If your pension plan sent you a notice saying it overpaid you, pension overpayment recovery is governed by rules that heavily favor you as long as you did not cause the error. Under the SECURE 2.0 Act, which applies to any recoupment that had not already started before January 1, 2023, a private-sector plan generally cannot claw back more than 10% of the total overpayment in any calendar year, cannot drop your monthly check below 90% of the correct amount, cannot charge interest or fees, and cannot pursue you at all if the first overpayment happened more than three years before it notified you in writing.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1056 – Form and Payment of Benefits The notice does not go away, but what the plan can demand is tightly bounded.
What SECURE 2.0 Limits the Plan to Doing
The protections are codified at 29 U.S.C. § 1056(h) and apply to participants who were not culpable in causing the overpayment. For you, they translate into a specific list of things the plan is not allowed to do:
- Charge interest on the overpaid amount or add collection costs.
- Recover more than 10% of the total overpayment in any calendar year through benefit reductions.
- Reduce your monthly payment below 90% of the correctly calculated benefit.
- Pursue the debt at all when the first overpayment occurred more than three years before the plan sent you written notice.
- Refer your account to a collection agency without first obtaining a court judgment or a settlement with you.
- Threaten litigation unless the fiduciary determines a lawsuit is likely to recover more than it costs.
- Deny you access to the plan’s formal claims procedure to contest the recoupment.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1056 – Form and Payment of Benefits
There is one more piece of relief worth knowing about. IRS Notice 2024-77 confirms that a plan can simply choose not to pursue an “inadvertent” overpayment without jeopardizing its tax-qualified status.2Internal Revenue Service. Guidance Under Sections 414(aa) and 402(c)(12) The plan is not required to forgive the debt, but it now has the clear option, which is a reasonable thing to raise in an appeal.
When the Protections Don’t Apply
SECURE 2.0’s caps and restrictions fall away if the plan determines you were culpable. Under the statute, that means you made misrepresentations or omissions that caused the overpayment, or you knew your payments were materially more than you were entitled to receive. Cashing checks at an amount you had no reason to question does not, on its own, make you culpable. Failing to report a return to work that should have reduced your benefit, or submitting incorrect earnings information, is a different matter — in those situations the plan can pursue the full amount without the annual cap or the three-year window.
If your spouse was overpaid during their lifetime, IRS guidance generally bars the plan from reducing your survivor benefit to recover that excess. The plan can only come after a survivor’s benefit when the error was in calculating the survivor benefit itself.
Plans Not Covered
These rules sit inside ERISA, which does not reach government pensions or most church plans.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1003 – Coverage If you receive a federal CSRS or FERS pension, state employee pension, or municipal plan benefit, the 10% cap and three-year discovery limit do not apply to you. Your rights come from the statute governing that specific plan, and the terms vary widely. Social Security overpayments follow their own waiver standard administered by the Social Security Administration.
How the Recoupment Actually Works
Most plans recover by reducing future checks rather than demanding a lump sum. The arithmetic is straightforward. If the plan says it overpaid you $12,000, it can take back no more than $1,200 per year. For a retiree whose correct benefit is $2,000 per month, no single payment can drop below $1,800. At $100 per month, that $12,000 takes ten years to recover.
Some plans will offer you a choice between paying the full amount up front and accepting the monthly offset. A lump sum ends the matter immediately, but most retirees on fixed incomes find installments more manageable. If the plan proposes a repayment pace steeper than SECURE 2.0 allows, that schedule is likely unenforceable for errors discovered after December 29, 2022, as long as you were not at fault.
A detail that surprises people: the overpayment is calculated on gross figures, before any taxes the plan withheld. If you were overpaid $500 per month for two years and taxes came out of each payment, you still owe the plan the full $12,000. The withheld-tax portion is something you recover from the IRS, not from the plan.
Taxes on What You Repay
You paid income tax on money the plan now wants back. How you recoup that tax depends almost entirely on one number: $3,000.
Repayments Over $3,000
If you return more than $3,000, Internal Revenue Code Section 1341 gives you the “claim of right” doctrine.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 1341 – Computation of Tax Where Taxpayer Restores Substantial Amount Held Under Claim of Right You get the better of two choices: deduct the repayment in the year you make it, or calculate a tax credit based on removing the income from the earlier year it was received.
IRS Publication 525 walks through the credit method. Figure your current tax without any deduction, then refigure your tax for the year the overpayment was originally received as if that income had never been there. The difference is your credit against this year’s tax.5Internal Revenue Service. Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income For the deduction method, you take the repayment as an other itemized deduction on Schedule A. Running the numbers both ways is worth the effort because the credit method often wins for retirees who have dropped into a lower bracket since the overpayment years.
Repayments of $3,000 or Less
Smaller repayments get worse treatment. Since 2018, miscellaneous itemized deductions have been eliminated, so repayments of $3,000 or less are not deductible at all.5Internal Revenue Service. Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income The threshold is a fixed statutory figure, not adjusted for inflation. That is a hidden cost of a long installment plan: if each year’s reduction comes in at or under $3,000, you may never cross the threshold to claim relief. When the plan offers a choice between a lump sum and installments, do the tax math before you decide.
Verify the Plan’s Math First
Before signing a repayment schedule, confirm the overpayment is real and the number is right. Administrators make calculation errors in both directions. The notice should state the start and end dates of the error and the gross amount claimed.
Ask for your Summary Plan Description, which sets out the benefit formula and the plan’s rules on error correction. Then request the calculation worksheets the plan used to arrive at both your original benefit and the corrected one. You want to see the inputs: years of service, final average salary, accrual rate, and any early-retirement reduction factors. Comparing those against your own employment records is where most mistakes show up.
Send document requests in writing to the plan’s benefits department, include your participant identification number, and specify the employment periods in question. Federal law requires plans to produce certain documents on written request from a participant, and the SPD is one of them. If the plan cannot produce the worksheets showing how it got to the overpayment figure, raise that failure in your appeal.
Filing an Appeal Inside the Plan
ERISA requires every pension plan to provide a claims procedure that gives you written notice of any adverse decision, with specific reasons, and a full and fair review.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1133 – Claims Procedure SECURE 2.0 reinforces this by requiring plans to let participants use the formal claims process to contest any recoupment.
Federal regulations set the clock on how fast the plan must respond. An initial claim decision is due within 90 days, with up to a 90-day extension if the plan notifies you in writing of the reason more time is needed. A denied claim that you appeal generally gets a decision within 60 days, extendable by another 60.7eCFR. 29 CFR 2560.503-1 – Claims Procedure
Send the appeal by certified mail with return receipt, or through the plan’s secure portal if there is one. Include everything you have: employment records, pay stubs, the original benefit calculation you were given at retirement, and any correspondence from the plan about your benefit level. A denial letter must explain the specific reasons for the decision and identify what steps remain open to you.
Outside Help if the Plan Won’t Budge
The Employee Benefits Security Administration within the Department of Labor assists retirees with benefit disputes. You can reach EBSA at 1-866-444-3272 or through the online form on the agency’s website.8U.S. Department of Labor. Ask EBSA A benefits advisor can walk you through your rights, and a call from the Department of Labor to a plan administrator sometimes produces a more reasonable outcome. EBSA also has regional field offices for in-person help.
ERISA gives you the right to sue in federal court to recover benefits, enforce your rights under the plan, or clarify your future entitlement.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 1132 – Civil Enforcement You generally have to exhaust the plan’s internal appeal before a court will take the case. ERISA litigation is specialized and costly, with attorney rates commonly running $500 to $900 per hour. Some lawyers take larger disputes on contingency, but most want an hourly retainer. The size of the claimed overpayment should drive whether a lawsuit makes financial sense.
What Happens if You Ignore the Notice
Silence does not make the debt disappear and usually makes the outcome worse. If you do not engage with the claims process, the plan can start reducing your monthly check on the schedule stated in the notice. For non-culpable participants, those reductions still have to stay within the SECURE 2.0 caps, but the plan does not need your consent to begin the offset once it has given proper notice.
Plans can also go to federal court themselves, bringing a fiduciary action to recover plan assets. Such a suit can reach only funds specifically traceable to the overpayment, not your general accounts, but it is still a real risk when amounts are large. If you believe the notice is wrong, engage with the process, demand the calculation documents, and file a formal appeal within the plan’s deadlines. Once those windows close, the leverage is gone.