To waive family attribution under Section 302(c)(2) and get capital-gain treatment on a stock redemption, you must clear a 10-year lookback on intra-family stock transfers, hold no interest in the corporation other than as a creditor for the 10 years after the redemption, file a written agreement statement with your tax return, and notify the IRS within 30 days if you acquire a prohibited interest during that decade. The Section 302(c)(2) family attribution waiver requirements are strict, and courts read them as bright-line rules rather than case-by-case judgment calls.
What the Waiver Actually Does
Section 318(a)(1) treats you as constructively owning stock held by your spouse (unless legally separated under a divorce or separate maintenance decree), children, grandchildren, and parents.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 318 – Constructive Ownership of Stock Adopted children count the same as biological ones. Siblings, grandparents, aunts, uncles, and in-laws are not on the list. So a parent who surrenders every share they personally own may still be treated as owning the shares held by their adult children, defeating the “complete termination of interest” test under Section 302(b)(3) that would produce exchange treatment.
Section 302(c)(2) lets the departing shareholder switch off family attribution, but only for family attribution under Section 318(a)(1). Entity-to-beneficiary attribution, partnership attribution, and option attribution under the other parts of Section 318 are untouched. If any of those forms of constructive ownership independently prevent a complete termination, the waiver cannot rescue the redemption.
The 10-Year Lookback on Prior Family Transfers
Before the waiver can apply, you have to pass a backward-looking test covering the 10 years before the redemption date. Section 302(c)(2)(B) blocks the waiver in two situations: if you acquired any portion of the redeemed stock from a related person during that window, or if you transferred stock to a related person who still holds those shares at the time of redemption (unless that person’s shares are redeemed in the same transaction).2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 302 – Distributions in Redemption of Stock
Both bars have an escape valve. The lookback does not apply if you can demonstrate that the acquisition or transfer “did not have as one of its principal purposes the avoidance of Federal income tax.” In Revenue Ruling 77-293, the IRS considered a father who gifted stock to his son and then had his remaining shares redeemed, with the son continuing to run the business. The ruling found no tax-avoidance purpose because the father was genuinely exiting rather than engineering a capital-gains withdrawal while keeping indirect control through a family member. The question turns on whether the combined effect of the transfer and redemption was designed to let you cash out at capital-gains rates while retaining economic influence through relatives.
The burden sits on the taxpayer. If the IRS finds a tax-avoidance purpose behind an intra-family transfer inside the 10-year window, the waiver fails and the redemption proceeds are reclassified as a Section 301 distribution.
The 10-Year Forward Restriction on Post-Redemption Interests
This is where most waivers break. Section 302(c)(2)(A) requires that immediately after the redemption, and for the next 10 years, you hold no interest in the corporation other than as a creditor. The statute lists officer, director, and employee as examples of prohibited interests, but that list is illustrative, not exhaustive.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 302 – Distributions in Redemption of Stock
In Lynch v. Commissioner, the Ninth Circuit held that providing post-redemption services as an independent contractor is also a prohibited interest. The court rejected any case-by-case analysis of whether the contractor kept meaningful control or a financial stake, calling that approach “inconsistent with Congress’ desire to bring a measure of certainty to the tax consequences of a corporate redemption.”3Justia. William M. Lynch and Mima W. Lynch v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue Consulting agreements, management contracts, and advisory roles all fall on the wrong side of the line. So does going back on the payroll in any capacity.
There is one exception. Stock acquired by bequest or inheritance during the 10 years does not violate the waiver. Buying shares, receiving them as a gift, or acquiring them through any other route triggers an immediate breach and starts the 30-day clock for notifying the IRS.
The Creditor Exception and Its Limits
Redemptions in closely held corporations are often financed with installment notes rather than a lump sum. Staying on as a creditor is allowed, but the debt has to look and function like real debt rather than a disguised equity stake.
Treasury Regulation Section 1.302-4(d) provides that the debt cannot be contingent on the corporation’s earnings, and the IRS has scrutinized whether the obligation is subordinated to general creditors, since subordination begins to resemble the risk profile of a stockholder.4eCFR. 26 CFR 1.302-4 – Termination of Shareholder’s Interest In Hurst v. Commissioner (124 T.C. No. 2), the Tax Court found that installment notes with cross-default and cross-collateralization provisions still qualified as true debt. The Hursts had received essentially no down payment, and the court treated the security provisions as reasonable creditor protections rather than proprietary interests. Payments did not depend on the corporation’s financial performance, which was the point that mattered.
The practical version: fixed payment schedule, no earn-out or profit participation, no subordination to other creditors. Using the redeemed stock as collateral is acceptable under Hurst. Adding voting rights or board observation rights alongside the note is not.
Extra Requirements When the Shareholder Is an Entity
When the shareholder being redeemed is a partnership, estate, trust, or corporation, Section 302(c)(2)(C) piles on additional conditions. Both the entity and every “related person” whose stock ownership would be attributed to the entity must satisfy the waiver conditions individually. Each related person must also agree to be jointly and severally liable for any tax deficiency, including interest and additions to tax, resulting from a later prohibited acquisition by anyone in the attribution chain.
The coordination burden is real. A trust being redeemed needs every beneficiary whose ownership would be attributed to the trust to accept the 10-year restrictions, file their own representations, and take on joint liability. One beneficiary who takes a part-time job at the company five years later can invalidate the waiver for everyone in the chain. Written agreements among the participants, spelling out the restrictions and the financial consequences of a breach, are usually necessary.
Filing the Written Agreement Statement
Treasury Regulation Section 1.302-4 prescribes what the agreement statement must contain and when to file it. The statement must identify the distributee by name and taxpayer identification number and the distributing corporation by name and employer identification number.4eCFR. 26 CFR 1.302-4 – Termination of Shareholder’s Interest You include it with the first tax return filed for the year of the redemption.
Two representations have to appear in the statement:
- That you have not acquired any interest in the corporation, other than by bequest or inheritance, since the distribution date.
- That you will notify the IRS within 30 days of any prohibited acquisition occurring within the 10 years following the distribution.
The statement should also confirm that no interest other than as a creditor remains and identify the shares that were redeemed. Electronic filers typically attach it as a PDF; paper filers attach it to Form 1040 for individuals or Form 1120 for corporations.
If the statement is left off the original return, you can request an extension under the IRS’s reasonable-cause framework. The IRS evaluates these requests case by case, and valid grounds generally involve circumstances beyond the taxpayer’s control: serious illness, natural disaster, inability to obtain records, or a filing-system issue that blocked timely submission.5Internal Revenue Service. Penalty Relief for Reasonable Cause Not knowing about the requirement, or relying on a preparer who missed it, does not qualify. Expect the IRS to want documentation supporting the reason claimed.
What Happens If the Waiver Is Violated
Acquiring a prohibited interest during the 10-year window retroactively revokes the waiver. The redemption gets reclassified as a Section 301 distribution rather than an exchange, and the tax treatment of the entire amount you received years earlier changes with it.
Section 301 taxes the distribution in three layers. The portion covered by the corporation’s earnings and profits is a dividend, taxed as ordinary income. Any remaining amount reduces your stock basis. Anything left after basis is exhausted is capital gain.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 301 – Distributions of Property For a corporation with substantial accumulated earnings, most or all of the proceeds can end up recharacterized as dividend income, wiping out the basis offset that exchange treatment would have given you.
The assessment period is the other trap. Section 302(c)(2)(A) gives the IRS at least one additional year from the date you notify it of a prohibited acquisition to assess the resulting deficiency, regardless of whether the ordinary three-year assessment period has already expired. The statute makes clear this extended assessment applies “notwithstanding any provision of law or rule of law which otherwise would prevent such assessment and collection.” Skipping the notification does not solve the problem; it simply layers potential penalties on top of the reclassification.