For most investors, a gold ETF is the cheaper, simpler way to own gold, and physical gold earns its higher costs only if you want metal you can hold, store yourself, and leave alone for a very long time. The choice between physical gold and a gold ETF turns on four things: how much you’re investing, how long you plan to hold, how you feel about counterparty risk, and whether the gold is going inside a retirement account. Taxes are largely a wash, because the IRS treats both as collectibles.
How the Costs Compare
Physical gold charges you most of its cost the day you buy it. Dealers add a premium to the spot price: roughly 2% to 4% on standard bars and 4% to 8% on sovereign coins like American Gold Eagles. Insured shipping, credit card surcharges, and (in some states) sales tax pile on top. A $10,000 bar can easily cost $10,200 to $10,400 before it reaches your door.
Gold ETFs charge an annual expense ratio instead. The cheapest physically-backed funds now run under 0.10%; SPDR Gold Shares (GLD), the largest, charges 0.40%.1State Street Global Advisors. SPDR Gold Shares GLD That fee comes out of the fund’s assets daily, so the amount of gold each share represents slowly declines over time.2Charles Schwab. ETFs: Expense Ratios and Other Costs Most brokerages have dropped trading commissions, so buying and selling is usually free.
The break-even math depends on how long you hold. A 3% dealer premium on a $50,000 purchase costs $1,500 once. An ETF charging 0.40% costs $200 in year one on the same amount, and it takes roughly seven or eight years of expense ratios to match the one-time physical premium. But that comparison ignores storage and insurance on the physical side, which chip away at the advantage every year. Under about $25,000, held under five years, an ETF almost always wins on cost. For large positions held for decades, the numbers converge and non-financial factors start to decide.
Taxes on Gold: Mostly the Same, With a Few Wrinkles
The IRS classifies gold as a collectible. Long-term gains face a maximum federal rate of 28%, higher than the 15% or 20% most stock investors pay.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1 – Tax Imposed Gold held one year or less is taxed as ordinary income at your marginal rate.
Choosing an ETF does not get you around this. The major physically-backed funds, including GLD and the Goldman Sachs Physical Gold ETF, are structured as grantor trusts, so tax treatment passes through as if you owned the metal.4Goldman Sachs Asset Management. Goldman Sachs Physical Gold ETF Grantor Trust Tax Reporting Statement The 28% collectibles ceiling still applies.
Futures-based gold funds are different. They may fall under Section 1256, which taxes 60% of your gain at long-term rates and 40% at short-term rates regardless of holding period.5Internal Revenue Service. Form 6781 – Gains and Losses From Section 1256 Contracts and Straddles For high earners the blended rate can beat 28%, but reporting gets more complicated.
One tax that only touches physical gold is state sales tax. In states that still tax bullion, combined rates of 7% to 10% can exceed the dealer’s premium. Most states now exempt gold bullion, and some apply exemptions above a purchase threshold, so a single large order may escape a tax that smaller buys would trigger. ETF shares are not subject to sales tax anywhere.
Getting Your Money Out
ETF shares sell in seconds during market hours at the current price. Since the SEC shortened the settlement cycle to one business day in May 2024, proceeds land in your brokerage account the next business day.6U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Shortening the Securities Transaction Settlement Cycle – Small Entity Compliance Guide
Selling physical gold is slower. You find a dealer or local coin shop, accept a buyback price below spot (the dealer needs margin on the resale), and if you’re shipping to a centralized buyer, you pay for insured transit and wait for verification before payment releases. Bars without recognized hallmarks may need to be assayed, which costs more and adds time. A week or more from decision to cash is typical.
Storage If You Buy Physical
Physical gold is your problem to protect. A quality burglar-rated home safe runs several hundred dollars up front, and a standard homeowner’s policy usually covers only a few hundred dollars of precious metals per loss, so you’ll need a separate rider. Bank safe deposit boxes rent for about $10 to $50 a year for small sizes and over $100 for larger ones, and FDIC insurance does not cover their contents, so you still need coverage.7PNC Bank. What Is a Safe Deposit Box Professional depositories offer allocated storage, where your specific bars sit in dedicated space, or cheaper commingled storage, where your gold is pooled with other customers’ metal and tracked by account balance.
ETF investors don’t deal with any of this. The fund’s custodian, typically a major bank, stores the gold in institutional vaults, and storage and insurance costs are inside the expense ratio.8SEC.gov. SPDR ETFs: Basics of Product Structure
Counterparty Risk
Physical gold’s real advantage is that no one else has to exist for you to own it. No custodian, no fund manager, no exchange. You hold the metal. For investors who view gold as insurance against systemic problems, that independence is the whole point.
Gold ETF shares represent a beneficial interest in a trust’s holdings, not a claim on specific bars, and retail shareholders generally cannot demand physical delivery.8SEC.gov. SPDR ETFs: Basics of Product Structure If the custodian bank became insolvent, recovering the gold could take time and legal expense. Exchanges can halt trading and regulators can impose restrictions in a crisis. Day to day these risks are small, but they exist in exactly the scenarios that drive people toward gold to begin with.
Gold Inside an IRA
An IRA adds tax-deferred or tax-free growth, but the rules on physical gold are strict. Bullion must meet a minimum fineness of 99.5%, with a specific carve-out for American Gold Eagles despite their 91.67% purity.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 408 – Individual Retirement Accounts A qualified trustee or custodian has to hold the metal. You cannot store it at home or in your personal safe deposit box.
Taking personal possession of IRA gold is a taxable distribution. The full value becomes ordinary income, and if you’re under 59½, you also pay a 10% early withdrawal penalty.10Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 408 – Individual Retirement Accounts A well-known Tax Court case saw a couple who moved IRA coins into a home-based LLC end up owing more than $300,000 on a $730,000 account. “Self-directed” is not “self-stored.”
Gold ETFs sidestep all of this. You buy shares in a standard brokerage IRA, no special custodian, no purity checks, no storage arrangements. For most retirement investors who want gold exposure, that alone tips the decision.
Reporting Paperwork
Physical gold creates reporting obligations that ETFs don’t. Pay a dealer more than $10,000 in cash for a single transaction or a series of related ones, and the dealer files Form 8300 with the IRS and FinCEN.11Internal Revenue Service. Form 8300 and Reporting Cash Payments of Over $10,000 It’s an anti-money-laundering filing, not a tax, but your transaction is on record.
On the sale side, dealers may need to issue Form 1099-B depending on what you sold and how much. Reporting is required for precious metals in forms and quantities that meet the minimums for regulated futures contracts, and for gold coins the threshold is typically 25 or more coins within 24 hours. Smaller sales may not generate a 1099-B, but you still owe tax on the gain.12Internal Revenue Service. Instructions for Form 1099-B (2026)
ETF sales are automatic. Your brokerage issues a 1099-B, tracks cost basis, and hands you what you need at tax time.
Which One Fits Your Situation
Pick a gold ETF if you’re investing under about $50,000, plan to hold under ten years, want easy tax reporting, or need gold exposure inside a retirement account. Choose a fund with a low expense ratio and be done with it. The cost math works, liquidity is instant, and storage isn’t your problem.
Physical gold earns its premium when you’re building a long-term store of wealth outside the financial system, want an asset with no counterparty, or plan to pass metal to heirs without selling. Investors who buy physical gold and then check the price every week would usually be better off in an ETF. The people who get the most out of holding the metal are the ones who buy it, put it away, and leave it alone.