PSU vs RSU: Vesting, Taxes, and Clawback Risk

A restricted stock unit (RSU) vests when you’ve stayed employed long enough, and a performance stock unit (PSU) vests only if the company also hits pre-set financial or operational targets. That’s the core of PSU vs RSU: an RSU grant delivers a known number of shares as long as you stick around, while a PSU grant can deliver anywhere from zero to double the target count depending on results. Both are taxed as ordinary income when shares actually land in your account, and both follow the same capital gains rules from that point on. The trouble usually shows up in the withholding math, the cost basis on your 1099-B, and what happens if a merger interrupts the schedule.

What RSUs and PSUs Actually Are

An RSU is a contractual promise from your employer to deliver shares of company stock on a future date. Nothing is transferred at grant. No shares appear in your brokerage account, you get no voting rights, and you receive no dividends. It’s a right to future stock, conditional on staying employed through the vesting schedule.

A PSU works the same way mechanically, but adds a second condition. The company has to hit specific performance targets before shares are delivered. Those targets can include earnings-per-share growth, total shareholder return against competitors, revenue milestones, or operational metrics like inventory turnover.1U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. United Technologies Corporation Schedule of Terms for Performance Share Unit Awards

One thing worth clearing up before anything else: a Section 83(b) election is not available for either award. That election requires actual property to have been transferred subject to forfeiture. RSUs and PSUs are promises, not transferred property, so there’s nothing to elect on.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 83 – Property Transferred in Connection With Performance of Services

How the Vesting Schedules Differ

RSUs vest on time. The two common structures are cliff vesting, where nothing vests until a specific date and then everything vests at once, and graded vesting, where shares vest in installments over several years. A typical graded schedule releases 25% each year over four years. Leave before a vesting date and unvested RSUs are usually forfeited immediately.

PSUs are tied to a defined performance period, commonly three years long. At the end of the period, the company measures actual results against pre-set targets and applies a performance multiplier. That multiplier typically runs from 0% when performance falls below the minimum threshold to 200% when it exceeds the maximum target.1U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. United Technologies Corporation Schedule of Terms for Performance Share Unit Awards Most plans also require continuous employment through the performance period, so you carry both retention risk and performance risk at once.

The practical gap between the two shows up in the numbers. Hold 1,000 RSUs and stay employed through the schedule, and you receive 1,000 shares. Hold 1,000 target PSUs and you might end up with zero, or you might end up with 2,000. You won’t know the final count until the performance period closes and the compensation committee certifies results.

How Both Are Taxed When Shares Vest

Neither award creates a taxable event at grant. Tax hits when shares are actually delivered. Under Section 83 of the Internal Revenue Code, property received for services is included in gross income once it’s no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 83 – Property Transferred in Connection With Performance of Services For RSUs and PSUs, that moment is delivery.

The fair market value of the delivered shares is treated as ordinary income, exactly like salary. Your employer reports the amount on your W-2, and it’s subject to federal income tax, state income tax where applicable, Social Security, and Medicare.

The RSU math is simple: shares vested times the stock price on the delivery date. If 500 shares vest at $100, that’s $50,000 of ordinary income. The PSU math uses the same formula, but the share count reflects the performance multiplier. A 500-PSU target with a 150% multiplier delivers 750 shares. At $100 a share, that’s $75,000 of ordinary income.

Most employers use a sell-to-cover arrangement for withholding. The company automatically sells enough of your newly vested shares to cover federal, state, and payroll withholding, then deposits the remainder in your brokerage account. That’s why the shares you actually see are fewer than the vesting total.

The Withholding Shortfall for Higher Earners

Employers can withhold on supplemental wages, which include RSU and PSU income, at a flat 22% rate on amounts up to $1 million per year. Above $1 million the mandatory rate jumps to 37%.

For most people with meaningful equity compensation, 22% is not enough. A household in the 32% or 35% federal bracket is underwithheld on every vesting event. Someone earning $250,000 in salary whose RSUs vest another $150,000 pays a marginal federal rate of 32% or higher on much of that RSU income, while only 22% went to the IRS. State underwithholding often stacks on top. The result is a four- or five-figure balance due in April.

The IRS expects the gap to be covered through quarterly estimated payments if you’ll owe at least $1,000 after all withholding and credits. The safe harbor for avoiding an underpayment penalty is paying at least 90% of the current-year tax, or 110% of the prior-year tax if your adjusted gross income exceeded $150,000.3Internal Revenue Service. Large Gains, Lump Sum Distributions, Etc. A simpler fix is to raise your W-4 withholding in a year with a large vesting event, since regular paycheck withholding counts the same as estimated payments for penalty purposes.

Employees vesting more than $1 million in a year face the opposite problem. The 37% mandatory rate may exceed their effective rate, meaning they’ll get a refund. But the cash is tied up until filing.

Cost Basis and the 1099-B Problem

Once shares vest and the ordinary income tax is handled, you own stock with a defined cost basis. That basis equals the fair market value per share on the delivery date. Every future gain or loss is measured from there.

Sell within one year of the delivery date and any gain is a short-term capital gain, taxed at ordinary rates. Hold longer than a year and gains qualify for long-term capital gains rates. For 2026, those rates are 0% on taxable income up to $49,450 for single filers ($98,900 joint), 15% up to $545,500 ($613,700 joint), and 20% above.4Tax Foundation. 2026 Tax Brackets and Federal Income Tax Rates High earners may also owe an additional 3.8% net investment income tax on capital gains when modified adjusted gross income exceeds $200,000 single or $250,000 joint.5Internal Revenue Service. Topic No. 559, Net Investment Income Tax

Here’s where thousands of people get it wrong every year. Brokers are generally prohibited from reporting the full adjusted cost basis for equity compensation shares on Form 1099-B. You’ll often see a $0 basis, or a blank field, which makes it look like your entire sale proceeds are taxable gain. They aren’t. You already paid income tax on the vesting-date value through your W-2.

To avoid paying tax twice on the same money, report the correct adjusted cost basis on Form 8949. Your broker should provide a supplemental information form showing the adjusted basis. Use that figure, not the one on the 1099-B. Skip this step and the IRS will assess capital gains tax on the full sale proceeds, leaving you to amend the return or answer a notice. This is the single most common filing mistake with equity compensation.

Wash Sales With a Regular Vesting Schedule

Sell vested shares at a loss and have another batch of the same company’s stock vest within 30 days, and you’ve likely triggered a wash sale. The IRS treats vesting as an acquisition of shares, which puts it squarely inside the wash sale window: 30 days before and 30 days after the loss sale.6eCFR. 26 CFR 1.1091-1 – Losses From Wash Sales of Stock or Securities

When the rule applies, you can’t deduct the capital loss that year. The disallowed loss is added to the cost basis of the newly acquired shares. It’s deferred, not erased, but if you weren’t planning for it your tax bill for the year will be higher than expected.

This catches people who sell at a loss between quarterly vesting dates. If your RSUs vest every three months, there’s almost no window where you can realize a loss without the next vesting event tripping the rule. Map the vesting calendar before any tax-loss selling.

What Happens in a Merger or Acquisition

A corporate deal can rearrange your equity compensation in ways the vesting schedule didn’t anticipate. Treatment of unvested RSUs and PSUs depends on the grant agreement, the company’s equity plan, and the negotiated deal terms.

Common outcomes for unvested RSUs include accelerated vesting at closing, conversion to equivalent equity in the acquiring company, a cash buyout at a negotiated value, or cancellation. Which applies depends entirely on the documents.

PSUs bring additional complexity because the performance period may be incomplete when the deal closes. Buyer and seller have to agree on how to measure performance when the original metrics no longer apply. Common approaches include paying out at target-level performance, measuring actual performance through the closing date, or converting the remaining PSUs to time-vesting-only awards with the acquiring company. Some deals set a floor so employees receive at least the target payout regardless of actual results to date.

Many modern equity plans use double-trigger acceleration, which requires two events before vesting speeds up: the acquisition plus an involuntary termination or significant reduction in role within a specified window after closing. Single-trigger plans accelerate on the deal alone. Double-trigger is more common now because buyers don’t want the workforce cashing out on closing day.

If your company is being acquired, read the grant agreement and the equity plan document. The change-of-control provisions live there, and they vary significantly across companies and even across grant years at the same company. What happened to a colleague at a different employer is not a reliable guide.

Clawback Risk on PSUs

Executive officers at publicly traded companies carry a risk with PSUs that doesn’t apply to time-vested RSUs. Under SEC Rule 10D-1, companies listed on U.S. exchanges must maintain a written policy to recover incentive-based compensation that was erroneously awarded because of a financial restatement.7eCFR. 17 CFR 240.10D-1 – Listing Standards Relating to Recovery of Erroneously Awarded Compensation

The look-back covers the three completed fiscal years before the company is required to restate. The recoverable amount is the excess over what would have been paid under corrected numbers, calculated without regard to taxes the executive already paid on the original figure.8U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Recovery of Erroneously Awarded Compensation Fact Sheet The company cannot indemnify you against recovery.

PSUs tied to earnings-per-share or revenue targets sit at the center of this rule because those are the metrics most likely to change in a restatement. RSUs vesting purely on time generally fall outside the rule since their value isn’t linked to a financial reporting metric. The rule applies to executive officers at listed companies, not to rank-and-file employees receiving equity grants.