Section 269A Income Reallocation: Tests, Safe Harbor, Penalties

Under Internal Revenue Code Section 269A, income reallocation happens when the IRS pulls earnings out of a personal service corporation and assigns them directly to the professional who performed the work, taxing that income at individual rates instead of the 21 percent corporate rate. The agency can do this when two conditions line up: the corporation performs substantially all of its services for a single other entity, and the principal purpose of using the corporate structure is to avoid or evade federal income tax.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 269A – Personal Service Corporations Formed or Availed of to Avoid or Evade Income Tax When both are met, the IRS can shift income, deductions, credits, and other tax benefits between the corporation and its employee-owners to reflect what the tax picture would look like without the corporate middleman.

Which Corporations Section 269A Reaches

Section 269A(b)(1) defines a personal service corporation as one whose main activity is performing personal services, with those services carried out primarily by employee-owners rather than a broader workforce.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 269A – Personal Service Corporations Formed or Availed of to Avoid or Evade Income Tax The statute does not list specific fields. Lists you may have seen naming health, law, engineering, accounting, and the like come from Section 448(d)(2), a separate provision covering accounting-method and tax-year issues.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 448 – Limitation on Use of Cash Method of Accounting Section 269A is broader. Any corporation whose value comes mainly from the personal efforts of its owners could fall within its reach.

An employee-owner under 269A is anyone who owns more than 10 percent of the corporation’s outstanding stock on any day during the tax year. Family ownership doesn’t provide a workaround. Section 269A incorporates the attribution rules of Section 318, so stock held by a spouse, children, grandchildren, or parents counts toward your 10 percent. The statute also modifies one of those attribution rules, substituting a 5 percent threshold for the usual 50 percent standard when tracing ownership through related entities.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 269A – Personal Service Corporations Formed or Availed of to Avoid or Evade Income Tax Indirect ownership is cast with a wider net here than in many other parts of the tax code.

The Single-Client Condition

The first condition is that the corporation performs substantially all of its services for or on behalf of one other entity. That entity can be another corporation, a partnership, or a sole proprietorship.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 269A – Personal Service Corporations Formed or Availed of to Avoid or Evade Income Tax The statute does not define “substantially all.” Regulations under Section 448 use a 95 percent standard for their own purposes, and some practitioners apply a similar figure when analyzing 269A, but that number is borrowed rather than built into the statute.

In practice, a corporation deriving essentially all of its revenue from a single client is clearly within 269A’s scope. A corporation splitting work among four or five unrelated clients likely is not. The classic case is a physician who incorporates but continues to work exclusively at one hospital, or a consultant whose corporation invoices only one company year after year. From the IRS’s perspective, these arrangements resemble employment dressed up as a contractor relationship. The corporation has no independent client base, no market exposure, and no real economic function other than sitting between the professional and the paying entity.

The Principal Purpose Test

Meeting the single-client test alone does not trigger reallocation. The IRS must also establish that the corporation was formed or used with the principal purpose of avoiding or evading federal income tax. The statute specifically targets arrangements where the corporate structure reduces the employee-owner’s income or secures deductions, credits, exclusions, or other benefits the individual could not claim on a personal return.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 269A – Personal Service Corporations Formed or Availed of to Avoid or Evade Income Tax

The IRS does not need a confession of intent. It looks at objective financial outcomes. If the corporation pays the owner a salary well below the fair market value of their services, retains the remaining profit at 21 percent, and funds generous corporate benefits along the way, the pattern speaks for itself. The government compares the combined tax liability of the corporation and the owner against what the owner would have owed as a regular employee. When the gap is large and the corporate structure provides no meaningful benefit other than tax savings, the test is usually satisfied.

For 2026, the top individual rate remains 37 percent for single filers with taxable income above $640,600 and married couples filing jointly above $768,700.3Internal Revenue Service. IRS Releases Tax Inflation Adjustments for Tax Year 2026 A professional earning $400,000 who pays themselves a $120,000 salary and leaves the rest in the corporation is shielding roughly $280,000 from individual rates that could reach 32 to 35 percent, instead subjecting that income to the flat 21 percent corporate rate. That kind of spread is exactly what 269A was designed to address.

The Safe Harbor and Business-Purpose Defense

Proposed regulations under Section 269A contain a safe harbor that can block reallocation even when both conditions are technically met. Under Proposed Regulation Section 1.269A-1(c), a personal service corporation is not treated as formed or used for the principal purpose of tax avoidance if the employee-owner’s federal income tax liability is not reduced by more than the lesser of $2,500 or 10 percent of what the owner would have owed performing the services individually. If your tax savings fall within that band, the IRS is not supposed to pursue reallocation.

The safe harbor is most useful for modest-income professionals whose corporate structure produces only small tax advantages. For high earners, savings almost always exceed both the $2,500 and 10 percent thresholds, and the safe harbor is irrelevant. One further caveat: these regulations were never finalized, so the safe harbor is a defensible position rather than an absolute rule.

Courts have also recognized legitimate business purposes as a defense. In Sargent v. Commissioner, 929 F.2d 1252 (8th Cir. 1991), the Eighth Circuit declined to apply Section 269A where the corporation had been established for genuine business reasons beyond tax reduction. If you can show the corporation provides real liability protection, facilitates retirement plan contributions at levels not otherwise available, or serves other non-tax functions, that evidence helps rebut the principal purpose finding.

What a Reallocation Actually Does

When both conditions are met, the IRS has authority to allocate all income, deductions, credits, exclusions, and other allowances between the corporation and its employee-owners.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 269A – Personal Service Corporations Formed or Availed of to Avoid or Evade Income Tax The statute permits this when the allocation is necessary to prevent tax avoidance or to clearly reflect the income of the corporation or any of its employee-owners. In plain terms, the IRS looks through the corporate wrapper and treats the earnings as if they had been paid directly to the individual.

Consider a corporation that earned $300,000 but paid the owner only $100,000 in salary. Under a 269A reallocation, the IRS could reassign the remaining $200,000 to the owner’s personal return. That income then faces individual rates rather than the 21 percent corporate rate. Deductions the corporation claimed for benefits like health coverage, life insurance, or vehicle expenses may be disallowed at the corporate level or shifted to the owner’s return, where they face stricter limitations or phase-outs. Cash flow doesn’t change; the tax return the amounts appear on does.

After reallocation, the owner owes the additional tax plus interest running from the original filing deadline. The IRS compounds underpayment interest daily at the federal short-term rate plus three percentage points. For the first quarter of 2026 that rate is 7 percent; for the second quarter, it drops to 6 percent.4Internal Revenue Service. Quarterly Interest Rates On a six-figure reallocation, interest alone can add tens of thousands of dollars by the time the audit concludes.

Accuracy-Related Penalties on Top

A 269A reallocation can also trigger accuracy-related penalties under Section 6662. The standard penalty is 20 percent of the underpayment. For an individual, the penalty applies when the understatement exceeds the greater of 10 percent of the tax that should have been shown on the return or $5,000. For C corporations other than S corporations and personal holding companies, the threshold is the lesser of 10 percent of the correct tax (or $10,000 if greater) or $10,000,000.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 6662 – Imposition of Accuracy-Related Penalty on Underpayments

In a typical case where six figures of income are shifted from a corporate return to an individual one, clearing the $5,000 understatement threshold is nearly inevitable. A $200,000 reallocation taxed at an additional 16 percentage points (the gap between a 37 percent individual rate and 21 percent corporate) produces roughly $32,000 in additional tax. A 20 percent penalty on that amount adds another $6,400. Combined with interest, the total cost can exceed the original tax savings by a wide margin.

Section 482: A Parallel Risk

Section 269A is not the IRS’s only tool. Section 482 gives the agency a broader and in some ways easier path to the same result. Where two or more entities are controlled by the same interests, Section 482 lets the IRS allocate income among them to clearly reflect each entity’s income or to prevent tax evasion. The important difference is that Section 482 does not require proof of a principal purpose of tax avoidance. The agency only needs to show that the allocation would more clearly reflect income.

Where a professional owns a corporation that provides services to a related entity without arm’s-length pricing, Section 482 allows the IRS to adjust both entities’ income to reflect what unrelated parties would have charged. The agency can invoke both sections in the same examination, using 269A for the structural argument and 482 for the pricing argument. Defeating one does not necessarily end the inquiry.

How to Reduce Your Exposure

The most direct way to avoid a 269A reallocation is to break one of the two required conditions. Diversifying the corporation’s client base so that services are not concentrated with a single entity removes the first prong entirely. Even a meaningful minority of revenue from other clients complicates the IRS’s argument that “substantially all” services go to one entity.

If client concentration is unavoidable due to the nature of your practice, focus on defeating the principal purpose test. Pay yourself a salary that reflects the fair market value of your services. When compensation tracks what a similarly qualified professional would earn as an employee of the client organization, the IRS has a harder time arguing that the corporate structure exists primarily to reduce taxes. Document the non-tax reasons for incorporating: liability protection, retirement plan flexibility, the ability to bring on associates, or operational independence from the client entity.

Electing S corporation status is another option worth evaluating. Because S corporation income passes through to the owner’s individual return, there is no corporate-level tax shelter for the IRS to attack. The reasonable-compensation issue still applies, but the 269A reallocation mechanism loses its purpose when income is already taxed at individual rates. The trade-off is that S corporations cannot offer certain fringe benefits on a tax-free basis and face restrictions on the number and type of shareholders.

If you already operate a personal service corporation with a single major client, check whether your combined tax savings fall within the safe harbor: no more than the lesser of $2,500 or 10 percent of the tax you would have owed performing the work individually. Staying inside that band is not immunity, since the safe harbor sits in proposed regulations that have never been finalized, but it gives you a defensible position if the IRS raises the issue.