A Payment Protection Insurance settlement is still possible in 2026, but only through a few remaining routes: a claim to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme if the lender that sold the policy has gone out of business, a court claim within the limitation period, or a Plevin complaint about hidden commission. The main complaints deadline of 29 August 2019 closed the standard route against lenders still trading, with two narrow exceptions.1Financial Conduct Authority. PPI Complaints Where a claim does succeed, the settlement combines a refund of premiums with 8% statutory interest for every year the policy ran.
Who Can Still Claim in 2026
Claims Against Failed Firms Through the FSCS
The largest route still open is the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. The 2019 deadline does not apply to the FSCS because it only handles firms that have gone bust rather than those still trading. If the lender or broker that sold the policy is no longer in business and was regulated by the FCA or its predecessor the FSA, you can file a claim regardless of when the complaints deadline fell. The one restriction is that the advice must have been received on or after 14 January 2005.2Financial Services Compensation Scheme. You Can Still Claim PPI for Failed Firms After the Deadline
Court Claims
Taking a case to court remains legally possible because the FCA deadline covers only complaints handled through the firm’s internal process and the Financial Ombudsman Service.1Financial Conduct Authority. PPI Complaints The Limitation Act generally gives six years from when you became aware, or should have become aware, of the mis-selling. Court claims are slower and more expensive than the complaints route, and limitation arguments turn on specific facts, so legal advice is important before starting one.
The Plevin Commission Route
A separate basis for compensation comes from the 2014 Supreme Court decision in Plevin v Paragon Personal Finance Ltd. The court held that failing to disclose a high level of commission paid out of the PPI premium made the lending relationship unfair under Section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974.3UK Government. Consumer Credit Act 1974 – Section 140A The FCA then set a 50% tipping point: where undisclosed commission exceeded half of the premium, firms should presume the relationship was unfair, and the refund covers only the portion of commission above 50%, not the whole premium.4Financial Conduct Authority. FCA Finalise Plans to Place a Deadline on PPI Complaints Commission on PPI was routinely between 50% and 80% of the premium, so most policies with hidden commission qualify.5The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom. Plevin v Paragon Personal Finance Limited
The Plevin route catches policies that were otherwise suitable for the borrower. Even if the cover genuinely matched your circumstances, hidden commission above the threshold still entitles you to a partial refund. If you already received a mis-selling payout from the FSCS, you cannot bring a separate Plevin claim against the same firm.2Financial Services Compensation Scheme. You Can Still Claim PPI for Failed Firms After the Deadline
Two Narrow Exceptions to the 2019 Deadline
A small number of standard complaints can still go to a lender that is still trading. If the policy was taken out after 29 August 2017, the normal complaints route may still apply. And if a PPI policy bought before that date was still active on 29 August 2019 and the insurer rejected a claim on it, you can complain about the specific grounds for that rejection.4Financial Conduct Authority. FCA Finalise Plans to Place a Deadline on PPI Complaints
How Your Settlement Is Calculated
A PPI settlement aims to put you back in the position you would have been in had the policy never been sold. The calculation has two main parts.
The first is a refund of what you paid. For a standard mis-selling claim that means all the premiums. For a Plevin commission claim it means only the slice of commission above 50% of the premium. If the PPI was financed as part of the loan rather than paid separately, the settlement should also return the extra loan interest you paid on the PPI portion of the borrowing.
The second is statutory interest at 8% a year, running from the date of each premium to the date of settlement. On a policy that ran for several years the interest alone can exceed the premium refund.
Documents You Need
A strong claim depends on identifying the original credit agreement. The most useful details are the policy number, the dates the cover ran, and the name of the lender. Old bank statements, loan agreements, and annual PPI statements are primary evidence. If you no longer have them, a credit report can help identify past lenders and account numbers, though entries drop off after six years.6MoneyHelper. How to Check Your Credit Report for Free
For FSCS claims, the scheme’s online portal walks you through what to supply: your name, date of birth, addresses, and the reason you believe the policy was mis-sold. Being specific helps. “I was told I had to buy PPI to get the loan” carries far more weight than “I don’t think I needed it.” Cross-check your statements so dates and amounts line up, because inconsistencies slow the process down.
Filing a Claim and Escalating a Dispute
For claims against failed firms, you file through the FSCS website. The FSCS acknowledges receipt and provides updates; processing times depend on complexity and current volumes.
For the narrow exceptions where the lender is still trading, you start with the firm’s own complaints channel. Most large banks run dedicated PPI portals for inquiry forms and supporting documents, and physical claim packs can also be sent by recorded post. The firm has eight weeks to issue a final response.7Financial Conduct Authority. PPI Complaints Deadline Leaflet
If a lender rejects your complaint or fails to respond within eight weeks, you can take the dispute to the Financial Ombudsman Service. The Ombudsman is free, independent, and can order the firm to pay compensation. You must refer the complaint within six months of the final response letter. Miss that window and you lose the right to escalate.7Financial Conduct Authority. PPI Complaints Deadline Leaflet Firms are bound by the Ombudsman’s decision once you accept it.
Tax on Your PPI Settlement
The premium refund is not taxable. It is your own money coming back. The statutory interest portion counts as savings income, and lenders deduct basic rate income tax at 20% before paying it. So if your settlement contains £1,000 of statutory interest, you receive £800 and the lender sends £200 to HMRC.
You can often reclaim that £200. The Personal Savings Allowance lets basic rate taxpayers earn up to £1,000 of savings interest tax-free each year, and higher rate taxpayers £500.8HM Revenue & Customs. Tax on Savings Interest: How Much Tax You Pay If your total savings income for the tax year falls within your allowance, you are entitled to a full refund of the tax deducted from the settlement.
To reclaim, submit form R40 to HMRC, either online or on paper from GOV.UK, with the settlement letter as evidence.9HM Revenue & Customs. Claim a Refund if You’ve Paid Tax on Your Savings and Investments You have four years from the end of the relevant tax year, so a payout received in 2025/26 must be reclaimed by 5 April 2030.10HM Revenue & Customs. SACM12155 – Overpayment Relief: Time Limits for Making a Claim If you file Self Assessment, you cannot use R40 and should include the interest on your return instead.
Avoid Upfront Fees and Scams
PPI refund scams continued after the deadline. The FCA warns consumers to be cautious of anyone claiming they can get a refund for you, and to report suspicious approaches through its contact form or on 0800 111 6768.1Financial Conduct Authority. PPI Complaints Common tactics include cold calls or texts about an unclaimed payout, requests for upfront fees to process a refund, and demands for bank details.
Legitimate claims never require an upfront payment. The FSCS and the Financial Ombudsman Service are both free. If you use a claims management company, check it is FCA-authorised through the FCA Firm Checker, and remember that CMC fees for PPI claims are capped by law. The remaining routes are straightforward enough to handle yourself, so paying a CMC is rarely necessary.