The Red Rock Secured fraud was a years-long scheme in which an El Segundo, California precious metals dealer convinced hundreds of retirement savers to roll money out of 401(k)s, IRAs, and federal Thrift Savings Plan accounts to buy gold and silver coins carrying undisclosed markups as high as 130 percent. In 2023, the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission sued the company and its executives in parallel. In April 2024, a federal judge entered consent judgments ordering more than $76 million to the SEC and roughly $56 million more to the CFTC, including nearly $39 million in restitution for victims.1SEC. SEC Litigation Release No. 259962CFTC. CFTC Obtains Court Order Against Red Rock Secured
How the Scheme Worked
Red Rock Secured sold physical gold and silver, but its real business was retirement rollovers. Sales representatives contacted people with tax-deferred accounts and warned them, in the SEC’s words, using “fear and lies” that their existing securities were in serious danger and that precious metals would protect them.3SEC. SEC Charges Red Rock Secured and Executives Federal employees with Thrift Savings Plan balances were a particular target, along with 401(k) and traditional IRA holders.
Customers were told they would pay a modest 1 to 5 percent markup over cost for “common bullion.” Instead, the sales floor steered nearly everyone into one niche product: Canadian Red-Tailed Hawk silver coins. The actual markup on those coins ran from 100 to 130 percent.4CFTC. CFTC Charges Red Rock Secured With Precious Metals Fraud
The pitch for the Red-Tailed Hawk coins layered several lies. Staff described the coins as “monetized bullion” of “limited mintage” that carried value beyond their silver content. They claimed Red Rock had a “direct relationship” with the Royal Canadian Mint and that the mint set the prices. None of that was true. Red Rock bought all of its inventory from a single third-party wholesaler, Bayside Metal Exchange, and CEO Sean Kelly personally set the coin prices.5California DFPI. CFTC et al. v. Red Rock Secured LLC Complaint
Representatives added a privacy angle too, warning customers that standard bullion carried CUSIP tracking numbers visible to the government while the Red-Tailed Hawk coins were “non-CUSIP,” “private,” and “non-trackable.” Commissions were tuned to match: 8 percent on the premium coins against 1 percent on common bullion, with the top salesperson earning 10 percent.5California DFPI. CFTC et al. v. Red Rock Secured LLC Complaint
How Many People Were Hurt, and How Badly
The SEC and CFTC counted the harm over slightly different windows. The SEC alleged that from at least 2017 through 2022, at least 700 investors paid more than $50 million into the scheme, and the defendants kept more than $30 million of it.3SEC. SEC Charges Red Rock Secured and Executives The CFTC, looking at November 2019 through February 2022, identified about 959 customers who paid roughly $61.8 million for Red-Tailed Hawk coins, with Red Rock retaining about $34.4 million in markups.4CFTC. CFTC Charges Red Rock Secured With Precious Metals Fraud The CFTC later put the total paid at over $69 million for coins worth only about $30 million.2CFTC. CFTC Obtains Court Order Against Red Rock Secured
The losses showed up as soon as customers tried to check or sell. One person who complained to the Better Business Bureau said their holdings were represented as worth $390,569 but had an actual market value of $177,000. Another reported investing $10,000 and receiving $3,600 on liquidation. Many customers said they could no longer reach anyone at the company and that phone lines eventually went dead.6BBB. Red Rock Secured LLC BBB Complaints
Who Was Charged
The SEC charged four defendants: Red Rock Secured LLC itself; CEO Sean Kelly, also known as Shade Johnson-Kelly; and former senior account executives Anthony Spencer and Jeffrey Ward. The CFTC’s parallel action named Red Rock, Kelly, and Spencer, but not Ward.1SEC. SEC Litigation Release No. 259964CFTC. CFTC Charges Red Rock Secured With Precious Metals Fraud
Kelly, a Los Angeles resident, held an 80 percent stake in the company, controlled day-to-day operations, supervised employees, was one of two bank account signatories, and personally set the markups. Neither Kelly nor Red Rock had ever been registered with the CFTC, the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, or Hawaii securities regulators.5California DFPI. CFTC et al. v. Red Rock Secured LLC Complaint Spencer was the top sales producer and later director of account services. Ward was also a senior account executive. Both were alleged to have directly misled customers about markups and about what the coins actually were.
The CFTC filed jointly with the California DFPI and the Hawaii Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs, which added state commodities and securities fraud claims, including unlicensed investment advice.7California DFPI. DFPI Charges Southern California-Based Precious Metals Dealer8Hawaii Governor. Hawaii Joins Suit to Charge Precious Metals Dealer
What the Court Ordered
On April 23, 2024, Judge R. Gary Klausner of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California entered consent judgments in both cases. The defendants agreed to the judgments without admitting or denying the allegations.
The SEC Judgment
The SEC side totaled more than $76.4 million in disgorgement, prejudgment interest, and civil penalties:1SEC. SEC Litigation Release No. 25996
- Red Rock Secured LLC: $50,150,000 in disgorgement, $6,110,000 in prejudgment interest, and $10,000,000 in civil penalties.
- Sean Kelly: $1,841,727.89 in disgorgement, $224,241.37 in interest, and $1,500,000 in penalties. Kelly was also permanently barred from serving as an officer or director of a public company.
- Anthony Spencer: $2,156,905.15 in disgorgement, $262,616.15 in interest, and $580,478.70 in penalties.
- Jeffrey Ward: $1,224,215.28 in disgorgement, $149,055.46 in interest, and $200,464 in penalties.
All four defendants were permanently enjoined from further violations of the antifraud provisions of the Securities Exchange Act and the Investment Advisers Act. The judgment also included an offset: amounts paid to the CFTC by Red Rock, Kelly, and Spencer would reduce what they owed the SEC.1SEC. SEC Litigation Release No. 25996
The CFTC Order
The parallel CFTC order required Red Rock, Kelly, and Spencer to pay $38,984,313.90 in restitution to defrauded customers, $5.1 million in disgorgement, and $12.25 million in civil monetary penalties. It also imposed permanent trading and registration bans in CFTC-regulated markets and barred Kelly and Spencer from acting as investment advisers, broker-dealers, or commodity advisers in California and Hawaii.2CFTC. CFTC Obtains Court Order Against Red Rock Secured
Will Victims Get Their Money Back
Nearly $39 million of the CFTC order is designated as restitution for customers, but the agency itself cautioned that court orders requiring payment to victims “may not result in the recovery of any money lost because wrongdoers may not have sufficient funds or assets.”2CFTC. CFTC Obtains Court Order Against Red Rock Secured
Collection work has continued well after the judgment. Court records show that although the SEC case was formally terminated on April 23, 2024, filings have continued as recently as March 2026, with garnishee parties including Bank of America and Morgan Stanley Smith Barney and separate motions from outside parties such as DB Miami, Inc. and the Royal Canadian Mint.9CourtListener. SEC v. Red Rock Secured LLC Docket
What Happened to the Company
Before the judgment was entered, Red Rock Secured began operating under the name American Coin Co.1SEC. SEC Litigation Release No. 25996 As of 2026, the Red Rock Secured BBB page shows 14 complaints, 12 of them unanswered, and multiple consumers describe the business as defunct.6BBB. Red Rock Secured LLC BBB Complaints