An onerous lease provision is the IFRS-specific liability you record under IAS 37 when a lease’s unavoidable costs exceed the economic benefits you expect from it. Under US GAAP there is no equivalent provision for leases; you instead test the right-of-use asset for impairment under ASC 360 and keep paying down the lease liability on its original schedule. Identifying which framework you report under is the first decision, because it determines whether you create a new liability or write down an existing asset.
When a Lease Becomes Onerous
A lease is onerous when the unavoidable costs of meeting your obligations under it exceed the economic benefits you expect to receive. The trigger varies: a division relocation that empties a floor of office space, a market downturn that makes a retail location permanently unprofitable, a change in operations that leaves equipment idle, or a technology shift that makes leased equipment obsolete mid-term.
The trigger matters less than the arithmetic. Unavoidable costs include the remaining lease payments, any maintenance you are contractually required to perform, and penalties or compensation you would owe the landlord. Expected benefits include continued use of the asset, cost savings, and any realistic sublease income. If the costs win, the lease is onerous and one of the two accounting responses below is required.
IFRS: Recognizing a Provision Under IAS 37
IAS 37 defines an onerous contract as one where the unavoidable costs of meeting the obligations exceed the economic benefits expected to be received. When a lease meets that definition, the standard requires recognizing the net loss as a provision immediately rather than spreading it across future periods. Three conditions must all be met: a present obligation exists from a past event, an outflow of resources is probable, and you can make a reliable estimate of the amount.
Test the ROU Asset First
Before recording a provision, assess whether the right-of-use asset itself is impaired under IAS 36. IFRS 16 explicitly subjects ROU assets to IAS 36 impairment testing. If the asset is impaired, write down its carrying amount first, then determine whether any remaining net cost still warrants an IAS 37 provision. Skipping the impairment step and jumping straight to the provision can result in double-counting losses on the same lease.
Measuring the Provision
The provision equals the least net cost of exiting the contract. You calculate two numbers and record the lower one:
- The net cost of fulfilling the lease through its remaining term: all remaining payments and directly related costs, less any income you could realistically generate by subleasing.
- The cost of terminating the lease early: the penalty, compensation, or termination payment the lease requires.
A 2022 amendment to IAS 37 clarified that costs of fulfilling include both incremental costs, such as direct labor and materials, and an allocation of other costs that relate directly to fulfilling the contract, such as depreciation on equipment used in performance. Before this change, some companies included only incremental costs, which understated the provision. If the termination payment is structured over time rather than due immediately, discount those future payments.
Discount Rate
When the time value of money is material, IAS 37 requires discounting the provision to present value. The rate must be a pre-tax rate that reflects current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific to the liability. This is not the incremental borrowing rate used to measure the lease liability under IFRS 16. The incremental borrowing rate reflects the lessee’s credit risk when borrowing; the IAS 37 rate reflects the risk characteristics of the provision itself. Using the wrong rate will misstate the provision.
Worked Example
Your company has 48 months remaining on an office lease at $10,000 per month, and the space sits empty after a headquarters relocation. After discounting the remaining payments and subtracting realistic sublease income of $2,000 per month from a partial sublet, the present value of fulfilling the lease is $340,000. The landlord offers early termination for a one-time payment of $300,000. You recognize a provision of $300,000, because exit is the cheaper path.
The Journal Entry
The initial entry debits an expense account, often labeled Onerous Lease Expense or Restructuring Expense, and credits Provision for Onerous Contract. The full estimated loss hits the income statement in the period the lease becomes onerous. As you make lease payments or pay the termination penalty, you debit the provision and credit cash, drawing down the liability. Any unwinding of the discount over time is recognized as a finance cost.
US GAAP: ROU Asset Impairment Under ASC 360
US GAAP takes a fundamentally different approach. There is no general onerous contract provision for leases. Under ASC 842, operating leases sit on the balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability, and the SEC staff has taken the position that it is generally inappropriate to accrue for a loss on a firmly committed executory contract unless specific authoritative guidance requires it. For leases, the specific guidance is the ASC 360 impairment model applied to the ROU asset.
The Recoverability Test
When a triggering event occurs, you test the ROU asset (or the asset group containing it) for recoverability. ASC 360-10-35-21 lists several indicators, including a significant adverse change in how the asset is being used, a current-period operating loss combined with a history of losses, or a current expectation that the asset will be disposed of well before its useful life ends. Vacating a leased space, committing to abandon it, or a sustained drop in cash flows associated with the asset all qualify.
The test compares the carrying amount of the ROU asset (or asset group) to the sum of undiscounted future cash flows expected from its use and eventual disposition. If the undiscounted cash flows fall below the carrying amount, the asset is not recoverable, and you measure the impairment loss as the difference between the carrying amount and fair value.
Abandonment
When a company commits to abandoning a leased space before the lease term ends, the decision itself is an impairment indicator, and you test the ROU asset immediately. An abandoned ROU asset is then reduced to its salvage value, typically zero or close to it, as of the cease-use date. Here is the point that trips people up: the lease liability does not change. Absent a lease modification or termination agreement with the landlord, you continue making lease payments and reducing the lease liability on its original amortization schedule. The impairment hits only the asset side. After impairment, the ROU asset is amortized over the shorter of its remaining useful life or the remaining lease term.
The Journal Entry
Debit Impairment Loss and credit Right-of-Use Asset for the difference between carrying amount and fair value. No separate provision or liability is created. The lease liability entries continue unchanged: each payment debits the lease liability (and interest expense for finance leases) and credits cash, on the original schedule.
How Subleasing Affects the Calculation
Sublease income is central under both frameworks because it directly reduces the net cost of fulfillment. Expected sublease income can offset the burden, but only to the extent it is realistic and legally available.
Check the lease for restrictions before assuming any sublease income. Many commercial leases contain recapture clauses that let the landlord terminate the lease entirely when a tenant attempts to sublease, sometimes triggering acceleration of remaining payments. Even leases that permit assignment may include profit-sharing provisions or landlord consent requirements that limit the financial benefit. If the lease prohibits subleasing outright, you cannot include sublease income in the measurement at all.
Under US GAAP, ASC 842-20-35-14 specifies that when lease cost for the sublease term exceeds anticipated sublease income, the excess is an impairment indicator for the ROU asset. If you cannot sublease the space for enough to cover your own payments, you likely have an impairment to test.
Later Changes: Reversal Under IFRS, Permanence Under US GAAP
Under IFRS, IAS 37 requires reviewing provisions at each reporting date and adjusting them to reflect the current best estimate. If conditions improve, such as securing a sublease tenant at a better rate than initially assumed, or the landlord agreeing to reduce remaining payments, you reduce the provision and recognize a gain in the income statement. If it becomes no longer probable that an outflow is required, the provision is reversed entirely. Reversals cannot exceed the original amount recognized.
Under US GAAP, impairment losses on long-lived assets are not reversible. Once you write down the ROU asset, the reduction is permanent. If circumstances improve, you adjust future amortization rather than reverse the impairment. This asymmetry can produce materially different results between the two frameworks when conditions turn around.
Tax Treatment
Book and tax treatment diverge for onerous leases, creating temporary differences that affect your tax provision. Under 26 U.S.C. ยง 461(h), the all events test for deducting a liability is not met any earlier than when economic performance occurs. For liabilities arising from the use of property, economic performance occurs as the taxpayer actually uses the property, not when the liability is recognized for accounting purposes.
The accounting provision under IFRS, or the impairment loss under US GAAP, hits the income statement immediately, but the corresponding tax deduction comes only as lease payments are actually made. The gap creates a deductible temporary difference that typically supports recognition of a deferred tax asset, recognized only to the extent it is probable (IFRS) or more likely than not (US GAAP) that sufficient future taxable income will be available to realize the benefit.
Disclosure Requirements
Under IFRS, IAS 37 requires detailed disclosures for each class of provision: carrying amount at the beginning and end of the period, additional provisions made during the period, amounts used, unused amounts reversed, and the increase from the passage of time. You also disclose a description of the nature of the obligation, the expected timing of outflows, and the uncertainties affecting amount or timing. If a reimbursement is expected, such as committed subtenant payments, you disclose that amount and any asset recognized for it.
Under US GAAP, ROU asset impairment losses follow ASC 360’s requirements: the amount of the loss, the facts and circumstances leading to impairment, the method used to determine fair value, and the segment affected. For SEC registrants, Regulation S-K Item 303 requires disclosure of material cash requirements from known contractual obligations and any known trends or uncertainties reasonably likely to have a material impact on continuing operations, which often means discussing the potential for future onerous-lease charges before they are recorded.
Provision Versus Impairment: Why They Are Not the Same
The two responses address different sides of the balance sheet even when they arise from the same business event. The ROU asset impairment asks whether the carrying amount of the asset has become unrecoverable. The onerous lease provision, an IFRS-only tool, asks whether the remaining contract still creates a net loss after the asset has been written down.
IFRS reporters typically perform both analyses and may end up showing a reduced ROU asset alongside a separate onerous contract provision for the same lease. US GAAP reporters show only the impaired ROU asset next to an unchanged lease liability. Neither framework lets you ignore the problem, but the mechanics and presentation differ enough that identifying your framework has to come before any journal entry.