An LLR Inc charge on your bank or credit card statement is almost always a purchase of LuLaRoe clothing bought through one of the company’s independent consultants. LLR, Inc. is the California-based corporate name behind LuLaRoe, a multilevel-marketing seller of women’s apparel such as leggings and dresses. If the charge looks unfamiliar, it may be an order placed by someone on your account, or it may be a legitimate purchase that included sales tax you did not actually owe. For several years, LuLaRoe’s checkout system added sales tax to orders in states and jurisdictions where clothing was not taxable, and that practice produced tens of thousands of overcharges and a string of class-action lawsuits.
Why the Charge May Be Higher Than It Should Be
LuLaRoe consultants processed orders through a proprietary point-of-sale app called “Audrey.” The system calculated sales tax based on the consultant’s location rather than the buyer’s shipping address.1U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Van v. LLR, Inc., No. 21-36020 A customer in a tax-free state like Alaska or Montana could be charged tax at the rate of whatever state or county the consultant lived in, adding as much as 10.25 percent to the price.2Top Class Actions. LuLaRoe Class Action Lawsuit Filed Over Improper Sales Tax Collection
LuLaRoe identified the programming error in January 2016. In April 2016, instead of correcting it, the company disabled a toggle in Audrey that had let consultants turn off tax for orders shipping to tax-free jurisdictions. The company distributed a white paper by tax attorney Terrel Transtrum arguing the practice was legal, comparing online orders to in-person “home party” sales where the consultant’s local tax rate would apply, and told consultants to share the document with any customer who questioned the tax.3Truth in Advertising. Porsch v. LLR, Inc. — Second Amended Complaint Attorneys general in Pennsylvania and Minnesota told the company to review and fix the practice, but it stayed in place until mid-2017.4ClassAction.org. LuLaRoe Hit With Class Action in New York Over Allegedly Fraudulent Sales Tax Policy
States Where Buyers Were Overcharged
A February 2017 lawsuit, Webster v. LLR, Inc., identified eleven states where clothing purchases were allegedly not taxable but customers were charged sales tax anyway:
- Alaska
- Delaware
- Massachusetts
- Minnesota
- Montana
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New York
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Vermont
The scale was large. In New York, where clothing purchases under $110 are exempt from sales tax, the Porsch complaint alleged LuLaRoe charged unauthorized tax on roughly 104,144 transactions between April 2016 and June 2017.3Truth in Advertising. Porsch v. LLR, Inc. — Second Amended Complaint In Alaska, improper charges totaled $255,263.72 across 72,373 purchases by 10,606 customers.1U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Van v. LLR, Inc., No. 21-36020 Separate complaints to the FTC also described customers being taxed in states like Massachusetts, New Jersey, and Delaware, and being taxed on shipping fees in jurisdictions that did not permit it.5Truth in Advertising. LLR FTC Complaints
The 2017 Refund Program
Between March and June 2017, LuLaRoe began issuing refunds for the improperly collected tax.1U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Van v. LLR, Inc., No. 21-36020 The company described the refunds as voluntary and unrelated to the lawsuits. Affected buyers received email notifications, and a service called “Checkbook” sent follow-up instructions for collecting payment. Customers who did not get a notice were directed to contact salestaxrefund@lularoe.com.6CBS 58. If You Purchased LuLaRoe, You May Be Getting Some Money Back
The program had gaps. Plaintiffs’ lawyers reported that LuLaRoe sometimes wired money to customers’ accounts with no prior explanation, leaving recipients unsure what the payments were for.7Forbes. Attorneys Question LuLaRoe’s Generosity in Wake of Sales Tax Lawsuit The Porsch complaint alleged that out of 104,144 affected New York transactions, only one had been refunded, calling the effort a “belated, ad hoc refund scheme.”3Truth in Advertising. Porsch v. LLR, Inc. — Second Amended Complaint In Montana, LuLaRoe said it had refunded $188,697 to state customers, but the plaintiff in Hill v. LLR, Inc. argued those refunds did not include interest or damages.8Great Falls Tribune. Great Falls Ex-LuLaRoe Consultant Sues Clothing MLM Company Over Illegal Sales Tax Collection
What the Lawsuits Produced
The longest-running case was Van v. LLR, Inc., filed by Katie Van in September 2018 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Alaska. Van alleged violations of the Alaska Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Act and common-law claims for conversion and misappropriation, seeking interest on the refunded tax plus statutory damages of $500 per transaction, roughly $36 million in total.1U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Van v. LLR, Inc., No. 21-36020
The case moved slowly. The Ninth Circuit ruled in June 2020 that even the small interest loss on refunded tax (about $3.76 for the lead plaintiff) was a concrete enough injury to sue over.9FindLaw. Van v. LLR, Inc., No. 19-35242 In March 2023 the Ninth Circuit vacated class certification, citing evidence that some consultants had given customers discounts or coupons that offset the improper tax, which meant checking who was actually harmed required looking at individual transactions.1U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Van v. LLR, Inc., No. 21-36020 The district court denied class certification again in December 2023. In January 2026 the parties told the court they had reached an agreement in principle to settle; the terms have not been publicly disclosed.10Bloomberg Tax. LuLaRoe Settles $36 Million Alaska Clothing Sales Tax Lawsuit
The parallel state cases did not produce consumer recoveries. Webster was denied class certification in August 2018 because of variations among state laws and was dismissed the following month.11ClassAction.org. Webster v. LLR, Inc. — Class Certification Denial Memorandum12ClassAction.org. Webster v. LLR, Inc. — Dismissal Order Porsch in New York and Hill in Montana were both ultimately dismissed.13Truth in Advertising. Lawsuits Against LuLaRoe Keep Mounting14GovInfo. Hill v. LLR, Inc. — Findings and Recommendations
A separate Washington State lawsuit focused on recruiting practices rather than billing. The state’s attorney general sued LuLaRoe in January 2019 alleging the company operated a pyramid scheme, and in February 2021 LuLaRoe agreed to pay $4.75 million (about $4 million for roughly 3,000 Washington residents and $750,000 for investigation costs) without admitting wrongdoing.15Washington State Attorney General. AG Ferguson Sues LuLaRoe Over Pyramid Scheme16Retail Dive. LuLaRoe To Pay $4.75M To Settle Pyramid Scheme Lawsuit That settlement did not provide refunds to retail clothing buyers.
What to Do About an LLR Inc Charge on Your Statement
If you recognize the purchase and the amount looks right, no action is needed. If the charge dates from between April 2016 and mid-2017 and you were billed sales tax on clothing shipped to one of the eleven states listed above, you may have been overcharged. LuLaRoe’s refund contact for the sales tax issue was salestaxrefund@lularoe.com, and the company said customers who did not receive an automatic notice should write there.6CBS 58. If You Purchased LuLaRoe, You May Be Getting Some Money Back
If the charge is one you do not recognize at all (no one in your household bought LuLaRoe clothing, and no consultant has your card on file), treat it the way you would any unknown charge: contact your card issuer or bank to dispute it. The LLR Inc descriptor itself only tells you the merchant; it does not tell you who placed the order.