A quality of earnings report is a financial due diligence analysis, prepared by an outside CPA firm, that strips accounting noise out of a company’s historical results to show what the business actually earns on a repeatable basis. The output is a normalized figure called Adjusted EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization), and in a middle-market deal that number is what both sides use to price the transaction, size the debt, and set the closing balance sheet. Reports typically cost between $20,000 and $100,000, and the adjustments inside them routinely move the purchase price by hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars.
How a QoE Report Differs From an Audit
An audit and a QoE look similar from a distance and answer completely different questions. An audit tests whether the financial statements comply with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles: are the numbers tied to supporting records, applied consistently, and free of material misstatement? The result is a pass/fail opinion on GAAP compliance.
A QoE asks the buyer’s question instead: if you owned this company starting tomorrow, what would it actually earn? GAAP-compliant numbers can still mislead a buyer. A company might legally book revenue from a one-time government contract, run the owner’s car payments through the business, or lease its headquarters from the owner at double the market rate. Each of those choices can survive an audit and still make the business look more profitable than a new owner will find it. The QoE identifies items like these, quantifies them, and produces an earnings figure that reflects standard ownership and arm’s-length operations.
The lens is also finer. Audits focus on annual periods and net income. QoE analysts work through monthly data across two to three years, looking for trends, seasonality, and performance patterns that annual snapshots hide. That granularity is what makes the report the most consequential financial document in most deals.
What Gets Adjusted to Reach Adjusted EBITDA
The core of any QoE is the schedule of normalizing adjustments. Each line item either adds back an expense the new owner won’t incur or removes income that won’t recur. The sum is Adjusted EBITDA: what the business should earn under normal, arm’s-length conditions.
Non-Recurring and Extraordinary Items
The first pass catches one-time events. A large legal settlement, a gain from selling unused equipment, a restructuring charge, or damage from a natural disaster all fall here. If the company spent $400,000 settling a lawsuit two years ago, that expense gets added back. If it booked a $250,000 gain from selling a warehouse, that gain comes out.
The judgment calls matter. Analysts have to decide whether an item is truly one-time or just infrequent. A company that settles a lawsuit every three years has a pattern, not an anomaly, and experienced QoE providers push back when sellers try to classify recurring costs as non-recurring to inflate the number.
Non-Operational Items
This category removes income and expenses tied to activities outside the core business: investment income, rental income from a side property, foreign currency gains, interest on excess cash. The buyer is purchasing the operating business, not the owner’s investment portfolio or a real estate side venture.
Owner and Related-Party Adjustments
In private company deals, this is where most of the movement happens. Owners routinely run personal expenses through the company or transact with related parties in ways that distort profitability. Typical adjustments include:
- Above-market owner compensation. An owner paying herself $800,000 when a replacement executive would cost $300,000 produces a $500,000 add-back.
- Personal expenses run through the business: vehicle leases, club memberships, family travel.
- Related-party rent, where the business leases its facility from an entity the owner controls at above-market rates. The adjustment reflects fair market rent.
- Family members on payroll who perform little or no work for the company.
These adjustments usually raise Adjusted EBITDA because they strip out costs the new owner won’t carry. For many privately held businesses, owner-related items are the single largest bridge between reported and adjusted earnings.
Revenue Quality and Sustainability
Adjusting expenses is only half the picture. A QoE also tests whether the revenue behind those earnings is real, properly timed, and likely to continue. Revenue problems tend to be harder to fix than expense problems, and this is where deals often get repriced or die.
Revenue Recognition
Under GAAP, revenue recognition follows Accounting Standards Codification Topic 606, which requires companies to recognize revenue when they transfer control of goods or services to the customer. QoE analysts look for practices that pull revenue into earlier periods. A classic example is a “bill-and-hold” arrangement where the company invoices the customer but hasn’t shipped the product. If the recognition criteria weren’t met, the QoE moves that revenue into the correct future period and lowers normalized historical earnings.
Other red flags: channel stuffing at period end to hit sales targets, recognizing long-term contract revenue upfront rather than as services are delivered, and recognition policies that shift between periods. Each one can mean the buyer is inheriting a future revenue hole already booked as past income.
Customer Concentration
Revenue sustainability also depends on where the money comes from. A business drawing a large share of revenue from one customer carries meaningful risk: if that customer leaves, a disproportionate chunk of earnings goes with them. Most QoE reports flag any customer at 15% to 20% or more of total revenue as a concentration risk. The report quantifies the exposure and typically recommends the buyer factor it into the valuation multiple. A business with three customers producing 60% of revenue will almost always command a lower multiple than one with a diversified base, even at identical Adjusted EBITDA.
Deferred Revenue in Subscription Businesses
For SaaS and other subscription businesses, deferred revenue gets special attention. It represents cash already collected for services not yet delivered. Following ASU 2021-08, acquirers measure contract liabilities using the same revenue recognition rules as if they had originated the contracts, which largely eliminated the old fair-value “haircut” that shrank post-close revenue. QoE analysts on subscription deals now spend more time on churn rates, renewal trends, and whether the deferred revenue balance is growing or shrinking, since those patterns predict future cash flow directly.
Reserves and Allowances
The report also tests whether reserves for sales returns, allowances, and bad debt are adequate. If the allowance for doubtful accounts has consistently been lower than actual write-offs, the report recommends increasing it so the income statement reflects what the company collects rather than what it hopes to collect.
Working Capital and the Closing Peg
Adjusted EBITDA sets the headline price. The working capital analysis sets what actually changes hands at closing, and it is where post-closing disputes most commonly erupt.
Net Working Capital is current operating assets (mainly accounts receivable and inventory) minus current operating liabilities (accounts payable and accrued expenses). The QoE evaluates whether the company has enough operational liquidity to sustain current revenue without the buyer injecting cash right after closing.
Inventory and Receivables Quality
Both categories get close scrutiny. For inventory, the analyst looks for obsolete, slow-moving, or damaged stock overvalued on the balance sheet. A distributor carrying $2 million in inventory might have $300,000 in products that haven’t moved in more than a year and would only liquidate at a steep discount. That write-down flows straight through to enterprise value.
For accounts receivable, the analysis ages every outstanding invoice and assesses collectibility. Receivables over 90 days old carry meaningfully higher default risk. If historical allowances haven’t kept pace with actual write-offs, the QoE adjusts receivables down to their realistic collectible value. No buyer wants to pay acquisition prices for invoices that will never turn into cash.
The Target Working Capital “Peg”
One of the most important outputs is the Target Working Capital, often called the “peg.” It represents the normalized level of NWC the business needs to run, typically an average over the trailing 12 to 24 months to smooth seasonal swings. The target goes into the purchase agreement.
After closing, actual NWC delivered gets compared to the target. If the seller delivered less than promised, the price drops dollar-for-dollar. If more, it rises. The mechanism exists because sellers have an incentive in the weeks before closing to strip cash out: collect receivables aggressively, delay vendor payments, run down inventory. The working capital true-up catches all of it. Because measuring working capital at a single point in time involves judgment, disputes frequently arise afterward, and most purchase agreements route disagreements to an independent accounting firm for binding determination.
Buy-Side and Sell-Side Reports
Most people associate QoE reports with buyers, but sellers commission them too, and the two versions serve different strategic purposes.
A buy-side QoE is the traditional engagement. The buyer hires an independent CPA firm after signing a letter of intent and entering exclusivity. The report’s job is to validate or challenge the seller’s earnings claims before the buyer commits. Buy-side reports tend to be skeptical by nature because the buyer’s advisors are looking for risks and overstatements.
A sell-side QoE is commissioned by the seller, usually two to three months before going to market. The goal is to find and address weaknesses before a buyer’s team does. If the analysis shows reported EBITDA drops 15% after adjustments, the seller has time to either fix the underlying issues or build a credible explanation into the offering materials. Sell-side reports give the seller control over the narrative, reduce the risk of late-stage price reductions (called “retrading”), often speed up the buyer’s own diligence, and can broaden the buyer pool because some institutional buyers won’t engage with a target that lacks third-party financial validation.
Neither version is inherently more trustworthy. Buyers should still run their own analysis when a sell-side report exists, because the seller’s firm was hired to present the business favorably within honest bounds. The two reports frequently disagree on specific adjustments, and those disagreements become negotiation points.
How the Adjustments Move the Purchase Price
QoE adjustments carry so much weight because of the multiplier effect. In most middle-market transactions, the purchase price equals Adjusted EBITDA multiplied by a negotiated valuation multiple, often between 4x and 8x depending on industry and growth profile. Every dollar of EBITDA adjustment gets amplified.
Take a business valued at 6x EBITDA. If the seller claims $5 million in EBITDA but the QoE reduces it to $4.5 million after adjustments, that $500,000 difference cuts $3 million from enterprise value. Adjustments of 10% to 25% in either direction are common in middle-market deals. That math is why a $40,000 QoE can be the highest-return investment a buyer makes in the entire transaction.
The adjustment schedule also becomes a negotiation document. Sellers rarely accept every buyer adjustment without pushback. Each contested line item gets debated, and the resolution moves the price. Experienced advisors treat the QoE as a pricing document dressed up as an accounting analysis.
Role in Debt Financing and R&W Insurance
The QoE doesn’t only shape price. It also determines how much debt the buyer can raise. Commercial lenders use the Adjusted EBITDA figure to calculate debt service coverage ratios and set the maximum loan amount. A lower Adjusted EBITDA means less financing, which can force the buyer to restructure the deal or walk away. On SBA-backed acquisition loans, lenders frequently commission their own quality-of-earnings analysis as part of underwriting even when the buyer already has a report.
The report also matters for representations and warranties (R&W) insurance, which has become standard in middle-market deals. R&W insurers evaluate the quality of the buyer’s diligence when pricing coverage. A thorough QoE satisfies one of the insurer’s primary requirements: evidence that the buyer did serious financial work. A sloppy or incomplete report can result in higher premiums, broader exclusions, or refusal to underwrite.
Cost, Timeline, and Choosing a Provider
For lower middle-market companies (generally under $25 million in revenue), a QoE report typically runs $20,000 to $60,000. Larger or more complex businesses above that threshold can expect $40,000 to over $100,000. The variation comes from company size, the state of the financial records, the number of entities involved, and how quickly the seller responds to information requests.
Most engagements take three to six weeks from kickoff to final report. That timeline compresses when the seller has clean books and responds quickly, and stretches when records are disorganized, accounting is done on a tax basis rather than GAAP, or multiple entities need to be untangled.
QoE work is done by CPA firms with transaction advisory practices. The skill set differs from audit or tax preparation, and the best providers focus exclusively on deal-related financial diligence. Regional and national firms with dedicated transaction advisory groups handle the bulk of middle-market work. Look for a provider with experience in the target’s industry; a firm that understands SaaS metrics will catch things a generalist misses on a software deal.
Independence matters. The firm preparing a buy-side QoE should have no existing relationship with the seller or the seller’s accounting firm, and the reverse holds for sell-side work. When lenders run their own analysis, they typically retain a separate firm entirely.
Red Flags That Reprice or Kill Deals
Certain findings reliably trigger repricing or blow deals up. Knowing what they look like helps both sides prepare.
- Customer concentration. Heavy dependence on one or two customers is the single most common valuation killer. When 20% or more of revenue comes from a single customer, buyers usually demand a lower multiple or build earnout protection into the structure.
- Declining margins or revenue. Shrinking gross margins or year-over-year revenue drops require explanation. If the decline is structural rather than temporary, the buyer will reprice.
- Messy financial records. Inconsistent accounting policies, unreconciled accounts, months-late closes, and commingled personal and business expenses create uncertainty, and buyers discount uncertainty heavily.
- Aggressive revenue recognition. Evidence that revenue was pulled forward from future periods raises questions about management integrity and signals a coming earnings shortfall.
- Undisclosed liabilities. Off-balance-sheet obligations, pending regulatory disputes, or unrecorded tax exposure erode trust and cause deal terms to deteriorate sharply.
- Working capital manipulation. Signs that the seller has been collecting receivables aggressively or delaying vendor payments to inflate closing cash suggest the buyer will need to inject capital soon after close.
A clean QoE doesn’t guarantee a closed deal, but a dirty one almost guarantees trouble. Sellers who get their financial house in order before going to market avoid the most painful surprises.
What a QoE Report Does Not Cover
A QoE is a financial analysis, not a full due diligence review. It doesn’t replace the other workstreams a buyer needs before closing. Legal due diligence covering pending litigation, regulatory compliance, and contract risk requires separate counsel. Environmental assessments identify contamination and remediation liabilities. Intellectual property reviews confirm ownership and enforceability of patents, trademarks, and trade secrets. Tax due diligence examines historical compliance and exposure from prior positions. Operational diligence evaluates management depth, technology infrastructure, and supply chain risk. The QoE’s value lies in its focused depth on one question: what does this business actually earn? Treating it as a substitute for the full diligence package leaves risks the report was never designed to address.