Law 15: Insurance Fraud Penalties, Proof, and Warnings

Puerto Rico’s Law 15 insurance fraud penalties, set out in Chapter 27 of Title 26 of the Insurance Code, make it a felony to knowingly submit false information on an insurance application or claim. Conviction carries a fine of $5,000 to $10,000 per violation, a fixed prison term of three years that a court can move between two and five years depending on circumstances, and mandatory restitution of every dollar gained through the fraud.1Justia Law. Laws of Puerto Rico Title Twenty-Six 2736 – Penalty

What Law 15 Prohibits

The Insurance Code bars anyone from filing, presenting, or helping to present a false document, statement, or report to obtain an insurance policy. Knowingly doing any of those things is fraud under the Code.2Justia Law. Laws of Puerto Rico Title Twenty-Six 2719 – Reports, Documents, or False Information In practice that covers lying on an application to get a lower premium, filing a claim for a loss that never happened, inflating the value of real damage, and concealing facts the insurer would have wanted to know before issuing coverage.

A separate section of the Code reaches the opposite direction. Knowingly giving false testimony or false written information about someone else’s alleged fraudulent acts in the insurance business is also a felony with the same penalty range.3Justia Law. Laws of Puerto Rico Title Twenty-Six 2730 – False Information You cannot fabricate a claim, and you cannot fabricate an accusation against someone who filed one.

The Penalty Structure

Insurance fraud under the Code is a felony. On conviction, a court can impose a fine of no less than $5,000 and no more than $10,000 per violation, a fixed prison term of three years, or both. Aggravating circumstances push the sentence up to a maximum of five years. Extenuating circumstances pull it down to a minimum of two.1Justia Law. Laws of Puerto Rico Title Twenty-Six 2736 – Penalty

Restitution is mandatory and sits on top of any fine or prison time. Anyone who benefits financially from obtaining insurance or receiving a claim payment through fraud must pay back the full amount gained.1Justia Law. Laws of Puerto Rico Title Twenty-Six 2736 – Penalty A person who inflated a $20,000 claim by $8,000 would owe that $8,000 back even after paying the court-ordered fine and serving any prison term.

The false-information provision in Section 2730 carries the same range: $5,000 to $10,000 per violation, a three-year fixed prison term adjustable between two and five years, or both.3Justia Law. Laws of Puerto Rico Title Twenty-Six 2730 – False Information

Administrative fines from the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance operate on a separate track from criminal penalties. A single act of fraud can result in an administrative fine from the regulator and a criminal prosecution in court.

What Prosecutors Have to Prove

Two elements shape most fraud cases: that the person acted knowingly, and that the false statement was material.

Knowing Conduct

The statute requires that the person knew the information was false. This is the line between an honest paperwork mistake and a criminal act. A typo on an application or a good-faith estimate that turns out to be inaccurate does not meet the standard. The government has to show the person understood the information was false and submitted it anyway to gain something they were not entitled to. That is also where most defenses are built, because proving a defendant’s state of mind beyond a reasonable doubt is one of the harder tasks a prosecutor takes on.

Materiality

A false statement generally triggers legal consequences when it is material, meaning it would have changed the insurer’s decision to issue the policy or the rate charged. Misstating something trivial that had no bearing on the insurer’s risk assessment is different from concealing a prior claim history that would have doubled the premium. If the allegedly false statement was immaterial, the defense can argue the misrepresentation did not amount to fraud at all.

The Fraud Warning on Insurance Forms

Section 2732 of the Insurance Code requires a standardized fraud warning, commonly called the Law 15 Notice, on insurance applications and claim forms. The language tells anyone signing the document that knowingly presenting false information with the intent to defraud is a crime punishable under Puerto Rico law.4Justia Law. Laws of Puerto Rico Title Twenty-Six 2732 – Notice

Once that warning sits directly above your signature, it becomes very difficult to argue later that you did not know false statements carried criminal consequences. Treat it as more than boilerplate. The penalties behind it are real.

What Happens to the Policy Itself

When an insurer discovers a policyholder provided materially false information on an application, the insurer may seek to rescind the policy. Rescission treats the contract as if it never existed, which goes further than denying a single claim. The entire relationship is voided, and the insurer returns premiums paid, minus any amounts already paid out on legitimate claims. Whether rescission is available depends on whether the misrepresentation was material to the insurer’s original decision to issue the policy or set its premium.

For a policyholder, rescission means losing coverage retroactively. Any losses that occurred during the supposed policy period become your personal liability. Stacked with criminal penalties and mandatory restitution, a single act of fraud can produce financial consequences that last years.

How Investigations Work

The Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCS) is the primary regulator overseeing insurance fraud enforcement in Puerto Rico. The Commissioner holds broad investigative powers under the Insurance Code, including authority to compel testimony. People under investigation must appear, testify, and submit evidence when requested.5Puerto Rico Government. OCS Insurance Code Regulations – Rule 201-A-8077 Failing to respond to subpoenas or skipping scheduled meetings is itself classified as obstruction of the Commissioner’s investigative power, which can trigger its own penalties.

If the Commissioner confirms a violation, administrative fines follow under the Code’s penalty provisions. Criminal referrals move through the courts separately.

Reporting Suspected Fraud

If you suspect insurance fraud, pull your documentation together before you contact anyone. A useful file includes the policy number, the names of everyone involved, the dates of the suspicious activity, and a specific description of what you believe to be false. Copies of emails, text messages, photographs, receipts, independent repair estimates, or medical records that contradict the submitted claim strengthen the report. A written log of your interactions with adjusters or agents gives investigators a timeline.

The OCS accepts reports through its official website at ocs.pr.gov.6Oficina del Comisionado de Seguros. Oficina del Comisionado de Seguros For complaints involving misuse of public funds or government-related insurance fraud, the Office of the Inspector General accepts reports by email, through its website, or on its confidential line at 787-679-7979. Puerto Rico law protects whistleblowers against retaliation for filing these complaints.