The substantially all rule in the federal R&D tax credit lets a business treat 100% of an employee’s wages as qualified research expenses when that employee spends at least 80% of their time on qualifying research activities during the tax year. Fall below 80%, and you only get to claim the actual percentage of time spent on research. The rule exists to spare companies from tracking every minute of employees who are overwhelmingly dedicated to research, and it can meaningfully change the size of a credit claim.
How the 80 Percent Threshold Works
The rule comes from 26 CFR § 1.41-2(d)(2), which defines “substantially all” as meaning at least 80% of an employee’s wages are allocated to qualified services during the tax year.1eCFR. 26 CFR 1.41-2 – Qualified Research Expenses The statute itself, 26 U.S.C. § 41(b)(2)(B), uses the phrase “substantially all” without pinning a number to it; the regulation supplies the 80%.2Internal Revenue Service. 26 USC 41 – Credit for Increasing Research Activities
Once an employee crosses the line, every dollar of that person’s wages counts as a qualified research expense, including time spent on team meetings, administrative tasks, and other non-research work bundled into the job.
Below 80%, the math changes completely. A software engineer who spends 72% of the year writing and testing new code contributes 72% of their wages to the credit calculation. The difference between 79% and 80% is not rounding. It is the difference between claiming a fraction of someone’s salary and claiming all of it. For a senior engineer earning $180,000, that one-point gap can mean an additional $36,000 flowing into the credit base.
What Time Counts Toward the 80 Percent
The statute recognizes three kinds of work as qualified services, and all three count toward the threshold.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 41 – Credit for Increasing Research Activities
- Direct research is the hands-on work: running experiments, writing code, building prototypes, designing new processes.
- Direct supervision is managing the people doing the research, but only where the supervisor has technical expertise and is actively guiding the experimental work. A VP reviewing R&D budgets does not qualify. An engineering lead reviewing experimental designs and redirecting technical approaches does.
- Direct support is work that keeps a specific research project moving without being research itself, such as a lab technician calibrating equipment for a particular experiment or a data specialist logging trial results.
All of this time only counts if the underlying work passes the four-part test for qualified research under Section 41(d): it must involve domestic research or experimental costs, be technological in nature, aim at a new or improved business component, and involve a process of experimentation directed at improving function, performance, reliability, or quality.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 US Code 41 – Credit for Increasing Research Activities Research aimed at style, cosmetic factors, or seasonal design changes is excluded by statute.
What Never Counts, Even Inside an R&D Department
The IRS Audit Techniques Guide is specific about what falls outside “direct support,” and auditors look for these. General administrative work does not qualify, even when performed inside a research group. The IRS lists payroll staff preparing checks for lab scientists, accountants tracking research expenses, janitors cleaning research facilities, and executives overseeing financial or personnel matters as non-qualifying.5Internal Revenue Service. Audit Techniques Guide – Credit for Increasing Research Activities IRC 41 – Qualified Research Expenses Marketing, manufacturing, and quality control performed after a product is already designed also fall outside the definition.
The common mistake is assuming that working in a research group automatically makes someone’s time count. It does not. The work itself, not the department, determines qualification.
Which Wages Get Multiplied by the Percentage
For W-2 employees, the wage figure used in the 80/20 calculation is the amount in Box 1 of the W-2. That captures base salary plus taxable bonuses, income from exercising non-qualified stock options, and restricted stock that vested during the year. For partners and sole proprietors, the relevant figure is net self-employment income. Employer-paid retirement contributions and health insurance premiums are excluded from the wage definition.
So when an employee clears 80%, you take their full Box 1 wages into the QRE calculation. When they fall short, you take their actual research-time percentage of those wages.
Contractors Do Not Get the 80/20 Treatment
The substantially all rule applies only to in-house employees. Payments to independent contractors and outside research firms fall under a separate category called contract research expenses, and the 80/20 threshold does not apply. Only 65% of amounts paid to most contractors count as qualified research expenses. That rate rises to 75% for payments to qualified research consortiums and 100% for payments to certain small businesses, universities, and federal laboratories for energy research.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 41 – Credit for Increasing Research Activities Companies that rely heavily on contract researchers cannot use the 80/20 rule to inflate their claim, and the IRS watches this line closely.
Documenting the 80 Percent, Employee by Employee
The IRS analyzes the substantially all rule on an employee-by-employee basis, so your documentation has to work at that same level of detail.5Internal Revenue Service. Audit Techniques Guide – Credit for Increasing Research Activities IRC 41 – Qualified Research Expenses For each person included in the credit, you need records showing total hours worked, hours spent on qualified activities, the specific projects those hours relate to, and what technical uncertainty each project was trying to resolve. Project management software, timesheets, and payroll records form the backbone of that record.
Organizational charts help explain why a particular employee qualifies under direct supervision or direct support. Narrative documentation covering the technical goals of each project and each person’s role is what ties the numbers to the legal requirements. The companies that struggle in audits are almost always the ones that assembled documentation after the fact. Contemporaneous records carry far more weight than reconstructed estimates.
Statistical Sampling for Larger Workforces
Companies with large numbers of employees or projects may not need to document every person individually. The IRS has acknowledged that statistical sampling can be appropriate when a full review would be impractical. As a general guideline, cases involving fewer than 50 sampling units (employees, projects, or contracts) are better handled through direct review, while larger populations may benefit from stratified sampling.6Internal Revenue Service. Field Directive – Use of Sampling Methodologies in Research Credit Cases When a company uses departmental accounting and cannot break costs down by project, IRS guidance suggests using individual employees as the sampling unit and reviewing the projects each sampled employee worked on to determine whether their wages qualify.
Sampling changes the mechanics of proof, not the underlying rule. Each sampled employee still has to clear (or miss) the 80% threshold based on their own work, and the results are then extrapolated across the population.