Navy Federal EFTA Settlement: $1.7M Payouts and Eligibility

The Navy Federal EFTA settlement is a $1.7 million class action resolution in Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union, approved by a federal court in San Diego in early 2026, that pays members whose unauthorized electronic fund transfer disputes were denied between October 10, 2022, and August 20, 2025. The claim-filing deadline of December 18, 2025, has passed.1Stephenson EFTA Litigation. Stephenson v. NFCU Claim Form If you filed a valid claim, your payment is on its way.

When and How You Get Paid

Judge William Q. Hayes granted final approval at a hearing on February 4, 2026, and the case docket shows a termination date of February 9, 2026.2ClassAction.org. 1.72M Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Ends Lawsuit Over Alleged Electronic Funds Transfer Act Violations3CourtListener. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union Docket Once the settlement becomes effective and Navy Federal deposits the funds, the claims administrator has ten business days to begin distributing money.4ClassAction.org. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Agreement As of mid-2026, payments have not yet been fully distributed.

Current Navy Federal accountholders will see their share applied as a credit to their accounts. Former members will receive a check in the mail.2ClassAction.org. 1.72M Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Ends Lawsuit Over Alleged Electronic Funds Transfer Act Violations Questions about a claim, a check that hasn’t arrived, or a change of address go to Kroll Settlement Administration at (833) 621-8312 or through the settlement website at stephensoneftalitigation.com.5Stephenson EFTA Litigation. Stephenson EFTA Litigation Settlement Website

How Much Each Claimant Receives

The settlement agreement doesn’t set a fixed dollar amount per person. Instead, after court-approved attorneys’ fees and litigation costs come out of the $1.7 million fund, whatever is left (the “net settlement fund”) is divided equally among all approved claims on a pro rata basis. Class counsel was permitted to ask for up to one-third of the settlement value in fees. Anything the court declined to award stays in the fund for class members.4ClassAction.org. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Agreement

Not every claim counts the same. Members of the Written Explanation Settlement Class each count as one approved claim. Members of the Document Request Settlement Subclass, who experienced an additional violation, each count as two approved claims and so receive roughly double the per-claim share.4ClassAction.org. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Agreement Because the final per-person figure depends on how many valid claims came in, the actual payout won’t be known until the administrator finishes processing.

Separately from the fund, the two named plaintiffs, Jeffrey Stephenson and Billy Smith II, each receive $5,000 for their individual actual-damages claims plus a $5,000 service award for representing the class.4ClassAction.org. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Agreement

What You Give Up By Taking the Settlement

The release in this settlement is narrow, and that matters. By accepting a payment, class members release only their statutory damages claims under the Electronic Fund Transfer Act. Statutory damages are the penalty amounts the law allows regardless of what you actually lost.6Stephenson EFTA Litigation. Stephenson v. NFCU Long Form Notice

You keep the right to pursue your own individual claim against Navy Federal for the actual money you lost when the credit union denied your unauthorized-transaction dispute.4ClassAction.org. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Agreement For members whose losses from a disputed transfer were substantial, that preserved right is often worth more than the pro rata share from the settlement fund. The narrow release reflects a structural limit in the law itself: EFTA caps total class-wide statutory damages at the lesser of $500,000 or one percent of the defendant’s net worth.7Cornell Law Institute. 15 U.S.C. § 1693m

Who the Settlement Covered

The settlement defined two groups of Navy Federal accountholders. The Written Explanation Settlement Class covered members whose claims of unauthorized electronic fund transfers were denied between October 10, 2022, and August 20, 2025. The Document Request Settlement Subclass was a smaller group within that class: members who, after the denial, asked Navy Federal for the documents it relied on and never received them.8Justia. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union, Preliminary Approval Order

The claim deadline was December 18, 2025. The deadline to opt out or object was December 3, 2025.5Stephenson EFTA Litigation. Stephenson EFTA Litigation Settlement Website Both have passed. If you were eligible but didn’t file a claim, you are not entitled to a payment from this settlement, though you still retain your individual actual-damages claim because you never signed the release.

What the Lawsuit Alleged

The complaint, filed October 10, 2023, in the Southern District of California, raised three EFTA violations.2ClassAction.org. 1.72M Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Ends Lawsuit Over Alleged Electronic Funds Transfer Act Violations First, that Navy Federal improperly denied members’ claims of unauthorized electronic fund transfers. Second, that it failed to provide an adequate written explanation of those denials. Third, that when members asked to see the documents Navy Federal relied on in deciding against them, the credit union never produced them.6Stephenson EFTA Litigation. Stephenson v. NFCU Long Form Notice The lawsuit also raised claims under California’s Business and Professions Code and Unfair Competition Law.

Navy Federal moved to dismiss the EFTA and breach-of-contract claims. The court denied that motion on September 20, 2024, letting the case proceed. After discovery and mediation before retired Judge Diane M. Welsh, the parties reached a settlement agreement on July 16, 2025, and Judge Hayes gave it preliminary approval on August 20, 2025.4ClassAction.org. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union Settlement Agreement8Justia. Stephenson v. Navy Federal Credit Union, Preliminary Approval Order

What This Settlement Is Not

Navy Federal has been the subject of several unrelated legal actions, and it’s easy to confuse them with this one. This settlement does not involve overdraft fees. A separate 2019 class action over overdraft fee practices settled for $24.5 million, with payments applied automatically to member accounts.9CU Today. Navy FCU Agrees to Settle Class Action on Overdrafts for $24.5 Million10Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Navy Federal Credit Union Overdraft Enforcement Action11Consumer Federation of America. From Refunds to Reversal: Navy Federal Overdraft Complaints Reveal Impact of CFPB Rollback on Military Families

It also does not involve mortgage lending. Oliver v. Navy Federal Credit Union, a mortgage discrimination class action revived by the Fourth Circuit in February 2026, is a different case entirely.12ABA Banking Journal. Fourth Circuit Revives Class Action Challenging Navy Federal’s Mortgage Lending Practices The Stephenson settlement is about denied unauthorized-transfer disputes and nothing else.