State Farm Policyholder Class Action: Depreciation, Totaled Cars, and Bias

State Farm, the largest property and casualty insurer in the United States, is defending a wave of policyholder class action lawsuits that touch nearly every major line of its business. The active cases include homeowners claims where plaintiffs say State Farm wrongly subtracted labor costs or sales tax when calculating “actual cash value,” auto cases over how totaled vehicles are valued, an underinsured motorist suit in New Mexico, and a Fair Housing Act case alleging that claims-processing algorithms disadvantage Black homeowners. Whether you may be covered depends on your state, the type of policy, and the date of your loss.

Homeowners Claims: Depreciation Disputes

The most common theory in these cases is that State Farm understates “actual cash value” (ACV) — the replacement cost minus depreciation — by subtracting things that shouldn’t depreciate at all. Shingles age; the labor to install them doesn’t. Sales tax isn’t a physical characteristic of an item. Plaintiffs in multiple states have pressed those arguments and reached settlements, with new cases still in progress.

Missouri: Pregon v. State Farm

In Pregon v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Company (Case No. 24SL-CC03130, Circuit Court of St. Louis County), Missouri policyholders challenged State Farm’s deduction of “Non-Material Depreciation” and “General Contractor Overhead and Profit Depreciation” from ACV payments on structural damage claims.1Pregon v. State Farm Settlement. Pregon v. State Farm Settlement Homepage The class covers Missouri policyholders with dates of loss between June 5, 2012, and approximately October 2017 who had those deductions applied.2Pregon v. State Farm Settlement. Frequently Asked Questions Payments are calculated by formula rather than from a lump-sum fund, with 8.9% annual simple interest running from August 2021.3Pregon v. State Farm Settlement. Stipulation and Settlement Agreement The final fairness hearing took place on March 3, 2026, and the claim submission deadline of April 2, 2026, has passed.

Alabama and Mississippi: Labor Depreciation Settlements

In Arnold v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Company (No. 2:2017cv00148, S.D. Ala.), the court approved a settlement covering Alabama policyholders with dates of loss between March 2011 and August 2017. State Farm agreed to pay 100% of withheld labor depreciation, plus interest and a share of withheld overhead and profit amounts. The deal was estimated at more than $38 million, and the case was dismissed with prejudice in October 2022.4Justia. Arnold v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Company A parallel Mississippi case settled on similar terms, estimated at more than $11.5 million.5MSB. Case Results

California: Pitkin v. State Farm (Sales Tax)

If you had covered personal property losses in California, a different depreciation case may apply. Pitkin v. State Farm General Insurance Company (No. 3:23-cv-00924, N.D. Cal.) was filed by homeowners who lost personal property in the 2020 Walbridge Fire. They allege State Farm improperly subtracts sales tax when calculating ACV benefits, since sales tax is a cost of replacement, not a feature of the item that wears out.6Bloomberg Tax. State Farm Facing Certified Class in Sales Tax Depreciation Suit State Farm concedes the practice but argues it is lawful under California Insurance Code section 2051(b).7Policyholder Pulse. Pitkin v. State Farm Class Certification Order

On July 15, 2025, Judge William H. Orrick certified a class of approximately 200,000 California policyholders who suffered covered personal property losses between March 1, 2019, and July 15, 2025, and received ACV payments reduced by sales tax depreciation. The opt-out deadline is May 28, 2026, and trial is set for September 8, 2026. No settlement has been reached.8State Farm Sales Tax Depreciation Lawsuit. Pitkin v. State Farm Settlement Website

Totaled Vehicle Payouts: The Audatex Cases

When a car is a total loss, State Farm owes the vehicle’s actual cash value. Several class actions attack a specific calculation step: a “typical negotiation adjustment” of roughly 4–11% that was subtracted from the listed prices of comparable vehicles in appraisal reports from the vendor Audatex, on the theory that buyers usually negotiate below sticker. State Farm stopped using Audatex in October 2021.9Auto Body News. State Farm to Pay $15.6M to Settle Arkansas Class Action Over Total Loss Valuations

Arkansas: Chadwick v. State Farm

Chadwick v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (No. 4:21-cv-01161, E.D. Ark.) went to trial in June 2025, and a jury found State Farm had breached its contract by applying the typical negotiation adjustment to roughly 37,000 Arkansas class members.9Auto Body News. State Farm to Pay $15.6M to Settle Arkansas Class Action Over Total Loss Valuations The parties then reached a $15.6 million settlement covering policyholders who filed total-loss claims between November 2016 and October 2021 and received payouts calculated using Audatex reports with the adjustment. The estimated average recovery is about $489.10Insurance Journal. State Farm Total Loss Settlement Judge D.P. Marshall Jr. granted preliminary approval in March 2026, with a final approval hearing scheduled for July 15, 2026.11Top Class Actions. State Farm Settlement Over Totaled Car Payouts Receives Preliminary Approval

Kansas: Gulick v. State Farm

Paula Gulick, et al. v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. (No. 2:21-cv-2573, D. Kan.) raises the same issue in Kansas. The court certified the class on April 30, 2025, covering Kansas residents who filed total-loss claims and received compensation potentially based on Audatex valuations between December 2017 and April 2025. The case has not settled. Trial is scheduled to begin February 2, 2027.12State Farm KS Total Loss Litigation. Frequently Asked Questions

Illinois and North Carolina

Not every total-loss case has moved forward. In Williams v. State Farm (No. 1:22-cv-01422, N.D. Ill.), Judge Virginia Kendall denied class certification in March 2026, finding individualized issues predominated.13Law360. State Farm Drivers Denied Class Cert in Car Value Suit In North Carolina, Craig Brewer v. State Farm alleges underpayment through “condition adjustments” and claims violations of the state’s Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act. State Farm moved to dismiss in November 2025, arguing the plaintiff refused to participate in the policy’s mandatory appraisal process.14Repairer Driven News. State Farm Wants North Carolina Class Action Thrown Out or Court to Order Appraisal

Washington: Hardy Diminished-Value Settlement

A separate auto-side case, Hardy v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (No. 2:25-cv-00072, W.D. Wash.), received preliminary approval on June 17, 2026, for an $8.8 million settlement resolving diminished-value claims by Washington policyholders.15Law360. $8.8M Deal in State Farm Diminished Value Suit Gets First OK

New Mexico: Underinsured Motorist Offsets

Schwartz v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (No. 18-cv-00328, D.N.M.) involves underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage. The plaintiff alleges State Farm sold UIM coverage without explaining the “Schmick Offset” — the practice of reducing UIM payouts by amounts recovered from the at-fault driver’s insurer. The suit asserts negligence, misrepresentation, and violations of New Mexico’s Unfair Trade Practices and Unfair Insurance Practices Acts.16Schwartz UIM Class Settlement. Frequently Asked Questions

The settlement is capped at $20,925,000 and covers individuals insured under New Mexico State Farm policies with UIM coverage between January 2010 and December 2021. Eligible class members can receive up to 21% of premiums paid for minimum-limits coverage, or 13% for higher-limits coverage, subject to pro rata reduction if claims exceed the cap. The claim deadline is July 2, 2026, with a final fairness hearing set for June 8, 2026.17Schwartz UIM Class Settlement. Schwartz UIM Class Settlement Homepage

Algorithmic Bias in Homeowners Claims

Jacqueline Huskey, et al. v. State Farm Fire and Casualty (No. 1:22-cv-07014, N.D. Ill.) alleges that State Farm’s claims-processing algorithms disproportionately flag Black homeowners’ insurance claims for extra scrutiny, in violation of the Fair Housing Act. The complaint, filed in December 2022, cites a 2021 YouGov survey finding Black policyholders were 39% more likely than white homeowners to be required to submit additional paperwork. One plaintiff alleges her storm-damage claim faced roughly three months of additional processing time compared to a white neighbor’s claim for identical damage from the same storm.18Sanford Heisler Sharp McKnight. State Farm Algorithm Bias Lawsuit

In September 2023, the court let the disparate-impact claim under Section 3604(b) of the Fair Housing Act proceed, finding the statistical evidence sufficient at the pleading stage. The court dismissed other claims, including a request for injunctive relief because the lead plaintiff was no longer a State Farm policyholder.19Saul Ewing. The Use of AI in the Insurance Policy Lifecycle and Legal Implications As of early 2025, the case was in discovery, with no class certification ruling or trial date yet set.20Wiley. AI in the Insurance Industry and Bad Faith Risk

Ohio: 1.4 Million-Policyholder Class

In Ohio, a class of more than 1.4 million policyholders was certified in a case alleging State Farm failed to disclose a 1994 Ohio Supreme Court ruling that made a specific policy exclusion unenforceable. Plaintiffs say they lost the chance to reduce their premiums without losing coverage.21NPHM. Class Action for 1.4 Million Policyholders Certified Against State Farm

The Hale RICO Settlement (Closed)

The largest policyholder settlement against State Farm by dollar amount, Hale v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (No. 12-cv-00660, S.D. Ill.), resolved for $250 million. The case grew out of an earlier Illinois state court judgment of $1.05 billion in Avery v. State Farm over the use of non-original-equipment-manufacturer crash parts in vehicle repairs. The Hale plaintiffs alleged under the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act that State Farm secretly funded the Illinois Supreme Court campaign of a justice who later participated in overturning the Avery judgment.22Top Class Actions. State Farm Non-OEM Crash Parts Class Action Settlement

The class covered consumers nationwide (excluding Arkansas and Tennessee) insured by State Farm between July 1987 and February 1998 whose vehicle repair claims had non-OEM crash parts used or specified. The court granted final approval in December 2018, and payments began in October 2019, with some recipients receiving additional distributions as recently as 2022.22Top Class Actions. State Farm Non-OEM Crash Parts Class Action Settlement State Farm admitted no wrongdoing. The claim window has closed.

California Regulatory and Antitrust Actions

These aren’t private class actions, but they affect California policyholders and are often grouped with the private suits. On May 4, 2026, the California Department of Insurance filed an accusation and order to show cause against State Farm General Insurance Company over handling of claims from the January 2025 Los Angeles wildfires. A market conduct examination of 220 sample claims found 398 violations of state law in roughly half the files, including delays, unreasonably low settlement offers, excessive reassignment of adjusters, and mishandling of smoke-damage claims.23California Department of Insurance. CDI Enforcement Action Against State Farm General The department is seeking fines of roughly $2 million to $4.3 million and a possible one-year suspension of State Farm’s certificate of authority to write new policies in the state. A hearing before an administrative law judge has not been scheduled.24CalMatters. State Farm California Violations

Separately, State Farm and more than a dozen other California homeowners insurers are defendants in antitrust lawsuits in Los Angeles County Superior Court. Plaintiffs Todd and Kimberley Ferrier, whose homes were destroyed in the wildfires, allege the insurers conspired to cancel fire policies in wildfire-prone areas, forcing homeowners onto the California FAIR Plan, which they say offers less coverage at higher prices.25Los Angeles Times. Judge Denies Move to Dismiss State Farm Collusion Lawsuit On May 14, 2026, Judge Samantha Jessner denied the insurers’ motion to dismiss. The U.S. Department of Justice filed a brief supporting the plaintiffs’ position, arguing the alleged group boycott is conduct separate from the insurers’ petitioning of state regulators and shouldn’t be shielded by the Noerr-Pennington doctrine.26Insurance Journal. State Farm Insurer Collusion Lawsuit Proceeds

If You Think You’re a Class Member

Eligibility in each of these cases turns on three things: the state where your policy was issued, the type of claim or coverage, and the date of loss or policy period. The relevant class definitions are set out on the official settlement websites cited above, along with claim deadlines, opt-out deadlines, and hearing dates. Claim windows are strict; the Pregon deadline, for example, has already closed, while others remain open into mid-2026. If your situation looks like it fits a class definition and the deadline has not passed, the settlement administrator for that specific case is the right first stop.