LIHTC Qualified Contract Process: Price, Marketing, and Protections

The LIHTC Qualified Contract process is a federal exit mechanism that lets an owner of a Low-Income Housing Tax Credit property ask the state housing credit agency to find a preservation buyer, and if the agency cannot produce one within a year, the affordability restrictions come off the building. The right lives in 26 U.S.C. § 42(h)(6)(I), and it becomes available after the fourteenth year of the compliance period.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 42 Low-Income Housing Credit The mechanics look straightforward on paper. In practice the eligibility question, the price calculation, and the state agency’s role each carry enough weight to derail an unprepared owner.

Who Can File and When

The compliance period is the fifteen-year window during which the IRS can recapture credits if the property falls out of LIHTC compliance. It starts in the first year of the credit period, which the taxpayer elected on IRS Form 8609 as either the placed-in-service year or the year after. Misreading that election by a single year produces a premature filing.

Federal law allows the request any time after year 14 of the compliance period.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 42 Low-Income Housing Credit Because the agency then has a full year to market the property, an owner who files at the earliest date can potentially exit restrictions as compliance year 15 closes. That timing is the reason experienced owners begin assembling documentation well in advance.

Eligibility depends on the Extended Use Agreement (sometimes called a Land Use Restriction Agreement) recorded against the property. Many of these agreements require the owner to waive the Qualified Contract right entirely as a condition of receiving the credit allocation. If the owner signed a waiver, the property stays affordable for the full extended use period, which typically runs thirty years from the placed-in-service date.2U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. What Happens to Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Properties at Year 15 and Beyond Summary Check the Extended Use Agreement before doing anything else. If the waiver is there, the process ends before it starts.

The Qualified Contract Price

The buyer does not pay market value. The price comes from a statutory formula in IRC § 42(h)(6)(F) that splits the building into its low-income and non-low-income portions.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 42 Low-Income Housing Credit

The non-low-income portion is valued at fair market value, and that valuation includes the land underneath the entire building. The low-income portion is calculated by taking the applicable fraction from the Extended Use Agreement and multiplying it by a figure built from three additions and one subtraction:

  • Outstanding qualifying mortgage debt and loans secured by or related to the building.
  • Adjusted investor equity, meaning the cash originally invested, increased by a cost-of-living adjustment based on the not-seasonally-adjusted CPI-U published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
  • Other capital contributions to the project not already counted.
  • Minus all cash distributed from the project or available for distribution, including partnership management fees, guaranty fees, investor fees, and returns of capital.

The base year for the CPI adjustment is the year in which the first taxable year of the credit period ends, and any single-year CPI increase above five percent is excluded from the calculation.4eCFR. 26 CFR 1.42-18 Qualified Contracts Over fifteen years the adjustment can raise the price meaningfully. Critics of the process argue the resulting number is often high enough that preservation buyers cannot meet it, which is one reason state agencies have grown hostile to the option.

The cash distribution offset reaches further than many owners assume. It captures not just distributions of net operating income to partners but affiliate fees, certain deferred developer fee payments, and cash sitting in project accounts that isn’t contractually restricted from distribution. Owners need certified audits and federal tax returns going back to inception to run the numbers accurately, and most state agencies require an independent CPA to verify the final figure on a state-provided worksheet.

Submitting the Request

The formal request goes to the state housing credit agency. Federal regulations give agencies broad discretion over what a complete submission looks like: an agency can reject an incomplete request, demand documentation beyond the owner’s representations, require that any appraisers be state-certified generals acceptable to the agency, and charge processing fees that vary by state.4eCFR. 26 CFR 1.42-18 Qualified Contracts

The one-year marketing clock does not start until the agency deems the request complete. A deficiency can suspend the running of that period or force resubmission from scratch. An incomplete filing costs time the owner cannot get back. Whatever the agency’s submission method, keep the receipt and any written acknowledgment that the package is deemed complete. That acknowledgment date is when the clock actually starts.

The One-Year Marketing Window

Once the agency accepts a complete request, it has 365 days to find a buyer willing to pay the calculated Qualified Contract Price and continue operating the property as affordable housing through the remaining extended use period.5U.S. Department of the Treasury. Housing Crisis in Focus LIHTC Best Practices to Discourage Qualified Contracts and Keep Housing Affordable for Longer Agencies typically list the property on their websites and contact nonprofits and preservation developers.

The owner must cooperate. That means giving prospective buyers access for inspections and providing due diligence materials like rent rolls, utility records, and maintenance histories. The agency facilitates the process but does not act as a broker. Because the IRS left the procedural details to states, the experience varies. Some agencies market aggressively; others treat the year as a passive waiting period. The owner has limited influence over which approach the agency takes.

What Happens at the End of the Year

Two outcomes are possible.

If the agency presents a bona fide contract from a qualified buyer at or above the calculated price, the owner is expected to sell. The property stays in the LIHTC program under the new owner for the remainder of the extended use period. An owner who refuses to close after a qualifying buyer appears generally remains bound by the original affordability restrictions.

If no qualifying buyer surfaces within the year, the extended use period terminates. The affordability restrictions on the property are released, and the owner can move toward market-rate operations after a three-year transition. This is the outcome most owners are pursuing. One caveat matters: the termination provision does not apply to the extent more stringent requirements exist in the Extended Use Agreement or in state law.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 42 Low-Income Housing Credit Tougher controls at either level survive.

Three-Year Tenant Protections

Termination of the extended use period does not clear existing residents out. Under IRC § 42(h)(6)(E)(ii), for three years after termination the owner cannot evict or terminate the tenancy of any existing low-income tenant except for good cause, and cannot raise the gross rent on any low-income unit beyond what LIHTC would have permitted.6Internal Revenue Service. Revenue Ruling 2004-82

Good cause means legitimate lease violations: nonpayment, criminal activity, or similar serious breaches. Refusing to renew a lease because the tenant is paying below-market rent does not qualify. The rent freeze applies to existing tenants in low-income units. Vacant units and units newly leased after termination are not subject to the same limits. Once the three years expire, the owner sets rents at market and follows ordinary local landlord-tenant law. Violations during the protected window expose the owner to administrative penalties from the state agency.

Other Restrictions That Survive the Process

Two situations catch owners by surprise.

First, the Extended Use Agreement may grant a right of first refusal under IRC § 42(i)(7) to tenants, a resident management corporation, a qualified nonprofit, or a government agency to purchase the building after the compliance period.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 USC 42 Low-Income Housing Credit The statutory ROFR minimum price is the principal outstanding debt secured by the building (excluding any debt incurred in the last five years) plus federal, state, and local taxes attributable to the sale. There is no adjusted investor equity component and no CPI adjustment, so on a property where original debt has been paid down, the ROFR price can be a fraction of the Qualified Contract price. Whether the ROFR or the Qualified Contract controls depends on the specific partnership and regulatory documents, and courts have reached conflicting conclusions on when a ROFR can be exercised. Review those documents before filing.

Second, many LIHTC properties carry Project-Based Section 8 Housing Assistance Payment contracts or other federal rental assistance. Those contracts are independent of the LIHTC program and survive a Qualified Contract termination.7U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. What Happens to Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Properties at Year 15 and Beyond An owner who successfully exits LIHTC restrictions still cannot raise rents above HAP contract limits on covered units and must continue to meet HUD’s physical and management standards. A successful Qualified Contract does not deliver full market-rate flexibility if a HAP contract remains in place.

Where the Policy Is Heading

The Qualified Contract option has narrowed considerably. Treasury has stated it “strongly supports efforts undertaken by state allocating agencies to adopt policies that prioritize credits for, or limit credit allocations to, projects for which the owner agrees to waive the qualified contract option.” Dozens of states now require Qualified Contract waivers for all new LIHTC allocations.5U.S. Department of the Treasury. Housing Crisis in Focus LIHTC Best Practices to Discourage Qualified Contracts and Keep Housing Affordable for Longer States that stop short of outright waivers often use their Qualified Allocation Plans to penalize applicants (or their affiliates) who have previously requested a Qualified Contract, disadvantaging them in competitive scoring rounds. Some states offer incentives for partial waivers, such as delaying the earliest QC request date.

Owners of older projects that predate these requirements may still hold the right. Even so, contact the state agency early. Agencies have wide regulatory latitude to define completeness, charge fees, and decide how aggressively to market the property during the marketing year.4eCFR. 26 CFR 1.42-18 Qualified Contracts An agency that views the process skeptically can slow it with every tool the regulations allow.