A “Shop with MR Points” charge means American Express Membership Rewards points were used to pay for an Amazon purchase through Amazon’s Shop with Points feature. If you recognize the order, the entry is simply recording that your points, rather than a dollar amount on your card, covered part or all of the checkout. If you don’t recognize it, two things are likely: your Amex card was auto-enrolled in the program and points were applied to a purchase you made without noticing, or someone added your card to their own Amazon account and spent your points.
Why This Charge Shows Up Without Warning
American Express and Amazon automatically enroll Membership Rewards cards in Shop with Points after the card is used for Amazon purchases.1The Points Guy. Deactivate Shop with Points Amazon Once enrolled, a “Pay with Points” option appears at checkout by default, and clicking quickly through the payment screen can apply points instead of, or alongside, a card charge. Enrollment in the program and activation of points as a default payment are separate settings, and the distinction is easy to miss.
The more serious cause is fraud. Criminals who obtain your card details — often from a breach at a third-party retailer — add the card to their own Amazon account, activate Shop with Points, and spend your rewards balance on items shipped to themselves.2PCMag. Shop on Amazon? Watch Out for This Sneaky Credit Card Points Scam Because a points redemption doesn’t generate a traditional dollar charge, it often fails to trigger the fraud alerts banks rely on. Cardholders typically get no notice when their card is linked to someone else’s Amazon account and no alert when points are spent. Victims usually find out only by checking their Membership Rewards balance. Reddit threads for Amex Platinum cardholders describe losses through this method, including one user who reported 500,000 Membership Rewards points drained.3Yahoo Finance. Watch for Shop with Points Scam on Amazon
Check Your Membership Rewards Activity
Before calling anyone, pull up the points history. In the Amex app or on americanexpress.com, open the Membership Rewards section and review recent redemption activity. That will show whether points were spent, when, and in some cases on what. Compare the dates and amounts against your Amazon order history. Anything that doesn’t match your own orders is a candidate for a fraud report.
Also log into Amazon and check Your Account for payment methods and linked rewards programs you don’t recognize. Remove anything that isn’t yours.
Report Unauthorized Redemptions to American Express
If points were redeemed without your authorization, call Amex using the number on the back of your card and ask to open a fraud investigation on the Membership Rewards account. Major issuers have restored stolen points balances once the unauthorized activity is confirmed; Chase, for instance, has stated that customers are not held responsible for unauthorized redemptions in confirmed fraud cases and are reimbursed for lost points.2PCMag. Shop on Amazon? Watch Out for This Sneaky Credit Card Points Scam Public documentation of Amex’s specific reimbursement process for this scheme is thinner, but the pattern across issuers has been to restore points once fraud is verified.
Amazon also provides a dedicated scam-reporting page for cases where the victim never shared information with the fraudster, and Amazon says it notifies the rewards partner — the bank — of every enrollment attempt so the issuer can monitor for suspicious activity.2PCMag. Shop on Amazon? Watch Out for This Sneaky Credit Card Points Scam Amazon does not notify the cardholder directly, because it does not necessarily know who the primary cardholder is.
If you made the purchase yourself but didn’t mean to pay with points, canceling the order before it ships triggers an automatic points refund within 48 hours. Returning the item after delivery also results in a refund, though Amazon applies refunds to other payment methods first before restoring points.4Amazon. Shop with Points Help
Turn Off Shop with Points on Amazon
To stop future surprise redemptions, unenroll the card. On Amazon, go to Your Account, open Amazon Wallet, and find the Shop with Points section. Click the enrolled card and select Unenroll.5Amazon. Shop with Points Account Management For stronger protection, remove the Amex card from your Amazon payment methods entirely, because simply unenrolling can still leave the door open to re-enrollment later.1The Points Guy. Deactivate Shop with Points Amazon
While you’re in Amazon, also review the shipping addresses saved on your account and delete any you don’t recognize.
Where Consumer Protection Law Fits
Rewards points sit awkwardly in consumer protection law. The Fair Credit Billing Act gives you strong rights to dispute billing errors on a credit card statement, including unauthorized charges, within 60 days of the statement date; a written dispute triggers an investigation during which the issuer cannot report the balance as delinquent and must resolve the matter within two billing cycles or 90 days.6Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. How Do I Dispute a Charge on My Credit Card Bill If the dispute is decided in your favor, the charge, fees, and interest must be removed.7California Office of the Attorney General. Credit Cards – Dispute a Charge
A points redemption that never produces a dollar charge on your statement may not fit neatly into that framework. In practice, issuers have handled Shop with Points fraud through their own fraud and rewards departments rather than through a formal FCBA dispute. The CFPB has flagged broader consumer frustrations with rewards programs, including redemption problems and customer service obstacles, but has not taken public enforcement action specifically on Shop with Points fraud.8Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. CFPB Report Highlights Consumer Frustrations with Credit Card Rewards Programs American Express’s rewards program terms also reserve the right to change the program at any time, often without notice.9Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Credit Card Rewards Issue Spotlight The practical route to recovering stolen points is still a direct call to Amex.