the greater of lost earnings or any profits gained from using the money. In exchange, the DOL provides relief from civil enforcement actions on the corrected violation. Late deposit of participant contributions is by far the most common VFCP filing, and the DOL provides an online calculator that computes the lost earnings owed to the plan.

What to Expect During the Examination

Once documents are organized, the audit itself follows a predictable structure. The opening conference is where the IRS or DOL agent explains the scope of the review and identifies what records they will need. Expect questions about internal controls: who processes contributions, who approves distributions, what checks prevent errors.

The auditor will issue Information Document Requests specifying exactly what records to produce. Each IDR includes a deadline, and those deadlines are not suggestions. Extensions may be granted in special circumstances, but the IRS expects timely, complete written responses.21Internal Revenue Service. Navigating the IDR Process – Effective Information Gathering Keep a log of every IDR received and every document provided. If you work with a benefits attorney or third-party administrator, loop them in immediately rather than after the response deadline has started ticking.

If the auditor identifies issues, a closing conference lays out preliminary findings and gives you a chance to provide additional context or documentation before the final report. Responding effectively at this stage can sometimes resolve issues that looked like failures but were actually documentation gaps. If genuine errors remain, resolution typically involves a closing agreement under Audit CAP, with sanctions reflecting the nature and severity of the failures.18Internal Revenue Service. Audit Closing Agreement Program (Audit CAP) – General Description Outright disqualification is rare and usually reserved for egregious or uncorrected failures, but the cost of a closing agreement alone is reason enough to keep your records audit-ready year-round.