Operating lease liabilities behave like debt in most of the ways that matter for financial analysis, and under ASC 842 and IFRS 16 they now sit on the balance sheet where debt sits. So yes, operating leases are generally considered debt, or at least debt-equivalent, in serious credit and valuation work. The harder question is how much weight to give them, because the answer shifts depending on the ratio you are calculating, the industry, and whose methodology you are following.
Why Operating Leases Look Like Debt
The core argument is straightforward. Lease payments are fixed, non-discretionary obligations. Miss them and the company loses access to assets it needs to run: stores, aircraft, distribution centers, equipment. Defaulting on rent for a warehouse disrupts operations the same way missing a bank loan payment would, and the present value of those future payments is a real claim on future cash flows.
That is exactly the logic behind ASC 842 (issued by FASB) and IFRS 16 (issued by IASB). Under the previous U.S. standard, ASC 840, companies could keep operating leases off the balance sheet entirely, disclosing billions in commitments only in footnotes. A retailer that leased its stores looked far less leveraged than a competitor that borrowed to buy identical buildings. Both standards closed that gap by requiring lessees to record a right-of-use asset and a lease liability equal to the present value of future non-cancelable payments, for virtually any lease longer than 12 months.1Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. Appendix B – Differences Between U.S. GAAP and IFRS Accounting Standards
So the accounting bodies have already answered part of the question: for balance-sheet reporting, operating lease obligations are liabilities. The remaining question is analytical. Should you add them to funded debt when you calculate leverage, coverage, and valuation ratios?
Where Lease Liabilities Diverge From Traditional Debt
Full equivalence breaks down in a few places, and understanding where matters more than picking a side.
Collateral runs the other direction. Traditional secured debt is backed by specific collateral the lender can seize. A lease works in reverse: if the lessee stops paying, it loses the right to use the asset, but the lessor does not gain a general claim on the lessee’s other property the way a secured lender would. Lease default is operationally devastating and structurally simpler at the same time.
Cash flow classification also differs. Finance lease principal payments show up in financing activities on the cash flow statement, which mirrors a loan repayment. Operating lease payments, on the other hand, flow entirely through operating activities.2Deloitte Accounting Research Tool. 7.6 Leases – Statement of Cash Flows Two companies with identical total fixed obligations can therefore report very different operating cash flow depending on how those obligations are structured. Any screen or model that leans heavily on cash flow from operations needs to account for that.
Income statement treatment splits as well. ASC 842 keeps two categories: finance leases produce front-loaded expense (amortization plus interest), while operating leases produce a single straight-line expense that resembles the old rent line. IFRS 16 uses a single model that effectively treats every lease like a finance lease. An IFRS company and an otherwise identical U.S. GAAP company can carry the same lease liability and still report different expense timing.
How the Rating Agencies Answer the Question
The three major credit rating agencies have each landed in a different place, which itself is worth noting. If there were a clean answer, they would have converged.
Moody’s
Moody’s has long treated operating leases as debt-equivalent. Its methodology simulates what the financial statements would look like if the company had bought the leased assets with borrowed money. Moody’s capitalizes leases by multiplying annual rent expense by a factor of 5x, 6x, 8x, or 10x depending on the sector, reflecting different asset useful lives and interest rate assumptions. When the present value of minimum lease payments comes in higher than the multiple-based estimate, Moody’s uses the higher figure.3Moody’s Investors Service. Analytical Adjustments: Approach to Global Standard Adjustments in the Analysis of Financial Statements
On the income statement, Moody’s reclassifies roughly one-third of rent expense to interest and the remaining two-thirds to depreciation. It also moves the principal portion of lease payments out of operating cash flow and into financing, treating those payments the same as loan repayments.3Moody’s Investors Service. Analytical Adjustments: Approach to Global Standard Adjustments in the Analysis of Financial Statements
S&P Global Ratings
S&P works from present value. For operating leases not already on the balance sheet, S&P discounts future payments at 7%. When the disclosed payment schedule ends in a “thereafter” lump sum beyond year five, S&P assumes annual payments equal to the fifth-year amount, capped at a total profile of 30 years.4S&P Global Ratings. Credit Rating Model: S&P Global Ratings Arrow Basic
Fitch Ratings
Fitch has moved. In 2020, it excluded leases from debt for most corporate sectors and applied a multiple approach only in lease-heavy industries such as retail, while using the reported lease liability directly in transportation.5Fitch Ratings. What Investors Want to Know: Lease Accounting More recently, Fitch has shifted toward using reported ASC 842 and IFRS 16 lease liabilities as a proxy for lease debt across sectors, replacing its earlier multiple-based method.6Fitch Ratings. Lower Leverage Under Lease Criteria Balanced by Coverage and Other Factors
The takeaway is not that one agency is right. It is that “include operating leases in debt” is a defensible default across the market, but the size of the adjustment and the way it flows through other statements is a judgment call.
What Including Leases Does to Your Ratios
Once you decide to treat operating lease liabilities as debt, the effects show up across several widely used metrics. In asset-intensive sectors like retail, airlines, and restaurants, the shifts can be dramatic.
Leverage Ratios
Debt-to-equity rises because reported liabilities go up while equity stays put. For heavy lessees this jump can be large. Debt-to-assets also increases, but less steeply, because the right-of-use asset partially offsets the liability on the other side of the balance sheet. Both numerator and denominator grow, and the ratio still moves higher, just not as sharply.
EBITDA and Valuation Multiples
This is where analysts most often go wrong. Under the old rules, operating lease payments sat in rent expense and were deducted before EBITDA. Under ASC 842, that same cash outflow gets split into amortization and interest, both of which sit below the EBITDA line. Reported EBITDA rises mechanically. Nothing about the business has changed.
If a company had $100 million in annual rent that migrated below the line, reported EBITDA jumps by $100 million. That inflated figure then feeds valuation multiples like EV/EBITDA unless the analyst is careful. The cleanest approach is to match numerator and denominator. If enterprise value includes lease debt, use EBITDAR (EBITDA before rent) so both sides consistently reflect the lease obligation. If enterprise value excludes lease debt, traditional EBITDA works. Combining an enterprise value that includes lease liabilities with a lease-inflated EBITDA produces a misleading multiple in either direction.
Net Debt-to-EBITDA
The workhorse of credit analysis takes a hit from both ends. Net debt increases as the lease liability enters the numerator, and EBITDA increases as rent leaves it. The two effects can partially offset each other, making the ratio look deceptively stable when both components have moved materially. Comparing this ratio across the pre- and post-ASC 842 line without adjustment is meaningless.
Practical Rules for Handling Leases in Debt Analysis
A few working principles hold up regardless of which methodology you adopt.
Be internally consistent. If you count the lease liability as debt on the balance sheet, carry that treatment through to the income statement and cash flow adjustments. Adding leases to leverage while leaving EBITDA and operating cash flow untouched produces numbers that flatter the borrower.
Consider a partial approach when full inclusion overstates risk. Some models include only the current portion of the lease liability in adjusted debt. Others apply a haircut to the full liability, reflecting the view that lease obligations carry lower default risk than secured bank debt. Both are defensible if applied consistently across the peer set.
Normalize historical trends. A leverage ratio from 2024 under ASC 842 is not directly comparable to the same ratio from 2018 under ASC 840. FASB offered two transition paths, and most companies chose not to restate prior periods, applying the standard only from the adoption date forward with a cumulative adjustment. If you are building a multi-year trend, either find a voluntary restatement or manually estimate the historical lease liability. Reading the adoption-date jump as real deterioration is one of the more common errors in post-842 analysis.
Use the comparability the standard gave you. Before ASC 842, two retailers with identical store footprints could report dramatically different balance sheets depending on whether they owned or leased. That distortion is largely gone. Peer comparisons on leverage and returns are now more reliable than they were under the old rules, provided you treat each company’s lease obligations the same way.
A Note on Loan Covenants
Lease liabilities appearing on the balance sheet did not automatically trigger covenant breaches for existing borrowers. Many credit agreements were amended before adoption to “freeze” GAAP at the pre-842 standard for covenant purposes, so lease liabilities appear in the financial statements but sit outside the leverage calculation for the life of the loan. New credit agreements written after ASC 842 took effect build the lease liability into their thresholds from the start. If you are analyzing covenant headroom, read the definitions in the credit agreement rather than assuming the GAAP balance sheet flows through unchanged.