Section 281 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 makes certain asset transfers void against the tax department when the seller has tax proceedings pending or an unpaid tax demand. It does not stop the sale between the buyer and seller, but it lets the department pursue the transferred asset for recovery as though the sale never happened, unless the buyer paid fair value without notice of the tax trouble or the seller obtained the Assessing Officer’s prior permission.1Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281
When the Restriction Is in Force
The window opens the moment any proceeding under the Income Tax Act is pending against the assessee. Assessment, reassessment, appeals, and proceedings for income that escaped assessment all count. The window does not close when the proceeding ends. It stays open until the Tax Recovery Officer serves a notice under Rule 2 of the Second Schedule demanding payment of the certified amount.1Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281
In practice, that means a seller with a completed assessment and an unpaid demand is still inside the restricted period. So is a seller with an ongoing scrutiny, and often a seller whose case is on appeal. The restriction operates automatically once the window is open, no matter what the seller intended.
What Transfers and Assets Are Covered
The definition of transfer is deliberately wide. Sales, mortgages, gifts, exchanges, and the creation of a charge (such as pledging an asset as security) all fall within scope, along with a catch-all phrase covering “any other mode of transfer whatsoever.”1Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281 Creative structuring will not sidestep it.
The covered asset categories are specific: land, buildings, machinery, plant, shares, securities, and fixed deposits with banks.1Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281 That list reaches beyond personal wealth into the operating assets of a business.
One important carve-out: assets held as stock-in-trade of the taxpayer’s business fall outside the definition.2Indian Kanoon. Income Tax Act, 1961 – Section 281 A developer selling flats from inventory or a trader selling shares held as trading stock can continue ordinary business dealings without triggering the provision. The same building would be restricted if held as an investment and free to sell if it sat in the developer’s stock. The difference in character matters.
The Two Value Thresholds
Both thresholds have to be crossed. The tax or other sum payable (or likely to become payable) by the seller must exceed ₹5,000, and the assets being transferred must exceed ₹10,000 in value.1Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281 These floors are low. Any meaningful property sale, share transfer, or fixed deposit closure will clear both.
What “Void” Actually Means Here
A transfer that falls inside the window and does not qualify for an exception is void as against the department’s claim for tax or other sums payable.1Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281 The department does not have to show that the seller intended to defraud revenue. If the conditions are met, the transaction fails as against the department automatically.
Void against the department is narrower than void altogether. Indian courts have held that the transfer stays valid between the parties and against the rest of the world. The buyer keeps ownership for every purpose except the department’s recovery claim. That single exception is the problem, because it lets the department chase the transferred asset as if the sale never occurred.
The department cannot declare the transfer void on its own. It must obtain a declaration from a competent civil court confirming that all conditions of Section 281 are satisfied before proceeding against the asset. The judicial check is real, but for a buyer, being dragged into that litigation is itself the harm.
The Two Exceptions That Save a Transfer
Only one of the two exceptions needs to apply for the transaction to survive.
Adequate Consideration and No Notice
A transfer is protected where the buyer paid adequate consideration (fair market value) and had no notice of the pending proceeding or the tax liability.1Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281 Both limbs must hold. A buyer who paid full price but knew of the seller’s tax proceedings fails the test. So does a buyer who was unaware but received the asset as a gift.
Notice is judged from the buyer’s side. The seller is presumed to know their own proceedings; the question is what the buyer knew. Courts have looked for formal notice served on or brought to the attention of the buyer. Documentation of pre-purchase due diligence, such as record searches and written representations from the seller about tax status, is what makes this exception usable if it is ever challenged.
Prior Permission of the Assessing Officer
A transfer made with the previous permission of the Assessing Officer is fully protected, regardless of the price paid or what the buyer knew.2Indian Kanoon. Income Tax Act, 1961 – Section 281 Permission has to be obtained before the transfer, not afterwards. For a seller who knows proceedings are open, this is the cleaner route.
How to Get the Assessing Officer’s Permission
CBDT Circular No. 4/2011 sets out a standardized process. The seller files a prescribed application with the jurisdictional Assessing Officer at least thirty days before the proposed transaction, giving details of the property, the proposed transfer, and any outstanding tax liabilities.
What the Assessing Officer does next depends on the seller’s demand status:
- Where there is no outstanding demand and none is expected within six months, permission should be granted within ten working days of the application.
- Where an undisputed demand is outstanding, the seller has to pay it with interest, and permission should follow within ten working days of payment.
- Where a disputed demand is outstanding, the seller must obtain a stay and indemnify the department, typically through a bank guarantee, other sufficient assets, or by allowing the department to retain first charge on the asset being transferred. Permission follows within ten working days of the indemnification.
- Where a demand is likely to arise within six months, the officer first considers whether provisional attachment under Section 281B is warranted for the seller’s other assets. If those remaining assets provide adequate security, permission should be granted within fifteen working days.
For transfers of assets worth ₹10 crore or more, the Assessing Officer needs approval from the Range Head before granting permission. Refusals must be issued through a reasoned written order and also require Range Head approval. Complete applications generally resolve within two to three weeks.
Section 281B: A Different, Sharper Tool
Section 281B is a separate provision that readers often confuse with Section 281. Where the Assessing Officer believes it is necessary to protect revenue during pending assessment or reassessment, the officer can provisionally attach the taxpayer’s property with prior approval from the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner.3Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281B An attachment under 281B actively freezes the asset. The taxpayer cannot deal with it at all until the attachment is lifted, which is very different from Section 281’s passive rule that only bites if a transfer happens.
A provisional attachment lasts six months. The Principal Commissioner or Commissioner can extend it, but the total cannot exceed two years or sixty days after the assessment or reassessment order is passed, whichever is later.3Income Tax Department. Income-tax Act, 1961 – Section 281B If the department misses that limit, the property is released.
What a Buyer Should Check Before Closing
The financial risk under Section 281 lands hardest on the buyer. A seller under proceedings may not disclose them. If the department later has the transfer declared void, the buyer stands to lose the asset to recovery while pursuing the seller separately for a refund of the purchase price.
The cleanest protection is a copy of the Assessing Officer’s permission, produced by the seller before the sale completes. Where the seller says no proceedings are pending, a written representation and independent verification from public records are the minimum. The adequate-consideration-and-no-notice exception is a fallback if something surfaces later; it is not a substitute for checking first. For land, buildings, and business assets, that due diligence costs very little against the size of the exposure.