Rewards Card Merchant Settlement: Surcharges, Rewards, and Pushback

The rewards card merchant settlement is a court-approved agreement between Visa, Mastercard, and roughly 12 million U.S. merchants that, for the first time, lets stores refuse premium rewards credit cards or add a surcharge when customers use them. U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan granted preliminary approval in June 2026, calling the deal “fair, reasonable, and adequate.”1 For cardholders, the practical upshot is simple: the card in your wallet may cost more to use at the register, and the rewards it earns may shrink.

The deal is valued at about $38 billion in projected merchant savings and runs alongside an older $5.54 billion cash settlement that compensates merchants for past fees. A final approval hearing is expected in late 2026 or early 2027.

What Changes at the Checkout Counter

The settlement breaks apart a longstanding Visa and Mastercard rule called “honor all cards,” which required any merchant accepting one card on a network to accept every card on that network. Credit cards are now sorted into three categories:

  • Standard consumer credit cards (roughly 10% of consumer credit volume), such as Visa Traditional and Mastercard Core.
  • Premium consumer credit cards (roughly 85% of volume), including Visa Signature, Visa Infinite, and Mastercard World Elite.
  • Commercial credit cards for business use.

Merchants can decide which categories to accept. A coffee shop could take standard consumer cards and refuse premium rewards cards. Premium and commercial cards will carry visual identifiers so cashiers and payment terminals can tell them apart.

Merchants also gain expanded surcharging rights. They can add up to 3% to credit card transactions and apply the surcharge selectively — all Visa cards, say, or only premium cards — without being required to surcharge competing networks like American Express at the same time. Separate “anti-steering” rules that limited how merchants could push customers toward cheaper payment methods are also gone, so a store can openly offer a discount for paying with debit or cash.

How aggressively stores will use these tools is unsettled. Matthew Goldman of the consulting firm Totavi told U.S. News that most retail chains are unlikely to turn away premium cardholders, who tend to be higher spenders, though some “merchant outliers” might.1 Because roughly 85% of active U.S. credit cards carry rewards and only about 7% of cardholders hold no-rewards cards, a store that refuses premium cards is refusing most of its credit-paying customers. The more likely pattern is surcharges presented as “convenience fees” at smaller merchants and specific categories where margins are tight.

What It Could Do to Your Rewards

Interchange fees — the 1.5% to 3% that merchants’ banks pay to card-issuing banks on every swipe — are what fund credit card rewards. Premium rewards cards sit at the top of that range, typically between 2% and 3%, and that money pays for sign-up bonuses, category multipliers, and annual perks.

The settlement squeezes that revenue in two ways. Posted interchange rates for standard consumer credit cards are capped at 1.25% for eight years following court approval, down from current rates of roughly 1.5% to 1.7%. Separately, the combined average effective credit interchange rate must drop by 10 basis points, or 0.1 percentage point, for five years. The 1.25% cap does not apply to premium rewards cards or commercial cards; those remain uncapped, but merchants can now push back on them through surcharges and selective acceptance.

One industry analysis projected a 20% to 40% reduction in the interchange income that funds rewards. For cardholders, that could show up as smaller sign-up bonuses, reduced category multipliers (3x points dropping to 2x, for example), higher annual fees, or some mix of all three. None of this is automatic or immediate — issuers set their own program terms — but the revenue pressure runs in one direction.

Whether Surcharges Are Legal Where You Live

The settlement’s 3% surcharge ceiling runs into a patchwork of state laws, so what you see at checkout will depend on where you shop.

  • Connecticut and Massachusetts maintain longstanding prohibitions on credit card surcharges.
  • California’s SB 478, effective since July 2024, requires all mandatory fees to be included in advertised prices, which functionally prevents separate surcharges on most consumer transactions.
  • Puerto Rico bans surcharges outright.
  • Colorado and Oklahoma cap surcharges at the lesser of 2% or the merchant’s actual processing cost.
  • New Jersey permits surcharges only up to the seller’s actual processing cost, with mandatory disclosure.
  • Minnesota requires avoidable surcharges to be disclosed before checkout and caps them at 3% for Visa and 4% for Mastercard.

In restrictive states, some merchants use “dual pricing” instead, displaying a cash price and a higher card price. Card networks sometimes treat that as a surcharge subject to its own compliance rules.

What Merchants Get

For store owners, the settlement delivers two distinct things. The injunctive relief package — the category rules, the 1.25% cap on standard cards, the 10-basis-point systemwide reduction, and the surcharging rights — reshapes how fees work going forward. Separately, the $5.54 billion cash fund approved in 2019 compensates merchants who accepted Visa or Mastercard between January 1, 2004, and January 25, 2019.

The claims filing deadline for that cash fund passed on February 4, 2025. The court approved an initial partial distribution of approximately $426 million to about 605,000 merchant claimants in October 2025, with payments beginning in February 2026. Nearly $5 billion remains in the fund for future distributions once outstanding legal disputes are resolved.

The injunctive relief settlement is a Rule 23(b)(2) class action, which means merchants cannot opt out of its terms. That mandatory structure is one of the main things opponents are fighting.

Who Is Objecting and What Could Still Change

Preliminary approval is not final approval, and some of the country’s largest retailers want the deal reworked or rejected.

The Retail Industry Leaders Association, representing over 200 retailers, filed preliminary objections in December 2025, calling the relief “illusory” and arguing it locks in “inflated interchange rates for years to come.” RILA criticized the fact that a mandatory class covering nearly every U.S. merchant was represented in negotiations by “five tiny businesses,” including a hair salon, a pharmacy, and a dentist. Walmart filed separately, asking either to split the plaintiff class or to be allowed to opt out.

The Merchants Payments Coalition called the 10-basis-point reduction a “mirage,” noting it applies only to the card-issuing banks’ share and represents a fraction of the average 2.36% swipe fee charged in 2025. The coalition also warned that banks could reclassify standard cards as rewards cards to keep fees high, which could render the honor-all-cards changes “unworkable.” Doug Kantor of the MPC said the settlement won’t produce “meaningful change at the consumer level.”

Judge Cogan acknowledged in his preliminary approval ruling that “many objections had merit” but said the relevant question was not whether the settlement represented “the best possible recovery, end stop” but rather the best possible recovery “in light of what can be gained and lost through trial.”

Until the final approval hearing, nothing in the settlement is locked in. If you carry a premium rewards card, the sensible moves are to watch for surcharge disclosures at checkout, read any program-change notices your issuer sends, and check your state’s surcharge rules before assuming a fee at the register is permitted.

  • 1