The Jones v. Lake Michigan Credit Union overdraft settlement was a $7.5 million class action resolution, finally approved by the Washtenaw County Circuit Court on October 12, 2022, that compensated LMCU members charged overdraft fees on debit card purchases their accounts had enough money to cover at the moment of purchase. The case was filed under case number 20-000240-CK, and Lake Michigan Credit Union settled without admitting wrongdoing.
What the Case Was About
The lawsuit challenged a practice the banking industry calls “authorize positive, settle negative,” or APSN. You swipe your debit card, the credit union checks your balance, sees enough money, and approves the transaction. The purchase doesn’t leave your account immediately. In the day or two before the merchant finishes processing, other charges can clear and drain the balance. When the original purchase finally posts, the account is short, and the credit union charges an overdraft fee on a transaction that was fully funded when you made it.
The plaintiffs argued LMCU’s account agreements didn’t clearly tell members this could happen. Their theory was breach of contract: the disclosures implied overdraft fees would only hit transactions that actually lacked funds at the time they were made. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has described APSN fees as charges “consumers would not reasonably anticipate,” because the account had a sufficient available balance when the transaction was initiated.1Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Consumer Financial Protection Circular 2022-06: Unanticipated Overdraft Fee Assessment Practices
Who Was in the Settlement Class
The class covered LMCU members charged APSN-type overdraft fees during a period running roughly from early 2014 through mid-2022. The $7.5 million settlement value combined a cash fund for direct payments with forgiveness of previously assessed but uncollected overdraft fees. Court-approved attorneys’ fees and service awards for the named class representatives came out of the fund before member distributions.
An independent settlement administrator calculated individual payments based on how many qualifying fees each member had been charged during the class period. Members who had been hit with more APSN fees received larger payments.
How Payments Were Sent
Eligible members did not have to file a claim. Payments went out automatically after final approval in October 2022, either as direct deposits into active LMCU accounts or as checks mailed to the last known address on file.
What to Do If You Never Received a Payment
If you were a class member and no payment ever reached you, or you received a check and didn’t cash it, those funds may eventually be transferred to the state as unclaimed property. Every state runs an unclaimed property program, and the dormancy period before a transfer varies by state. Search your state’s unclaimed property office under your name to see whether money is being held for you.
What Class Members Gave Up
Accepting the settlement meant releasing the right to sue Lake Michigan Credit Union individually over the same overdraft fee practices. The release covers both claims a member knew about and claims they hadn’t yet discovered, as long as the conduct happened during the class period.
The deadline to opt out passed before final approval in 2022. Anyone who didn’t formally exclude themselves is bound by the settlement regardless of whether they cashed a check. This is how class action settlements generally work: doing nothing keeps you in the class, and being in the class ends your ability to bring the same claims on your own.
How Federal Overdraft Rules Fit In
Under federal Regulation E, a financial institution cannot charge overdraft fees on ATM or one-time debit card transactions unless the account holder has specifically opted in to overdraft coverage. The institution has to provide a written notice describing the service, give the consumer a reasonable chance to consent, obtain that consent, and send written confirmation that includes the right to revoke it at any time.2eCFR. 12 CFR 1005.17 – Requirements for Overdraft Services
That opt-in requirement applies only to ATM and one-time debit card transactions. It does not cover checks, recurring automatic payments, or ACH transfers. The Jones case fell squarely inside the opt-in framework because it was about debit card purchases, and the dispute was whether the opt-in form and account agreement actually explained that fees could be charged on transactions approved against a positive balance.2eCFR. 12 CFR 1005.17 – Requirements for Overdraft Services
Lake Michigan Credit Union currently charges $30 per transaction covered by its overdraft service.