Robert Starnes: Investment Fraud, FINRA Bar, and Federal Sentence

Robert C. Starnes, a former Wauwatosa, Wisconsin financial advisor, was sentenced on November 5, 2025, to 40 months in federal prison for an investment fraud scheme that cost more than a dozen clients over $3 million. U.S. District Judge Lynn Adelman also ordered three years of supervised release and $3,093,304.17 in restitution.1U.S. Department of Justice. Financial Advisor Sentenced in Investment Fraud Scheme Starnes, 66, had pleaded guilty to wire fraud after taking retirement savings from friends, family members, and acquaintances and spending it on himself instead of investing it.

What Starnes Did

Starnes operated as Robert C. Starnes Financial Services from an office in Wauwatosa and had been registered in the securities industry since 1986.2FINRA BrokerCheck. Robert Charles Starnes Individual Summary He pitched people he knew personally, telling them his strategies would grow their retirement portfolios.1U.S. Department of Justice. Financial Advisor Sentenced in Investment Fraud Scheme

None of the money was ever invested. Starnes deposited client checks straight into his personal accounts at Wells Fargo and BMO Harris Bank and used the funds for credit card bills, mortgage payments (including one for $25,000), and other personal expenses. To keep clients from noticing, he sent them fabricated account statements, often carrying the names and logos of well-known firms such as DWS Investments and Barclays, showing balances and returns that did not exist.3Wealthmanagement.com. Wisconsin Advisor Sentenced to 40 Months for $3M Investor Fraud

When a client asked to withdraw funds, Starnes wrote them a check or transferred money from his own account, which made the fictional investments look real. The scheme ran from roughly 2008 to 2023.3Wealthmanagement.com. Wisconsin Advisor Sentenced to 40 Months for $3M Investor Fraud

How It Came Apart

In May 2023, heirs of a deceased client contacted Quest Capital Strategies, a broker-dealer where Starnes had previously been registered, saying he had taken funds from their family member into his personal account and had agreed, but failed, to repay $153,689. That same month, SA Stone Wealth Management, Starnes’s then-current broker-dealer, fired him for violating firm policy on accepting client funds and reported the discharge to FINRA on May 16, 2023. In August, another client reported she had written $35,000 in checks payable directly to Starnes and found no record of her money at the firms listed on her statements.4FINRA BrokerCheck. Robert Charles Starnes BrokerCheck Report

FINRA Bar and Wisconsin Order

FINRA opened an investigation and asked Starnes to appear for on-the-record testimony. He said he would not appear.4FINRA BrokerCheck. Robert Charles Starnes BrokerCheck Report On July 27, 2023, he signed an Acceptance, Waiver, and Consent agreeing to a permanent bar from associating with any FINRA member firm in any capacity, without admitting or denying the findings.5Financial Advisor Magazine. Barred Wisconsin Broker Indicted for Wire Fraud

In 2024, the Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions, Division of Securities, issued a Summary Order to Cease and Desist barring Starnes from future registration as a registered representative or investment advisor representative in the state, revoking his registration exemptions, and prohibiting him from offering or selling securities in or from Wisconsin. The order rested on the FINRA bar, which under Wisconsin law lets the state administrator discipline a person expelled by a self-regulatory organization.6Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions. Summary Order to Cease and Desist, Case No. S-248141

Federal Charges, Guilty Plea, and Sentence

In January 2024, a federal grand jury in the Eastern District of Wisconsin indicted Starnes on two counts of wire fraud.7U.S. Department of Justice. Financial Advisor Indicted for Wire Fraud He pleaded guilty. In an October 2025 letter to the court he wrote: “There’s really no excuse for what I did, and I am not going to try to defend myself. What I did was wrong, and I know it’s wrong… Instead of investing the money entrusted to me, I took my friends’ and clients’ hard-earned money and used it like it was my own.”8Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. Robert C. Starnes of Wauwatosa Sentenced for Investment Fraud Scheme

At sentencing, Judge Adelman said Starnes “had not invested any funds on behalf of his victims” and that those he defrauded were “not wealthy, but ordinary, hard-working families.”9Wisconsin Law Journal. Wauwatosa Advisor Gets 40 Months for $3M Investment Fraud The 40-month prison term was accompanied by three years of supervised release and the full $3,093,304.17 restitution order.1U.S. Department of Justice. Financial Advisor Sentenced in Investment Fraud Scheme

Civil Recovery for Victims

Restitution from the criminal case is one path to recovery; victims have also pursued another. In November 2024, a FINRA arbitration complaint was filed alleging that Quest Capital Strategies and StoneX Securities are vicariously liable for the losses Starnes caused. The claimants are seeking $3 million. The FINRA regulatory action against Starnes himself did not include a finding that any affiliated firm committed a willful violation or failed to supervise him, but that does not stop victims from asserting supervisory liability claims in arbitration.4FINRA BrokerCheck. Robert Charles Starnes BrokerCheck Report