The difference between self-funded and fully funded health plans comes down to who carries the risk when claims arrive. In a fully funded plan, the employer pays a fixed monthly premium to an insurance carrier, and the carrier is on the hook for whatever the medical bills turn out to be. In a self-funded plan, the employer pays claims directly out of its own assets, usually with a third-party administrator running the mechanics and stop-loss insurance capping the downside. That single structural choice ripples into cost, cash flow, tax exposure, plan design freedom, and which government agencies regulate the plan.
About 67% of covered workers in the U.S. are enrolled in self-funded plans, and the share climbs to 80% at companies with 200 or more employees.1Kaiser Family Foundation. Employer Health Benefits 2025 Annual Survey
How the Money Moves in Each Model
Under a fully funded arrangement, the employer sends the carrier a set premium each month for every enrolled employee. That premium covers expected claims, the carrier’s administrative overhead, and its profit margin. If claims run higher than premiums collected, the carrier absorbs the loss. If claims run lower, the carrier keeps the difference. The employer buys budgetary certainty and gives up any upside from a healthy year.
The carrier runs the plan: provider networks, claims processing, ID cards, member calls, coverage compliance. Federal law requires fully insured carriers to spend at least 80% of premium dollars on actual medical care in the small-group and individual markets, and at least 85% in the large-group market, with the balance covering administration and profit.2Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Medical Loss Ratio Carriers that miss those thresholds must issue rebates to plan members.
Self-funding flips the model. The employer pays claims directly from its own assets or a dedicated trust and sets aside a claims fund based on actuarial projections of expected utilization. Those funds stay in the employer’s accounts, earning interest or returns until a claim is actually paid. In exchange, the employer bears the risk when claims come in high and needs enough cash flow to absorb month-to-month volatility.
Most self-funded employers hire a third-party administrator (TPA) to handle operations: claims processing, network management, benefit coordination, and member communications. TPA fees are typically charged per employee per month. Because the employer is paying only for healthcare actually used plus a flat administrative fee, it avoids the profit and risk charges baked into fully insured premiums.
One quieter advantage of self-funding is data access. Self-funded employers receive detailed claims data showing where the healthcare dollars go, which providers drive costs, and which conditions are most prevalent in the workforce. Fully insured employers generally don’t have that visibility, since the carrier owns the data.
Where the Cost Difference Actually Comes From
The core financial argument for self-funding is that you stop paying someone else’s profit margin and risk load. In a fully insured plan, up to 15% to 20% of every premium dollar goes to the carrier’s administrative costs and profit.2Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Medical Loss Ratio A self-funded employer replaces that with a TPA fee and keeps whatever savings come from a year of lower-than-expected claims.
Self-funded plans also avoid state premium taxes, which fully insured carriers must pay and pass through to the employer. Those taxes vary by state and carrier type, generally ranging from under 1% to over 5% of premiums.3National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Premium Tax Rate by Line On $1 million in premium, even a 2% tax adds $20,000 a year.
Both plan types owe a per-covered-life fee funding the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute. For plan years ending between October 1, 2025, and September 30, 2026, the fee is $3.84 per covered life.4Internal Revenue Service. Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Trust Fund Fee Questions and Answers Modest, but it applies regardless of funding model.
The downside of self-funding is volatility. A single transplant, premature birth, or cancer diagnosis can generate hundreds of thousands of dollars in claims. Fully insured plans trade away potential savings for the certainty that this year’s costs won’t exceed this year’s premiums.
Stop-Loss Insurance: How Self-Funded Employers Cap the Risk
Self-funded doesn’t mean unlimited exposure. Most self-funded employers buy stop-loss insurance, which reimburses the employer when claims exceed a defined threshold. Two forms exist, and most employers carry both.
- Specific (individual) stop-loss protects against catastrophic claims from a single member. The employer picks a deductible, often called the attachment point, and the carrier reimburses anything above it. Attachment points typically start around $15,000 for small groups and can exceed $1,000,000 for very large employers. A group under 50 employees might carry a $50,000 specific deductible; a group over 150 might set it at $150,000 or higher.5U.S. Department of Labor. Unified Group Services Response to Departments Request for Information
- Aggregate stop-loss caps total plan-wide claims for the year. The attachment point is calculated as a percentage of expected claims, with 120% and 125% being the most common multipliers. If total claims exceed that ceiling, the carrier reimburses the overage.6Society of Actuaries. Health Watch – Buying and Selling Employer Stop-loss Is Simple Or Is It
Stop-loss carriers don’t always offer a uniform deductible across the group. When an employee has a known high-cost condition, the carrier may “laser” that individual by assigning a higher specific deductible for that person alone. A lasered member might carry a $200,000 specific deductible while the rest of the group sits at $75,000. The employer absorbs more risk for that individual before stop-loss kicks in, and the surprise often lands at renewal if someone was diagnosed with a chronic condition during the prior plan year.
The Regulatory Split Is Bigger Than It Looks
The regulatory divide between these models is one of the most consequential factors in the decision, and it’s often underestimated.
ERISA Preemption vs. State Insurance Law
Self-funded plans are governed primarily by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), a federal law setting minimum standards for employee benefit plans in private industry.7U.S. Department of Labor. Employee Retirement Income Security Act ERISA’s preemption clause at 29 U.S.C. ยง 1144 keeps states from treating self-funded plans as insurance companies subject to state regulation.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1144 – Other Laws For an employer with workers in multiple states, that means one uniform plan instead of 50 sets of mandated benefits and coverage rules.
Fully insured plans fall under state insurance department jurisdiction. Each state dictates which benefits the plan must cover, how premiums are rated, and what solvency requirements the carrier must maintain. An employer with staff in 15 states faces 15 regulatory regimes if it’s fully insured.
What ERISA Still Requires
Federal preemption doesn’t mean self-funded plans are unregulated. Employers must provide participants with a Summary Plan Description written clearly enough for the average participant to understand their rights and obligations.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1022 – Summary Plan Description Plan fiduciaries must manage the plan solely in participants’ interests, with the care and diligence a prudent person would exercise in a similar role.10Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1104 – Fiduciary Duties The plan must also file an annual Form 5500 with the Department of Labor.
ERISA gives participants the right to sue to recover benefits, enforce plan terms, or seek relief for fiduciary breaches, and the Secretary of Labor can bring enforcement actions and collect civil penalties.11Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1132 – Civil Enforcement ERISA litigation over denied claims is common, and courts hold plan administrators to the fiduciary standard when reviewing claims decisions.
ACA Essential Health Benefits and Mental Health Parity
The Affordable Care Act’s essential health benefits mandate applies to fully insured plans in the individual and small-group markets. It does not apply to self-insured group health plans or to large-group fully insured plans.12U.S. Department of Labor. FAQ About Affordable Care Act Implementation Part 66 Self-insured plans that do cover essential health benefits must still comply with the ACA’s ban on annual and lifetime dollar limits for those benefits, but they have more flexibility in deciding what the plan covers in the first place.
The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act applies to both funding models. Financial requirements and treatment limitations on mental health and substance use disorder benefits must be no more restrictive than those on medical and surgical benefits.13U.S. Department of Labor. Self-Compliance Tool for the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act Self-funded employers sometimes assume federal preemption exempts them from parity rules; it doesn’t. The Department of Labor has primary enforcement authority over parity compliance for private-sector self-funded plans.
Nondiscrimination Testing
Self-insured health plans must pass nondiscrimination testing under Internal Revenue Code Section 105(h). The plan can’t provide more favorable eligibility or benefits to highly compensated individuals, defined as the five highest-paid officers, anyone owning more than 10% of the company, or the highest-paid 25% of employees. Failing either the eligibility test or the benefits test makes reimbursements to highly compensated individuals taxable income. Fully insured plans face a parallel ACA nondiscrimination requirement on paper, but enforcement guidance has been indefinitely delayed.
Level-Funded Plans as the Middle Path
Level-funded plans sit between the two models and have become popular with smaller employers testing self-funding. The employer makes a fixed monthly payment split into three buckets: a claims fund for expected medical costs, a stop-loss premium that caps downside risk, and an administrative fee for the TPA.
The difference from a fully insured plan shows up at year-end. If actual claims come in below the amount set aside, the employer receives a refund or a credit toward the next plan year. In a fully insured arrangement, that surplus belongs to the carrier.
Because level-funded plans are technically self-insured, they’re generally governed by ERISA rather than state insurance law, which carries the same regulatory advantages as a traditional self-funded plan, including exemption from state benefit mandates. For employers with 25 to 100 employees who want cost transparency without the full volatility of self-funding, level-funded plans are often the entry point.
Which Model Fits Your Company
There’s no legal minimum size for self-funding. Employers with as few as 25 employees run viable self-insured plans, though the math gets riskier with a smaller risk pool. The practical threshold has more to do with cash reserves and risk tolerance than headcount. A 40-person company with young, healthy employees and strong cash flow may be a better self-funding candidate than a 200-person firm with thin margins and an aging workforce.
Self-funding tends to work when the employer has predictable cash flow to absorb claims volatility, enough enrolled employees to spread risk meaningfully, a reason to want plan design flexibility and exemption from state mandates, and the administrative capacity to handle ERISA compliance and reporting.
Fully insured plans tend to work when the employer needs fixed, predictable costs with no exposure to claims volatility, lacks the cash reserves to handle a bad claims year, operates in a single state where mandate compliance isn’t burdensome, or has a small enough workforce that one catastrophic claim could overwhelm the claims fund even with stop-loss protection.
Level-funded plans deserve a serious look for employers in the 25-to-200 range who want the data transparency and potential savings of self-funding but aren’t ready for full financial exposure. The fixed monthly payment and year-end surplus refund offer a reasonable middle path, and most level-funded plans include built-in stop-loss coverage that limits downside from the start.